How to Calculate the Distance Between Mars and Earth?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter MMS
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Earth Mars
12 replies · 3K views · last reply
MMS
Messages
146
Reaction score
4
Hi guys,

There are many calculators and applications out there that can calculate you the distance between Earth and Mars at every time, but I'm trying to find the actual function that gives me so and draw the path of it.

My objective is finding the distance R (and Phi of t), as shown below, as a function of time.
I'm trying to sort out some geometry here but I keep getting functions that are implicit (with R and Phi).

Any ideas how to find R and Phi and as a function of time each explicitly?

Diagram of two circular orbits about a central sun, with a red planet on the outer dashed circle and a green planet on the inner one, showing radii r2 and r1, angles theta2 and theta1, separation R and angle phi.
 
I don't do orbital mechanics myself, but I know that it's a lot more complex than you seem to think. To start with, both orbits are elliptical, not circular, and of course their speeds are different.
Here's a starting point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_mechanics
 
What is phi supposed to represent?

You can resolve the polar coordinates into cartesian coordinates, and then easily determine the distance.

Chet
 
Danger said:
I don't do orbital mechanics myself, but I know that it's a lot more complex than you seem to think. To start with, both orbits are elliptical, not circular, and of course their speeds are different.
Here's a starting point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_mechanics

Approximately speaking, they're circular. I can tell you both their time periods as well (Kepler's 3rd law).

Chestermiller said:
What is phi supposed to represent?

You can resolve the polar coordinates into cartesian coordinates, and then easily determine the distance.

Chet

It's simply the angle that is defined in the image.
 
MMS said:
By the way, the path that I'm trying to draw (in some program of course) is the following:
Okay, sorry. I thought that you meant something that you could use to programme a spacecraft trajectory.
 
MMS said:
It's simply the angle that is defined in the image.
You have a line drawn from Mars to Earth that is also tangent to Earth's orbit. I hope you realize that you can't generally do this.

Chet
 
Chestermiller said:
You have a line drawn from Mars to Earth that is also tangent to Earth's orbit. I hope you realize that you can't generally do this.

Chet

In that specific time it is shown to be tangent (as if someone snapped a picture at that time). Of course, it isn't the general case which I'm looking for.
 
Danger said:
Okay, sorry. I thought that you meant something that you could use to programme a spacecraft trajectory.
I'm still far from orbital mechanics so no need to worry about that now. :D
 
MMS said:
In that specific time it is shown to be tangent (as if someone snapped a picture at that time). Of course, it isn't the general case which I'm looking for.
So, again, what does phi look like when it's not tangent, and why do you want to know phi?
 
Chestermiller said:
So, again, what does phi look like when it's not tangent, and why do you want to know phi?

This could be phi at a different time:

Diagram of two concentric circular orbits around a black central dot, with a green dot on the inner orbit and a red dot on the outer orbit, joined by lines to the centre, and an angle phi marked at the green dot.


Knowing phi and R as a function of time helps me plot its path as shown below.
Plot in the complex plane of a red curve, Im(z(t)) against Re(z(t)), axes from -2 to 2, looping repeatedly around a near-circular path with inward spirals.
 
I believe I have reached the answers. I'd be happy if someone could give it a look:

My final answer for R(t) using the law of cosine is:
Equation R(t) = square root of (r1^2 + r2^2 + 2 r1 r2 cos(θ2 - θ1)), the law of cosines distance formula between two points at radii r1 and r2 with angle difference θ2 - θ1.


And phi(t) using arctan(y/x) for R:
Equation: phi(t) = arctan of (r2 sin(theta2) - r1 sin(theta1)) divided by (r2 cos(theta2) - r1 cos(theta1)).
 
MMS said:
I believe I have reached the answers. I'd be happy if someone could give it a look:

My final answer for R(t) using the law of cosine is:
Equation R(t) = sqrt(r1^2 + r2^2 + 2 r1 r2 cos(theta2 - theta1)), giving the distance between two points at radii r1 and r2 with angular positions theta1 and theta2.


And phi(t) using arctan(y/x) for R:
Equation: phi(t) = arctan( (r2 sin(theta2) - r1 sin(theta1)) / (r2 cos(theta2) - r1 cos(theta1)) )
Yes. That looks correct.

Chet