How Does Twin Motion Affect Cart Direction?

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
whoareyou
Messages
162
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement



Text-based physics multiple-choice problem about identical twins on a rail car, with options A to D asking how the car moves after both twins jump off.


The Attempt at a Solution



My first attempt was that since one of the twins runs east at top speed (with both masses) then the cart moves west and then he jumps off. Then after the second twin runs with the same speed west, the cart (with only one mass this time and the same speed) would move east, and he'd jump off. So I decided that B should be the answer. Is that correct?
 
I know my intuition isn't good for this one! Definitely worth working out. Beware of the changing mass and the difficult choices for frame of reference.
 
whoareyou said:

Homework Statement



Printed multiple-choice physics problem about two identical twins on a rail car running in opposite directions and jumping off the ends, with options A to D on how the car moves afterward.


The Attempt at a Solution



My first attempt was that since one of the twins runs east at top speed (with both masses) then the cart moves west and then he jumps off. Then after the second twin runs with the same speed west, the cart (with only one mass this time and the same speed) would move east, and he'd jump off. So I decided that B should be the answer. Is that correct?

I think that is the correct answer, but can you articulate why?