How has computer power impacted the lives of those who cannot afford technology?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wolram
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Computer Power
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the impact of computer power on individuals who cannot afford technology, highlighting both benefits and drawbacks. Participants argue that while advancements in computing have significantly improved scientific understanding and created job opportunities, they have also contributed to economic disparity and a decline in essential skills among the underprivileged. Key examples include the use of supercomputers for modeling astronomical phenomena and the rise of IT jobs in countries like India, which provide economic benefits but also raise questions about accessibility and equity in technology.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of supercomputing and its applications in scientific research.
  • Familiarity with CAD/CAM technologies and their role in product design.
  • Knowledge of economic principles related to technology and job markets.
  • Awareness of global disparities in technology access and education.
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the role of supercomputers in astrophysics and their contributions to our understanding of the universe.
  • Explore the impact of CAD/CAM technologies on manufacturing and design processes.
  • Investigate the growth of the IT industry in India and its implications for global job markets.
  • Examine the effects of technology on essential skills and economic mobility among low-income populations.
USEFUL FOR

This discussion is beneficial for sociologists, economists, educators, and technology advocates interested in the intersection of technology, education, and economic disparity. It provides insights into how advancements in computing can both improve and hinder the lives of those without access to technology.

wolram
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
Messages
4,410
Reaction score
551
I am a fan of computers and the advancement of computer power , computer power, (calculations per sec) has improved life for the privileged (any one that can afford technology) but how much has computer power improved the life of those that can not.

And how has computer power increased our knowledge of the universe?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
You don't have to own a computer to benefit from it.
 
jimmysnyder said:
You don't have to own a computer to benefit from it.


I own a computer, and i learn stuff every day, but how doe's that help people that can not afford technology, how doe's the ability to do millions of calculations per second improve our knowledge of the universe?
 
Such things as modeling astronomical phenomena, potential drug actions, CAD/CAM development of new technologies...
 
Maybe it's decreased their quality of life:

Sally is a cashier at a store, as such, she can count basic change out, but the rest of her job concerns none of the addition, subtraction, or multiplication that a cashier traditionally would have known. She only needs to know how to scan objects, not do basic math... then as a result of that and other society influences (the credit card, the TV, etc.), she loses her remaining math skills, can't do her own taxes (pay someone to do them or take free services), and can't balance her checkbook (in fact, she even wonders: what is a checkbook?).

As a result, Sally spirals into dept and eventually loses her home, her job, and become a number in the growing computer database on the unemployed. Hence, she and her kids become fodder for the computer models of the economists. why did the family finances fail? Oh... in addition to not knowing how to live within their means, Dad's in jail because he robbed the electronics store down the street from the grocery where Sally worked.

Joy. what a pretty picture.

Note however: Sally does know more about how our nation and planet seems to violate entropy and create economic disparity. Hopefully there's life elsewhere reaching a more homogenized state.
 
Just let me finish working on this Terminator, and I'll answer your question.
 
Danger said:
Such things as modeling astronomical phenomena, potential drug actions, CAD/CAM development of new technologies...


Modeling but not making them real, how many models end up in the bin? AFAIK computers have not advanced past A Einstein.
 
physics girl phd, raises a good point, the one that holds the best algorithm will wield the power to the detriment of the mass.
 
CAD/CAM was a great example: you owe the design of every electronc or mechanical thing you own to it. You're also defining "computer" much too tightly. Every car has a pretty sophisticated computer on it, for example. Every CD player, dvd player, all tv broadcasts, etc. The food you eat was genetically engineered with the aid of computers.

There are very few people on Earth who'se lives have not been improved by comptuers.
 
  • #10
wolram said:
I own a computer, and i learn stuff every day, but how doe's that help people that can not afford technology, how doe's the ability to do millions of calculations per second improve our knowledge of the universe?
Does anyone benefit from the stuff you learn other than you?
 
  • #11
jimmysnyder said:
Does anyone benefit from the stuff you learn other than you?

Yes, because I didn't knock them over the head today to get gas money.
 
  • #12
Joskoplas said:
Yes, because I didn't knock them over the head today to get gas money.
There you have it wolram, in a nutshell. Joskoplas takes time out from his busy day to look up sports scores on the internets, finds out that he won $20 in the office pool and some poor computer illiterate gas pump jocky saves money on aspirin. Benefit.
 
  • #13
russ_watters said:
CAD/CAM was a great example: you owe the design of every electronc or mechanical thing you own to it. You're also defining "computer" much too tightly. Every car has a pretty sophisticated computer on it, for example. Every CD player, dvd player, all tv broadcasts, etc. The food you eat was genetically engineered with the aid of computers.

There are very few people on Earth who'se lives have not been improved by comptuers.


Cd players, cars, this is exactly what i mean, THESE THINGS ARE TECHNOLODGY things that not every one can afford.
As yet no one has given any evidence of how computer power has improved our understanding of the universe.
 
  • #14
wolram said:
As yet no one has given any evidence of how computer power has improved our understanding of the universe.

I believe that I have. You seem to have misunderstood my meaning of the word 'modeling'. Supercomputers are routinely used to model (simulate) what goes on within stars and even entire galaxies. Models are also used to test theories directly related to the eventual realization of fusion reactors, supersonic aircraft, bioengineering, and dozens of other fields that couldn't possibly be done by any number of mathematicians using pencils and paper.
 
  • #15
Danger said:
I believe that I have. You seem to have misunderstood my meaning of the word 'modeling'. Supercomputers are routinely used to model (simulate) what goes on within stars and even entire galaxies. Models are also used to test theories directly related to the eventual realization of fusion reactors, supersonic aircraft, bioengineering, and dozens of other fields that couldn't possibly be done by any number of mathematicians using pencils and paper.


No misunderstanding Danger, it seems that every one wants to blatantly over look
what i am saying.

1, how has computer power increased our knowledge of the universe.
2 How has computer power helped those that can not afford technology.
 
  • #16
wolram said:
1, how has computer power increased our knowledge of the universe.
Pretty much all observational astronomy relies on computer data crunching, stellar structure relies on hydrocodes and galaxy formation on N body models. I don't know ho wmuch fundamental particle physics releis on modelling but all the experimental stuff certainly does.

2 How has computer power helped those that can not afford technology.
The cost of doing business reductions allows ordinary people to have bank accounts and telephones - which 50years ago they couldn't simply because the cost of the paperwork to administer them was too high for poor customers to be profitable.
There are kids in India making a very nice living as programmers, next year it will be poor kids in china and the decade after africa.
 
  • #17
wolram said:
physics girl phd, raises a good point, the one that holds the best algorithm will wield the power to the detriment of the mass.

but at some point, an angry mob of torch-wielding villagers will attack your castle.

you'd better have self-replicating/maintaining machines by that point if you hope to carry on after killing them.
 
  • #18
mgb_phys said:
Pretty much all observational astronomy relies on computer data crunching, stellar structure relies on hydrocodes and galaxy formation on N body models. I don't know ho wmuch fundamental particle physics releis on modelling but all the experimental stuff certainly does.


(Please note the difference from understanding the problem , to understanding the whole)

.

The cost of doing business reductions allows ordinary people to have bank accounts and telephones - which 50years ago they couldn't simply because the cost of the paperwork to administer them was too high for poor customers to be profitable.
There are kids in India making a very nice living as programmers, next year it will be poor kids in china and the decade after africa.


Some kids in India ?
 
  • #19
wolram said:
Some kids in India ?

There has been a huge boom in IT jobs in India in the last 5-10years. India because it has good schools and they speak English,

It benefits everyone-
Indian gets a new rich middle class with well paid jobs
US companies get software developed for 1/4 the cost of paying american programmers
American students can avoid having to study nasty hard science subjects and become real estate agents and advertising executives instead.
And consultants making a killing fixing projects that are a disaster beause they were handed off to the cheapest offshore bidder with no proper management!
 
Last edited:
  • #20
in india, you can probably make a decent living off of no more than adsense and referrals. half the people spamming blogs don't seem to speak english, either.
 
  • #21
mgb_phys said:
There has been a huge boom in IT jobs in India in the last 5-10years. India beause it has good schools and they speak English,

It benefits everyone-
Indian gets a new rich middle class with well paid jobs
US companies get software developed for 1/4 the cost of paying american programmers
American students can avoid having to study nasty hard science subjects and become real estate dealers and advertising executives instead.
And onsultants making a killing fixing projects that are a disaster beause they were handed off to the cheapest offshore bidder with no proper management!

So now we descend to trivia? India is quite well off compared to some countries.

i do not intend to knock science, i have the ultimate respect for it, all i am asking is
(how has computer power increased our knowledge) re guarding the universe, and how has it bettered the life of the majority who can not afford technology.
 
  • #22
Computers have allowed researchers access to large public databases. My collaborators and I are currently working on the second of what will be a series of papers on the properties of interacting galaxies. We chose galaxies of the M-51 type to restrict membership. I would view survey images from Nasa's IRSA database (B&W Schmidt telescope images in three bands), select candidates for inclusion by visual appearance, and email Ari (Finland) and Dave (New York) with my impressions, including how the pairs should be categorized. Ari would review the images and if he agreed, the pairs were categorized at that time, If there was disagreement or only conditional approval, we would hand the vetted list (via email) to Dave, who would act as an arbiter/tie-breaker. After the galaxy pairs were categorized, Ari would get their data (minor/major axes, position data, apparent recessional velocities, and MANY more) from Nasa's NED database and populate the spreadsheets with that data. It took us well over 2 years, and many thousands of potential candidates, many of them several times, plus one revision of the draft requested by the referees. The paper was submitted electronically, presented to subscribers through Springer's early electronic publishing system, and finally published in their print journal Astrophysics and Space Sciences. NONE of this would have been possible without computers and the Internet, the most important component of which was that the three of us found each other on-line with similar research interests. It can be argued (and rightfully so) that even a peer-reviewed paper on galaxy interactions adds little to our knowledge of the universe as a whole, but with a LOT of people nibbling around at the edges of mundane problems like this, we might achieve more than you'd expect.
 
  • #23
Sorry - I thought you were questioning that India had an IT industry,
The big change brought about by computers is the disconnection between raw materials and the job.
The first steel plants were on top of the coal and iron ore, the shipyards where these were near a river. This limited the jobs available - there aren't many shipbuilding jobs in Manitoba or many wheat farming jobs on the Clyde.

Computers allow the job to be wherever there are educated people - this makes the world a lot flatter which is going to have huge consequences for politics and economies. A bit larger than the effects of computer games.

It's not quite there yet but the big effect computers are going to have in the next decade is being able to model proteins. This will allow drugs to actually be designed rather than the current system of - try lots of compounds and see who gets better, it's worked for the last 4000years but it is time medicine became a science.
 
  • #24
Communication;
Most people in India now have cell-phones. A large part of that whole continent has simply skipped over the installment of telephone lines because cell-phones made them obsolete before they ever arrived. These cell-phones, and their networks, were modeled on, and are operated by, computers. Without the computers that operate them, this new method of communication would be impossible, and without the computers that modeled them, they would be so expensive that only the "privileged" could afford them.

Transportation;
Most people in the "3rd World" get around on mopeds. These mopeds are produced in factories that use computerized machinery and automated systems. Without these systems, mopeds would belong only to the privileged.

Likewise, if a person with a low income (from a global perspective) buys groceries to feed his familly, those groceries would be more expensive if not for the computers used in agriculture (for modelling crop-yields, controlling storage environments, predicting fertilizer/pesticide requirements, etc.). Conversely, if a person is so poor that he cannot buy groceries from a store, and must get by on subsistence farming, he probably uses metal tools to farm. These tools are made of refined metals that are forged with the aid of computer controlls without which their manufacture would make them prohibitively expensive, and the subsistence farmers of the world would have to fashion old-style, pre-Egyptian plows out of sharpened wooden sticks.

If AIDS prevention measures have had any effect in South Africa, if CARE packages arrive in the right place at the right time to prevent tens of thousands from starving to death in Ethiopia, if vaccination forestalls the suffereing and death of millions every year around the globe, computers have been beneficial to those people (most of whom will never own a computer).

But due to the constant and rapid advances in computer tech, many people who would never own a computer without these advances will. When I was in West Africa in the early '90s, we built a school and a small medicall fecility for a town that could not afford to sustain these institutions on their own. Among the school supplies were several old desktop computers. The children who attend this school will have access to the most advanced information in the world; the same information available to anyone, anywhere.

By US standards (even then), these machines were archaic. If you tried to give one to your teenage child here, they would wine about how slow it was. Why is that? It is because they were more than ten years old and, as a direct result of computer advancement being so rapid, they had become something the privileged no longer have use for. They were items to be thrown away, if some charitable organization hadn't been available to take them to the "less priveleged."

And that is the main benefit; as the cutting edge, state-of-the-art, gets more and more advanced, the things that are way out of reach for most people today will become attainable tomorrow, and universally possessed by even the poorest people, the day after tomorrow.

Wow, I went on a lot longer than I intended, there. But the list of benefits (for those who can't obtain the latest tech) is very long.
 
  • #25
wolram said:
And how has computer power increased our knowledge of the universe?

The computer tells me that somewhere in the universe there is an individual called wolram. Without the computer I probably would have not known this.
 
  • #26
Thanks Lurch, Turbo.

Turbo, you explain study not knowledge, i say again or restate, how has computer power increased our knowledge since say A Einstein.
Lurch i have seen the crap machinery exported to India, and i say again India is quite well off,
India runs on cast offs and to a lesser extent computers, (call centers any one).
 
  • #27
physics girl phd said:
Maybe it's decreased their quality of life:

Sally is a cashier at a store, as such, she can count basic change out, but the rest of her job concerns none of the addition, subtraction, or multiplication that a cashier traditionally would have known. She only needs to know how to scan objects, not do basic math... then as a result of that and other society influences (the credit card, the TV, etc.), she loses her remaining math skills, can't do her own taxes (pay someone to do them or take free services), and can't balance her checkbook (in fact, she even wonders: what is a checkbook?).

I'm an engineer and I can't do basic math. I have a computer and matlab. There are better things to worry about than multiplication tables and adding/subtracting.

I don't do my own taxes. I don't think most people do either. Who balances a checkbook? I go online and it tells me.

As a result, Sally spirals into dept and eventually loses her home, her job, and become a number in the growing computer database on the unemployed. Hence, she and her kids become fodder for the computer models of the economists. why did the family finances fail? Oh... in addition to not knowing how to live within their means, Dad's in jail because he robbed the electronics store down the street from the grocery where Sally worked.

Joy. what a pretty picture.

Note however: Sally does know more about how our nation and planet seems to violate entropy and create economic disparity. Hopefully there's life elsewhere reaching a more homogenized state.

I think this is a silly generalization.
 
  • #28
Lurch i have seen the crap machinery exported to India, and i say again India is quite well off,
India runs on cast offs and to a lesser extent computers, (call centers any one).
But they wouldn't be if there were no cast-offs. And besides, I was mostly talking about West Africa and Ethiopia and Somalia and such places.

I also see that like ten people posted while I was typing. Man, I'm slow without my Dragon!
 
  • #29
Without the Internet, I wouldn't know even a single percent of everything I do now about developing nations and their situations. So, while this technology hasn't necessarily touched many of them directly, it at least broadens the knowledge of others, like me, so I may act in whatever capacity I pursue. At the minimum, my education may benefit them by helping me make more informed decisions at the voting booth.

Most importantly, I get to communicate with people around the world directly, such as at this very site. The old pen pal through snail mail would never have gotten me this far.
 
  • #30
OAQfirst said:
Without the Internet, I wouldn't know even a single percent of everything I do now about developing nations and their situations. So, while this technology hasn't necessarily touched many of them directly, it at least broadens the knowledge of others, like me, so I may act in whatever capacity I pursue. At the minimum, my education may benefit them by helping me make more informed decisions at the voting booth.

Most importantly, I get to communicate with people around the world directly, such as at this very site. The old pen pal through snail mail would never have gotten me this far.


The Internet is a glorified telephone, it is the number crunchers i am talking about, and no one wants to really address, if computer power increased over night by 100 fold how would it help our knowledge of the universe, and the people that can not afford technology?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
14K
Replies
2
Views
924
Replies
29
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
645