Inconsistent operator-state relation in Zettili problems 3.4 and 3.5

4 replies · 4K views · last reply
KostasV
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Photo of two printed textbook pages of solved quantum mechanics problems 3.4 and 3.5, with equations numbered 3.163 to 3.176 and eigenstate expansions for operators A and H.
1. Homework Statement

(Uploaded photo from Zettili Quantum Mechanics - Chapter 3 - Solved problems 3.4 and 3.5)
Check at problem 3.4 the relation that he gives between operator A and state φn.
Now check the relation that he uses in problem 3.5 between A and φn again.
They are different while on the announcement of prob 3.5 he does not mention any change of this relation.

Homework Equations



The Attempt at a Solution


Is there any misprint or am i that dumb that cannot understand some change of the relation that he implies?
 
Last edited:
I think that's not a misprint for the answer of prob 3.5 follows as a consequence of the written relation between ##\hat{A}## and ##|\phi_n\rangle## in that problem. My guess is that he forgot that in the previous problem 3.4 he defined ##|\phi_n\rangle##'s as the eigenstates of ##\hat{A}##.
 
blue_leaf77 said:
I think that's not a misprint for the answer of prob 3.5 follows as a consequence of the written relation between ##\hat{A}## and ##|\phi_n\rangle## in that problem. My guess is that he forgot that in the previous problem 3.4 he defined ##|\phi_n\rangle##'s as the eigenstates of ##\hat{A}##.

So, in problem 3.5 he probably wanted to change the relation between ##\hat{A}## and ##|\phi_n\rangle## to ##\hat{A}## ##|\phi_n\rangle## = n ##\alpha_o\ ## ##|\phi_{n+1}\rangle## (in order not to be anymore eigenstates of ##\hat{A}## ) but forgot to mention it?
 
KostasV said:
So, in problem 3.5 he probably wanted to change the relation between ##\hat{A}## and ##|\phi_n\rangle## to ##\hat{A}## ##|\phi_n\rangle## = n ##\alpha_o\ ## ##|\phi_{n+1}\rangle## (in order not to be anymore eigenstates of ##\hat{A}## ) but forgot to mention it?
Yeah, probably.
 
blue_leaf77 said:
Yeah, probably.
Thanks for your response to my issue !