How Do I Determine (S) vs. (R) Configuration in Cyclopentanediol?

2 replies · 5K views · last reply
Chiborino
Messages
19
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Skeletal structure of cyclopentane-1,2-diol drawn as a five-membered ring, with an OH on the upper-left carbon on a bold wedge and an OH on the right carbon on a hashed bond.

A question on a pretest asks me to name this. I know it's either (1R,2R) or (1S,2S)1,2-Cyclopentanediol because the OH's are facing in opposite directions, but I'm not sure how to figure out if the OH's are S or R



2. The attempt at a solution
I somewhat have an understanding of the concept, but I'm not entirely sure how to do it with a ring structure.

To be more specific, I'm confused about how to set up the determination of S vs. R. I know I can draw the top carbon either one of these two ways:
Two Fischer projections side by side, labelled R and S, each with a central carbon bearing OH and H and a CH2 chain; priority letters a, b, c, d are marked and red arrows trace the path from c to b to a.

I'm just not sure about how to figure out which one is actually what's being depicted
 
Last edited:
Skeletal structure of cyclopentane-1,2-diol drawn as a five-membered ring, with OH on the top carbon on a solid wedge and OH on the lower right carbon on a hashed wedge.

Since the carbon atoms are all depicted in the same plane, the c-c bonds also lie within the same plane. That means that of the two remaining bonds on each carbon atom, one is projecting toward the viewer (dark wedge or invisible H) and the other is projecting away from the viewer (dashed wedge or invisible H). This should be sufficient for you to construct a model.

Two Fischer projections of a cyclopentanediol-type ring drawn as cross shapes, labelled R on the left and S on the right, with red arcs tracing the path from a to b to c; labels a, b, c and d shown in boxes.


Remember that in this representation, the vertical bonds are actually projecting away from the viewer, and the horizontal bonds are projecting toward the viewer.

If you're trying to visualize this rather than using an actual model, think of rolling the molecule away from you until you're looking at it edge-on, with the carbon formerly at the top now pointing away from you. The carbon at the top of the ring is now on the far side of the molecule, the C-C bonds point to the left and right (but the rotation moves them from "down" to "toward me"), the C-H bond points down and away, and the C-O bond points up and away.
 
Last edited:
PhaseShifter said:
Skeletal structure of cyclopentane-1,2-diol drawn as a five-membered ring, with an OH group on the top-left carbon on a wedge bond and an OH group on the lower-right carbon on a hashed bond.

Since the carbon atoms are all depicted in the same plane, the c-c bonds also lie within the same plane. That means that of the two remaining bonds on each carbon atom, one is projecting toward the viewer (dark wedge or invisible H) and the other is projecting away from the viewer (dashed wedge or invisible H). This should be sufficient for you to construct a model.




Two Fischer projection diagrams labelled R and S, each with groups labelled a, b, c and d and a red arrow tracing the sequence from c to b to a; the left shows OH at top, H at bottom, CH2 on the left, and a CH-OH group on the right.


Remember that in this representation, the vertical bonds are actually projecting away from the viewer, and the horizontal bonds are projecting toward the viewer.

If you're trying to visualize this rather than using an actual model, think of rolling the molecule away from you until you're looking at it edge-on, with the carbon formerly at the top now pointing away from you. The carbon at the top of the ring is now on the far side of the molecule, the C-C bonds point to the left and right (but the rotation moves them from "down" to "toward me"), the C-H bond points down and away, and the C-O bond points up and away.

So then, rolling it away from me would put the OH on top, and that would mean that it's the (1R,2R)-1,2-cyclopentanediol.

Thanks a lot. :D