Hydrostatics on plane surface (basic fluid mechanic Q)

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
uzman1243
Messages
80
Reaction score
1
HW Template missing as it was moved from another forum
Handwritten-style worked solution for hydrostatic force on a tank wall: a cross-section of a water tank with a 3.5 m square top and a triangular bottom, with F1 = 210 kN, F2 = 88.4 kN, R = 298.4 kN, and positions y1 = 2.33 m, y2 = 3.96 m, yR = 2.81 m.


I don't understand how they got the "position of individual forces".

For F1, I'm guessing they used a pressure diagram and that's why it's 2/3 from the tip of the triangle. But why wouldn't the force act on the centroid for this square section (thus its 3.5/2)?
Diagram of a vertical gate: a triangular pressure distribution with arrows pushing on the left, next to a plan of a gate shaped as a square topped by a V-shaped bottom, marked 3.5 m on the top and right side, with 3 and 4 slope marks at the lower corners.

But for position of F2 (y2), they used the equation. Can you explain this?
 
Attachments
  • Worked hydrostatics solution: a water tank cross-section with a 3.5 m square top and a triangular bottom, forces F1 = 210 kN and F2 = 88.4 kN and their positions and resultant.
    Untitled.png
    51.2 KB · Views: 669
  • Two diagrams: at left, a right triangular plate with pressure arrows pushing on its vertical face; at right, a pentagon-shaped plate with top edge 3.5 m, vertical sides 3.5 m, and a V-shaped bottom with slopes marked 3 and 4.
    Untitled.png
    2.2 KB · Views: 914
uzman1243 said:
Cross-section of a water tank with a 3.5 m vertical rectangular side topped by a V-shaped sloping bottom; dimensions 3.5 m across the top, 3.5 m height and 3 and 4 labelled on the sloping sides.


I don't understand how they got the "position of individual forces".

For F1, I'm guessing they used a pressure diagram and that's why it's 2/3 from the tip of the triangle. But why wouldn't the force act on the centroid for this square section (thus its 3.5/2)?

The hydrostatic force F1 doesn't act at the centroid of the square because it's not constant with respect to depth. You must integrate the pressure distribution acting over the area to find the magnitude of the force F1, and then calculate the first moment of this force with respect to the waterline in order to locate the point at which the hydrostatic pressure acts.

Since the pressure distribution is triangular w.r.t. depth, it's easy to calculate the total hydrostatic force and to find the center of pressure, knowing some geometric facts about triangles.
Hand-drawn diagram of a vertical square plate with its top at the water surface, sides labelled 3.5 m, and bottom corners cut by 3 to 4 slope triangles; arrows show triangular water pressure on the plate.

But for position of F2 (y2), they used the equation. Can you explain this?

Since the top of the square is at the waterline for the body, the pressure distribution is pretty simple: it's a triangle. No complicated formulas are required to find the center of pressure.

For the bottom of the body, the bottom is sloping and the pressure distribution is trapezoidal, so there are no easy formulas to apply except the one shown in the solution.