How Fast Must a Person Run to Catch a Ball Dropped from a Building?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a ball being thrown upward from a building and a person running on the ground attempting to catch it. The discussion centers around kinematics and the calculations necessary to determine the average speed required for the person to catch the ball at the bottom of the building.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster attempts to calculate the time the ball spends in the air and subsequently the average speed needed for the person to catch it. Some participants question the need to add times from different phases of the ball's motion, suggesting that the calculations for upward and downward motion may already be accounted for in the displacement formula used.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the calculations presented, providing feedback on the correctness of the methods used. Some guidance has been offered regarding the interpretation of the equations and the setup of the problem, but there is no explicit consensus on the correct approach or final answer.

Contextual Notes

There are indications of confusion regarding the signs used in the equations, particularly concerning the direction of acceleration due to gravity and the initial velocity of the camera in a related question. Participants are also exploring additional problems related to motion and acceleration, indicating a broader context of learning and inquiry.

ccgrad05x2
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
A ball is thrown upward from the top of a 25.4-m-tall building. The ball's initial speed is 12 m/s. At the same instant, a person is running on the ground at a distance of 32.0 m from the building. What must be the average speed of the person if he is to catch the ball at the bottom of the building?

This problem will use the kinematics equations.

Here is what I have so far:

First, I will want to determine the time that the ball will spend in the air. Then, I can divide the distance by the time and that will give me the average speed of the person.

First, I must account for the time the ball will spend going up after being thrown. I calculated this to be:

V = Vinitial + at
0 = 12.0 + (-9.80xt)
t- 1.22449

I can then multiply this number by 2 to account for the ball coming back down to the "top of the building" So far, total time is 2.44898.

Now I must account for the time the ball is falling down the 25.4 m.

Using this formula: displacement = vinitialt+ .5at^2
-25.4 = 12.0t + .5(-9.8)t^2
0 = .4.9t2 +12.0t + 25.4
I solved for this, and found the time to be 3.80965 seconds.

That would give me a total time of 3.80965 + 2.44898 = 6.25863

Then, Avg Speed = Distance/Time = 32.0/6.25863 = 5.11924 m/s

This answer is not correct though, and I am having trouble figuring out what I am missing.

Thanks for the help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
ccgrad05x2 said:
Using this formula: displacement = vinitialt+ .5at^2
-25.4 = 12.0t + .5(-9.8)t^2
0 = .4.9t2 +12.0t + 25.4
I solved for this, and found the time to be 3.80965 seconds.
This bit is correct. There is no need to add on the other times you calculated, this calculation takes both the upward and downward motion into account.
 
Oh, I see now. Thanks so much for the help.

If you do not mind, I have another two questions that I would really appreciate someone answering if they had the time.

A hot-air balloon has just lifted off and is rising at the constant rate of 2.4 m/s. Suddenly one of the passengers realizes she has left her camera on the ground. A friend picks it up and tosses it straight upward. If the passenger is 1.4 m above her friend when the camera is tossed, what is the minimum initial speed of the camera if it is to just reach the passenger?


So, the first thing I thought I should do was calculate the distance the balloon and camera would be traveling.

The balloon would have been:
d = vinitialt + .5at^2
d = 2.4t

Now, the distance traveled by the camera would be:
d + 1.4 = 0(t) + .5(9.8)t^2
So, if i substitute for d, I can get thsi equation
2.4t + 1.4 = 0(t) + 4.9t^2
0 = 4.9t^2-2.4t-1.4

Solving for t gave me the value of 0.83285.

Now, to find the initial speed, I know that
a= (vfinal-vinitial)/t

Therefore,
-9.8 = 0-vinital/.83285

v initial would then equal 8.16193 m/s but this isn't correct. I am thinking that I might have mixed up a sign somewhere maybe?

Also, this I am sure is a simple question, but this is my first time with physics and I just cannot get anything going that is correct.

So, if I am traveling at 30m/s and want to pass a truck, in order to do that I need to cover 36m, and my acceleration is 2.7 m/s^2, what formula can I use.

I had thought this:

36 = 30(t) + .5(2.7)t^2
36 = 30t + 1.35t^2
1.35t^2 + 30t - 36 = 0
t=1.1414 which is not.

I am getting hung up on the fact that I am not acclerating from zero. I guess I need to now how to account for the fact that I am already traveling at a speed of 30m/s.

Thanks again
 
ccgrad05x2 said:
So, if I am traveling at 30m/s and want to pass a truck, in order to do that I need to cover 36m, and my acceleration is 2.7 m/s^2, what formula can I use.

I had thought this:

36 = 30(t) + .5(2.7)t^2
36 = 30t + 1.35t^2
1.35t^2 + 30t - 36 = 0
t=1.1414 which is not.

I am getting hung up on the fact that I am not acclerating from zero. I guess I need to now how to account for the fact that I am already traveling at a speed of 30m/s.

You are taking it into account. That's what the term in red is for. Can you give us the exact problem statement?
 
Last edited:
ccgrad05x2 said:
.


Now, the distance traveled by the camera would be:
d + 1.4 = 0(t) + .5(9.8)t^2

If you are trying to figure out the initial speed of the camera, why have you set it to zero here?

Also, the acceleration due to gravity is downward. You have it positive here, but you're using a coordinate system with a positive upward convention.
 
Cepheid,

Thank you for your responses. The exact question for your first reply was:

A car is behind a truck going 30.0 m/s on the highway. The driver looks for an opportunity to pass, guessing that his car can accelerate at 2.7 m/s2, and he gauges that he has to cover the 16.0 m length of the truck, plus 10 m clear room at the rear of the truck and 10 m more at the front of it. In the oncoming lane, he sees a car approaching, probably traveling at the speed limit of 25 m/s. He estimates that the car is about 500.0 m away.
How long does it take the driver to complete the pass?

If x1 is the position of the driver, and x2 is the position of the oncoming car, what would be the value of separation distance (x2 - x1) at the end of a successful pass?
After I know how long it will take, I will be able to calulate the distance the second car would have traveled. Then, from that number, I was planning on substituing the 36m the original truck would have gone.

c) What would be the driver's speed at the end of the pass?


With regards to your second reply, the d + 1.4 = 0(t) + .5(9.8)t^2 was set at zero as I saw that being the time when the two distances the camera and balloon would have traveled would have been equal and therefore the zero represents the final velocity of the camera ( as it just barely made it into the person's hands) From this, I was planning on backtracking and then obtaining the initial velocity after I knew the time until the distances were equal.

Thanks.
 
So, when i posted my answer to the following equation
A hot-air balloon has just lifted off and is rising at the constant rate of 2.4 m/s. Suddenly one of the passengers realizes she has left her camera on the ground. A friend picks it up and tosses it straight upward. If the passenger is 1.4 m above her friend when the camera is tossed, what is the minimum initial speed of the camera if it is to just reach the passenger?


So, the first thing I thought I should do was calculate the distance the balloon and camera would be traveling.

The balloon would have been:
d = vinitialt + .5at^2
d = 2.4t

Now, the distance traveled by the camera would be:
d + 1.4 = 0(t) + .5(9.8)t^2
So, if i substitute for d, I can get thsi equation
2.4t + 1.4 = 0(t) + 4.9t^2
0 = 4.9t^2-2.4t-1.4

Solving for t gave me the value of 0.83285.

Now, to find the initial speed, I know that
a= (vfinal-vinitial)/t

Therefore,
-9.8 = 0-vinital/.83285

v initial would then equal 8.16193 m/s but this isn't correct. I am thinking that I might have mixed up a sign somewhere maybe?

the 8.16193 answer I was told was off by orders of magnitude. I understand an order of magnitue of 1 is like from 1 going to 10 but do not understand how it applys to this problem
 
ccgrad05x2 said:
Now, the distance traveled by the camera would be:
d + 1.4 = 0(t) + .5(9.8)t^2

Again, you still haven't answered my question. Why have you set the initial velocity to zero (highlighted in RED), when this is what you are trying to solve for? In other words, if d(t) is the distance of the camera above the person as a function of time, then

[tex]d(t) = v_0t + \frac{1}{2}at^2[/tex]

where [itex]v_0[/itex] is the initial velocity, the quantity you are trying to solve for. You have set it to zero, which makes no sense!

Also, (another thing I pointed out before), the acceleration is negative.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
17K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
6K