How did I capture these intriguing feedback loop photos?

8 replies · 6K views · last reply
LaurieAG
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Feedback loops can be very cheap and can be modified easily by things to produce some interesting photos.

I used the attached setup to capture these images over 12 years ago and they are accurate to what you actually see on the screen within the maxed out limits of the hardware/software combination used at the time.

To make this interesting, especially as this is a physics forum, I will set forward a couple of questions below with regards to what I had to do to capture the images that I will be posting. I will post the first images and answer the question to show what I did to give you the general idea.

I invite anybody else to answer the questions or post their own feedback loop pictures and pose their own questions with regards to what you did to get the image. Note: none of these images have been modified in any way shape or form apart from the original reduction in size so please don't post modified images. Only the names have been changed to protect the innocent:wink:

(1) How did I create 2-PerfectOrb?

(2) What caused 3-Startled to become startled?

(3) (a) What happened straight after 4-DamnedSpot was captured?
(b) What happened if you did not capture 4-DamnedSpot

(4) What is the only thing altered between 5-Blue and 6-Orange?

(5) What is different between 7-Fractal, 8-Flare and all the other pictures so far?

Answers

(1) I gradually skewed 1-1-Winiverse until I had 1-2-FernShell. 2-PerfectOrb was not far away.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a camera-feedback setup: a monitor labelled Source with points A, B and C, a camera labelled Target on a stand, and a PC with video and TV cards, with yellow and red light paths and specs listed.
    1-Setup.jpg
    42.6 KB · Views: 543
  • Photo of a monitor showing a feedback loop: a nested, tilted tunnel of concentric red and white rectangles with a desktop of taskbar icons visible at the edges.
    1-1-Winiverse.jpg
    84.7 KB · Views: 554
  • Photo of a video feedback image on a monitor: a bright glowing starburst at upper left, with radiating blue-white spiral arms curving across a dark background.
    1-2-FernShell.jpg
    51.1 KB · Views: 521
Last edited:
Sorry, limit of 3
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a video monitor screen showing a pale cyan glowing disc with a blue arc to its right, with a row of small bright dots curving across the upper left against a dark background.
    2-PerfectOrb.jpg
    47.1 KB · Views: 526
  • Photo of a glowing cyan circle with a dark round spot at its centre, against a dark brown background with faint thin bright lines at the edges.
    4-DamnedSpot.jpg
    15 KB · Views: 551
  • Photo of a bright cyan glowing disc with a jagged, spiky edge on a dark background, with faint curved lines at the left, possibly a video or camera feedback display.
    3-Startled.jpg
    62.4 KB · Views: 467
And the next 2
 
Attachments
  • Blurry, horizontally streaked photo of a glowing cyan and teal blob of light on a dark brown background, with a bright curved edge at the lower left.
    5-Blue.jpg
    57.7 KB · Views: 460
  • Photo of a warm orange-red blurred field with horizontal banding and scan-line distortion, with a curved bright edge at the lower left and upper right corners.
    6-Orange.jpg
    59 KB · Views: 477
And the next pair
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a television screen showing a feedback loop image: a fractal-like pattern of branching white and dark shapes on a red-brown and blue background, with scan lines visible across the screen.
    7-Fractal.JPG
    22.2 KB · Views: 457
  • Blurry dark photo with streaks of light: a bright cyan diagonal streak on the left, a white streak at lower right, and thin pale lines running across the upper right.
    8-flare.JPG
    18.9 KB · Views: 512
Andy Resnick said:
Sheesh- first Borek, now you... I'm never going to get any work done :)

Enjoy Andy,

I call the whole series 'within 90 degrees of reality' to explain why (3) (b) is possible with this setup. Any other ideas on this anomally?

Here are some hints,

(2) If you have one you probably won't not be able to put your finger on it.

(3) (a) It's not the same as (b) but it's the same as what you get when you disturb (b).
(3) (b) Einstein predicted it, Zena had one and you too can have one if you turn your loop into a shadow trap.

(4) You are either too close and too far or too left and too right or too up and too down.

(5) If you reflect on this problem again and again at the same time you surely can not fail.

The loops hardware/software is constant, each image has one discrete distance, three discrete angles and any other optical interference is constant/fixed/, for anybody who wants to try to work out the maths behind it.

Here's another one.

(6) On reflection What part of 9-sphere is not an illusion?
 
Attachments
  • Recursive camera feedback image: a red-tinted spiral tunnel of nested, echoing bright spots receding into a dark centre, with blue streaked edges and horizontal scan-line distortion.
    9-Sphere.JPG
    14.1 KB · Views: 1,277
LaurieAG said:
Feedback loops can be very cheap and can be modified easily by things to produce some interesting photos.

I remember doing this 'back in the day', just to see what would happen. There was a little burst of lab activity because it's a feedback loop- a particularly easy to visualize feedback loop.

I had a *really* hard time replicating this with my (digital) USB camera, IIRC all I needed to do in the analog age was to play with the 'synch' dial on the monitor and the NTSC signal protocol did the rest..

This morning I was able to get something by tweaking the camera frame rate relative to the monitor refresh rate, but it wasn't much more than a vague approximation to a strobe light.
 
Hi Andy,

Andy Resnick said:
This morning I was able to get something by tweaking the camera frame rate relative to the monitor refresh rate, but it wasn't much more than a vague approximation to a strobe light.

I think the ratio of the lag in the old PC hardware has to be similar to capture images like these, that's why I posted the setup specs. I have tried to do similar things on newer hardware but I couldn't replicate the images because the resolution, capture speed, monitor size, tv/video card lag was different and the on screen window had an ugly thick skin around it.

I'll let you know how the (3) images were generated after you've had a go. (3) (b) is an amazing sight to behold so, if you can find any, you can post astronomical images of (3) (b) on this thread as well. Cheers.
 
Some answers.
LaurieAG said:
(2) If you have one you probably won't not be able to put your finger on it.
Just put your finger on the edge of 2 PerfectOrb on the screen and hold it there to distort the image as shown.