I think the book is wrong about this trig equation

  • Thread starter Thread starter srfriggen
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Book Trig
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the rejection of certain angle solutions (π/2 and 3π/2) when solving the equation (sin(2x))/(sec^2(x)) = 0. Participants agree that these angles should be excluded because they make the denominator zero, rendering the equation undefined. The conversation highlights the distinction between equivalent equations and the importance of considering the domains of functions when solving trigonometric equations. There is also a mention of how discontinuities in the original function can be addressed by using an alternative formulation. Ultimately, the consensus emphasizes the necessity of recognizing undefined values in trigonometric functions.
srfriggen
Messages
304
Reaction score
7
Homework Statement
Solve for x:
Relevant Equations
(sin(2x))/(sec^2(x)) =0
When solving for x I get the angles 0, pi, pi/2 and 3pi/2. However, I thought I should reject the pi/2 and 3pi/2 values since they are not in the domain of sec^2(x). I am using the opens tax precalc book and their answer does not reject those two angles.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
observing\cos x = \frac{1}{\sec x}your concern may disappear.
 
  • Skeptical
Likes pbuk
srfriggen said:
Homework Statement:: Solve for x:
Relevant Equations:: (sin(2x))/(sec^2(x)) =0

When solving for x I get the angles 0, pi, pi/2 and 3pi/2. However, I thought I should reject the pi/2 and 3pi/2 values since they are not in the domain of sec^2(x). I am using the opens tax precalc book and their answer does not reject those two angles.
I get your concern and agree that those values should be rejected. For ##x = \frac \pi 2## or ##x = \frac {3\pi} 2##, the denominator in your equation is zero, so the fraction is undefined.
anuttarasammyak said:
observing ##\cos ⁡x=\frac 1 {\sec⁡ x}## your concern may disappear.
Perhaps this is what the authors of the solution did, but nevertheless, the two values I mentioned make the original equation undefined on the left side.
 
  • Like
Likes pbuk and Delta2
anuttarasammyak said:
observing\cos x = \frac{1}{\sec x}your concern may disappear.
The denominator of the original fraction becomes zero at the two values I mentioned. I used this fact to solve the equation but then rejected those two values. Should we not take into account the order of operations of the input angle in the original composite function, not the manipulated equation?
 
  • Like
Likes pbuk
It is too subtle for me to distinguish
\sin 2x \cos^2x=0 and
\sin 2x / \sec^2x=0
or
x-1=0 and
\frac{1}{\frac{1}{x-1}}=0
and hope that it does not matter for physics.
 
  • Skeptical
Likes pbuk and PeroK
The first two equations you wrote do not have the same domains. Consider y=(sqrt(x))^2 and y=x. The former has a domain [0, inf) white the latter is all Reals, even though the equations are both equal.
 
Mark44 said:
I get your concern and agree that those values should be rejected. For ##x = \frac \pi 2## or ##x = \frac {3\pi} 2##, the denominator in your equation is zero, so the fraction is undefined.
Perhaps this is what the authors of the solution did, but nevertheless, the two values I mentioned make the original equation undefined on the left side.
Thank you for the reply
 
srfriggen said:
Consider y=(sqrt(x))^2 and y=x. The former has a domain [0, inf) white the latter is all Reals, even though the equations are both equal.
x=sgn(x)|x|=sgn(x)\sqrt{x^2}\neq \sqrt{x^2}
This confirms that the equations
y-x=0
and
y-\sqrt{x^2}=0
are not equal.

Many texts e.g. Wikipedia article of trigonometry says
\sec x = \frac{1}{\cos x}
You should add "except x=half integer pi" in mind for all those statements. It seems tough work for me, a lazy guy. I am tempted to write
\frac{1}{\sec{\pi/2}}=0
or more directly
\frac{1}{\pm \infty}=0
 
Last edited:
  • Wow
Likes pbuk
srfriggen said:
Homework Statement:: Solve for x:
Relevant Equations:: (sin(2x))/(sec^2(x)) =0

When solving for x I get the angles 0, pi, pi/2 and 3pi/2. However, I thought I should reject the pi/2 and 3pi/2 values since they are not in the domain of sec^2(x). I am using the opens tax precalc book and their answer does not reject those two angles.
Technically, of course, you are correct. Mathematically, in general we have:$$\frac{f(x)}{g(x)} = 0 \ \Leftrightarrow \ f(x) = 0$$That said, if we define the funtions: $$t_1(x) = \frac{\sin(2x)}{\sec^2 x} \ \text{and} \ t_2(x) = \sin(2x)\cos^2 x$$then we see that ##t_1(x) = t_2(x)## except where ##\cos x = 0##, where ##t_1(x)## is not defined. And we see that the discontinuities in ##t_1(x)## are all removable. We can, therefore, view ##t_2(x)## as a patched-up version of ##t_1(x)## with the removable discontinuities removed.

In that sense, we can recast the question in terms of ##t_2(x)## and obtain the additional solutions. In many cases, this would be a mathemetically important thing to do. Especially if we question how we ended up with ##\sec^2 x## in the denominator instead of ##\cos^2 x## in the numerator in the first place!
 
  • #10
anuttarasammyak said:
x=sgn(x)|x|=sgn(x)\sqrt{x^2}\neq \sqrt{x^2}
This confirms that the equations
y-x=0
and
y-\sqrt{x^2}=0
are not equal.
Equations are not "equal" to each other. The proper term is "equivalent," meaning that two equivalent equations have exactly the same solution sets.

Just as your example shows that the equations ##y = x## and ##y = \sqrt{x^2}## are not equivalent, it's also true that ##y = \frac{\sin(2x)}{\sec^2(x)}## and ##y = \sin(2x) \cos^2(x)## are not equivalent, the equations in post #1 of this thread.
anuttarasammyak said:
Many texts e.g. Wikipedia article of trigonometry says
\sec x = \frac{1}{\cos x}
You should add "except x=half integer pi" in mind for all those statements. It seems tough work for me, a lazy guy. I am tempted to write
\frac{1}{\sec{\pi/2}}=0
or more directly
\frac{1}{\pm \infty}=0
It's not legitimate to use infinity in any kind of arithmetic or algebraic expression.
 
  • Like
Likes .Scott, vela, jim mcnamara and 2 others

Similar threads

Back
Top