How Can Opposite Deflections in a Magnetic Field Be Explained?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 2K views
sona1177
Messages
171
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


Consider a magnetic field in the z direction. Two particles are moving perpendicular to this magnetic field, that is, they are both moving in the x-y plane. It is observed that the particles are both deflected by the magnetic field and they are deflected in opposite directions. Which of the following scenarios can account for this behavior?
they were initially moving in the same direction, but one is uncharged False
they were initially moving in the same direction, but they are oppositely charged TRUE
they were initially moving in opposite directions, but they have the same charge False
they were initially moving in the same direction, but they have the same charge False
they were initially moving in opposite directions, but both are uncharged False
they were initially moving in opposite directions, but they are oppositely charged False

Homework Equations



what am i doing wrong? someone please, help its due in 20 mins!

The Attempt at a Solution


 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you been supplied with a meaning to "opposite directions"?
 
I fail the person who made up this question. So forfeit goes to the student.

If "opposite direction" means vxB is oppositely signed for the two particles, #2 is correct.
If "opposite direction" refers to a spatial direction, #3 is the correct answer.