How Does a Rain Catchment System Affect Water Levels in a Tank?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
4 replies · 3K views
Physiogista
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
I am volunteering at an orphanage in Guatemala. There is no well, and the city water is a relatively expensive. I would like to install a rain catchment system on our roof for use in the outhouse bathroom and garden. I've diagrammed it and attached the image.

My question is this: Will the water tank completely fill up, or will the water level in the water tank stay at the water level of the red pipe? My education says that the rain will fill up the very bottom of the tank, then the flat part of the red pipe, and then continue to fill the tank and up the red pipe in such a way that the respective water levels are equal. However, common sense seems to be saying that the tank will not fill up past the level of the flat red pipe section because the water has to "push" its way up the tank.

Will this system work? Is my common sense concern reflective of reality?
 

Attachments

  • Water flow question.jpg
    Water flow question.jpg
    17.2 KB · Views: 588
Engineering news on Phys.org
The vertical part of the red pipe would have to have more volume then the tank for this to work. I am no expert, but I would place the red pipe at the top of the tank.
 
Physiogista said:
My question is this: Will the water tank completely fill up, or will the water level in the water tank stay at the water level of the red pipe? My education says that the rain will fill up the very bottom of the tank, then the flat part of the red pipe, and then continue to fill the tank and up the red pipe in such a way that the respective water levels are equal.
Yes that is correct. Assuming the top of the tank has a hole somewhere the tank can fill to the level of the red pipe inlet. ie the gutter height.
leaks are twice as likely as a top filled tank and the pipe may be more vulnerable to damage on the ground, A stray spade strike and the tank empties.

Why can't you go overhead? A hose tied to an overhead rope/cable strung between the house and tank works. Depending on catchment size, rain fall, flow rate structure strength, span length etc of course.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Brent White
Welcome to PF.
The red pipe and tank here form what is termed an “inverted siphon”.
The top of the tank must have a small air vent.
Place a stop valve at the tank where the red pipe attaches so you can service the red pipe without draining the tank.
The tank only needs one drain/fill hole, the brown pipe can come from a 'T' in the red pipe.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Jeff Rosenbury and Redbelly98
Thank you all!