How Would Changes in the Sun's Mass and Earth's Velocity Affect Earth's Orbit?

  • Thread starter ritwik06
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Astronomy
In summary, if you reduce the mass of the sun by 1%, the Earth's velocity will also be reduced by 1%. This will cause the Earth to spiral inward and eventually decay into the Sun.
  • #1
ritwik06
580
0
Q.1 If the mass of the sun is reduced by 1% and the Earth's velocity is also reduced by 1%, what will be the trajectory of the earth?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
Q.2 In astronomy, looking deeper into space amounts to looking back into the past. If I want to study an object 1 million years ago compared to a similar object in my neighbourhood, how far in the space should I search?
 
  • #3
ritwik06 said:
Q.2 In astronomy, looking deeper into space amounts to looking back into the past. If I want to study an object 1 million years ago compared to a similar object in my neighbourhood, how far in the space should I search?

the simple answer is look out approximately 1 million lightyears
but the simple answer glosses over some stuff that you should know.

There are several different ways to quantify distance at astronomical scale. For short distances, like a million LY, the different measures are approximately the same so it is not worthwhile bothering to distinguish. But for longer distances, like a billion LY, the different measures give noticeably different numbers, so it pays to be clear which you are using

Probably the most useful is the present distance----the distance to the object at the present moment in time---which is the distance that occurs in the Hubble Law. It takes account of the fact that space has expanded during the time the light has been traveling.

what I advise you to do is google Ned Wright (a prof at UCLA) and go to his site and find "Cosmology Calculator"
this related different kinds of distance, like redshift, and light travel time, and present (Hubble-Law) distance. you can play around with that and find out what present distance would correspond to a light travel time of a billion years. It will be more than a billion LY because space will have expanded after the light traveled thru it.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
ritwik06 said:
Q.1 If the mass of the sun is reduced by 1% and the Earth's velocity is also reduced by 1%, what will be the trajectory of the earth?
If you wanted to keep the orbit distance the same, then you would reduce Earth speed by the SQUARE ROOT of the factor you reduce sun mass by.

I know this is not your question but I tell you anyway:smile:

the square root of 0.98 is approx 0.99

so if you reduce mass of sun by TWO percent (to 0.98 previous) then in order to keep orbit same size you should reduce speed by ONE percent (to 0.99 of previous speed)
=========================

so in the question you asked, you are reducing the speed by TOO MUCH to keep Earth in present orbit. At the moment you magically reduce sun mass to 0.99 and Earth speed to 0.99, the Earth will enter a new orbit which is more elliptical and makes it fall in closer to the sun, a little bit.

After it has gone around the sun it will come back to about the same point where you made the magic change, but its orbit will have been more of an oval and during part it would have been closer than before.

you should not have done that, people will not like getting hotter for part of the year

if you wanted to reduce sun mass by one percent, then you should have reduced Earth speed by HALF a percent
because the square root of 0.99 is approximately 0.995
 
Last edited:
  • #5
ritwik06 said:
Q.1 If the mass of the sun is reduced by 1% and the Earth's velocity is also reduced by 1%, what will be the trajectory of the earth?
The Sun would still be considered a "massive body", especially relative to the Earth's mass. Therefore, reducing the orbital velocity of the Earth would make that velocity less than necessary to maintain orbit at present or lesser distance so the Earth would slowly spiral inward and eventually decay to where it would spiral into the Sun.
 
  • #6
I agree with Marcus.

If you wanted to spell it out, formula for circular velocity is: V=sqr(GM/r)

So for the Earth in its present configuration is
sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30+5.97e24)/149597870691)

And under a Sun 0.99 times as massive as the current Sun, to maintain a circular orbit at the same distance would be
sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30+5.97e24)/149597870691)

To compute the ratios:
sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30*.99+5.97e24)/149597870691) / sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30+5.97e24)/149597870691)=0.994987

Notice that Everything but the 0.99 under the root symbol in the numerator cancels out, leaving you with sqr(0.99)=0.994987
 
Last edited:
  • #7
tony873004 said:
I agree with Marcus.

If you wanted to spell it out, formula for circular velocity is: V=sqr(GM/r)

So for the Earth in its present configuration is
sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30+5.97e24)/149597870691)

And under a Sun 0.99 times as massive as the current Sun, to maintain a circular orbit at the same distance would be
sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30+5.97e24)/149597870691)

To compute the ratios:
sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30*.99+5.97e24)/149597870691) / sqr(6.67e-11*(1.989e30+5.97e24)/149597870691)=0.994987

Notice that Everything but the 0.99 under the root symbol in the numerator cancels out, leaving you with sqr(0.99)=0.994987
Ok, but Marcus said it would change to a more elliptical orbit and you give the formulae for a circular, closer orbit. Wouldn't it do a more eccentric ellipse like Marcus posted? And, would it ever return to the aphelion radius we now have??

Every time I post anything re: solar system/planetary/orbital stuff I always screw it up..:mad:
I just got to stick with stars, supernovae, black holes, etc. At least sometimes I get some of those right...:confused:
 
  • #8
Labguy said:
Ok, but Marcus said it would change to a more elliptical orbit and you give the formulae for a circular, closer orbit. Wouldn't it do a more eccentric ellipse like Marcus posted? And, would it ever return to the aphelion radius we now have??

If we approximate the current orbit as circular, then yes, it ought to enter an elliptical orbit with aphelion at the current earth-sun distance.
 

Related to How Would Changes in the Sun's Mass and Earth's Velocity Affect Earth's Orbit?

1. What is astronomy?

Astronomy is the study of celestial objects, such as planets, stars, galaxies, and other phenomena in the universe. It involves the observation, measurement, and analysis of these objects and their movements.

2. How is astronomy different from astrology?

Astronomy is a scientific study that uses evidence and observations to understand the universe. It is based on empirical evidence and scientific methods. On the other hand, astrology is a belief system that claims to predict human affairs and terrestrial events based on the positions and movements of celestial bodies. Astronomy is considered a science, while astrology is not.

3. How do astronomers measure distances in space?

Astronomers use a variety of techniques to measure distances in space, including parallax, radar ranging, and standard candles. Parallax involves measuring the apparent shift of an object against a background as the observer's position changes. Radar ranging uses radar signals to determine the distance to an object. Standard candles, such as supernovae, have a known brightness, allowing astronomers to calculate their distance by measuring their apparent brightness.

4. What is the difference between a planet and a star?

A planet is a celestial body that orbits a star and does not produce its own light. It is much smaller than a star and does not undergo nuclear fusion. A star, on the other hand, is a massive, luminous sphere of plasma that produces energy through nuclear fusion. It is much larger than a planet and can emit its own light.

5. How do astronomers find new objects in the universe?

Astronomers use a variety of tools and techniques to discover new objects in the universe. These include telescopes, both on the ground and in space, as well as computer simulations and data analysis. Astronomers also collaborate and share information to help identify and study new objects in the universe.

Similar threads

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
27
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
24
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
901
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
7
Views
4K
Back
Top