Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around preparing for a career in oil refinery management as a civil engineer, particularly in the context of choosing an appropriate engineering major at Florida State University, which does not offer petroleum engineering. Participants explore various engineering disciplines and their relevance to the oil refining industry.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant expresses uncertainty about which engineering field to pursue, considering industrial, mechanical, or civil engineering as alternatives to chemical engineering, which they find unappealing.
- Another participant suggests that chemical engineering is ideal for understanding refining processes, while mechanical and electrical engineering are also relevant, particularly for the mechanical aspects of refinery operations.
- A participant with experience in refineries notes that most engineers in the field are chemical, mechanical, or electrical, with civil engineers typically working for contractors rather than directly in refineries.
- One participant indicates a preference for civil engineering due to its focus on production processes and transportation, and seeks advice on preparing for a career in that field.
- Another participant recommends researching companies that operate refineries and the architectural/engineering firms that support them, while also suggesting that the participant engage with faculty members for guidance.
- There is a mention of industrial engineering's role in creating efficient processes, which some participants find appealing.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying opinions on the best engineering discipline for a career in oil refinery management, with no consensus reached. Some favor chemical engineering for its direct relevance to refining processes, while others advocate for civil or industrial engineering based on personal interests and career goals.
Contextual Notes
Participants highlight the importance of internships and practical experience, but note a lack of opportunities in their local area, which may limit exposure to relevant fields within civil engineering.