How to solve V=B+CT(V^N) for V?

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter thiago.omena
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
5 replies · 3K views
thiago.omena
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know how to solve V=B+CT(V^N) for V?

The answer is V=[B^(1-N)+C(N-1)T]^(1/(1-N))
I don't understand how to get there.
Please help me out. Thank you
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Hey thiago.omena and welcome to the forums.

Are these matrices or just plain old numbers?
 
chiro said:
Hey thiago.omena and welcome to the forums.

Are these matrices or just plain old numbers?

In the question? They are just variables. I am trying to isolate the V.
 
thiago.omena said:
Does anyone know how to solve V=B+CT(V^N) for V?
The answer is V=[B^(1-N)+C(N-1)T]^(1/(1-N))
I don't understand how to get there.
What makes you think that's the answer? It doesn't look right to me. In fact, I do not believe there is a solution in closed form.

Btw, it's better to use the formatting this site provides. If you click Go Advanced you'll see a toolbar with e.g. X2 for superscript. Select the text to be superscripted and click the icon:
V=B+CT(VN)
 
[itex]V= B+ CTV^N[/itex] is the same as the polynomial equation [itex]CTV^N- V+ B= 0[/itex]. There is NO general formula for solving a polynomial equation of degree greater than 5. In fact, it was proved about a hundred years ago that there cannot be a formula (involving only roots of numbers) for such equations.

And it is easy to show that your [itex]V=[B^{1-N}+C(N-1)T]^(1/(1-N))[/itex] is NOT a general solution to the equation. In the case that C= T= 1, B= -2 and N= 2, the equation becomes [itex]V= -2+ V^2[/itex] which is the same as [itex]V^2- V- 2= (V- 2)(V+ 1)= 0[/itex] which has roots 2 and -1. But your formula gives [itex]V= [(-2)^{-1}+ (1)(-1)(1)]^{1/-1}= [-1/2+ -1]^{-1}= [-3/2]^{-1}= -2/3[/itex] which is NOT a solution.
 
thiago.omena said:
Does anyone know how to solve V=B+CT(V^N) for V?

The answer is V=[B^(1-N)+C(N-1)T]^(1/(1-N))
I don't understand how to get there.
Please help me out. Thank you

Is this a thermodynamic equation? If it is, you're likely looking for an asymptotic solution for V >> 1 and N >> 1. As has been said, solving the equation exactly is not possible in general, but an approximate solution in the large V and/or N limits may be possible, and is perhaps the answer you claim to have.