How Do You Calculate Neutron Wavelength?

14 replies · 2K views · last reply
jjson775
Messages
112
Reaction score
26
Homework Statement
Show that the wavelength of a neutron is (2.86x10-11/√K)m where K is the kinetic energy in electron volts.
Relevant Equations
λ=h/mv
λ^2=h^2/m^2v^2
=h^2/2/(m^2v^2/2)
=h^2/2/(Km)
=h^2/2Km
 
Is there a question here ?

As an urgent hint: use brackets where necessary !
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
BvU said:
Is there a question here ?

As an urgent hint: use brackets where necessary !
There are 2 brackets missing in the homework statement. They look OK to me in the attempted solution. I can't get to the answer (λ in terms of K and m) from my last line. m should be in the numerator.
 
No, numerator is correct. Actually, when I looked again at the homework statement, the brackets are OK.
 
jjson775 said:
No, numerator is correct. Actually, when I looked again at the homework statement, the brackets are OK.
The mass in the numerator is not correct.
##K=\dfrac{p^2}{2m}~\Rightarrow~p=\sqrt{2mK}##.

##\lambda=\dfrac{h}{p}=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}.##
 
m is shown in the numerator in the textbook. See attached file.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation: 'show that' lambda = 2.86 x 10^-11 m divided by the square root of K_n, followed by lambda^2 = h^2/(m^2 v^2) = (h^2/2)/(m^2 v^2/2) = h^2/(2Km), giving lambda = h/sqrt(2Km) with question marks.
    DFCC8CA5-C66A-435C-A62D-78FD808F98E0.png
    17.7 KB · Views: 201
See Problem 3
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a printed textbook page, Section 41.1 The Double-Slit Experiment Revisited, with numbered problems 1 to 5 and an equation for neutron wavelength, lambda = 2.86 × 10^-11 / sqrt(K_n) m.
    7B238C36-30C8-4F9F-81B1-9BA3605D85B3.jpeg
    80.9 KB · Views: 183
That "m" stands for "meters" not "mass". In other words, if you enter a number for the kinetic energy in electron volts, take the square root and divide the result into 2.86 x 10-11, the result will be in meters. I dislike mixed unit formulas of this kind exactly because of the confusion they sow as we have seen in this case.

Do you know how to proceed now?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU
jjson775 said:
See Problem 3
The variable ##m## is usually typeset in an italic font whereas the unit m is not.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jjson775
vela said:
The variable ##m## is usually typeset in an italic font whereas the unit m is not.
Unfortunately the textbook page where the formula appears was posted a few replies after the confusion had already set in.
 
I am actually past this point in the book and knew I was hung up on something silly with this problem, which was the case. I mixed up the m for mass with meters. A mental block. I am a retired engineer, 78 years old, seeing modern physics for the first time. Past special relativity and now in QM. Thanks.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU and kuruman
jjson775 said:
I am actually past this point in the book and knew I was hung up on something silly with this problem, which was the case. I mixed up the m for mass with meters. A mental block. I am a retired engineer, 78 years old, seeing modern physics for the first time. Past special relativity and now in QM. Thanks.
Good luck with your endeavor. We are here to help.