# Invariant mass plots for resonance 'particles'

• I
• IAN 25
In summary: So the invariant mass squared must increase as a result. I hadn't thought of that. Now, I am happy with that. Thanks again.In summary, the interaction p + π- → n + π- + π + can create an intermediate 'particle' called a rho, which can be detected as a peak in the plot of invariant rest mass energy. The invariant mass of the system is not equal to the sum of the invariant masses of the pions, resulting in a continuous range of rest mass energies. This is due to the fact that the pions can have different kinetic energies in the center of mass frame, leading to an increase in the invariant mass of the system.
IAN 25
The interaction p + π- → n + π- + π + may proceed by the creation of an intermediate 'particle' or resonance called a rho. This can be detected as a peak in the plot of invariant rest mass energy of the emergent pions versus frequency of pions observed. My question is quite simply, invariant rest mass is invariant. So, how can you have a spectrum of rest mass energies? The rest mass of the pi plus and pi minus are well known to be 139.6 Mev/ c2 for both, so how can you have a range of their rest mass energies?

You are confusing the invariant mass of the system with the sum of the invariant masses. The invariant mass of the system is the square of the total 4-momentum, which is also the total energy in the CoM frame. This is not equal to the sum of the invariant masses of the pions.

As a curiosity, a system of two photons have a non-zero invariant mass (unless they are collinear). The Higgs was discovered as a peak in the photon-photon invariant mass spectrum at 125 GeV.

Thank you. Okay, I understand what the invariant mass of the system is - but if it is the sum of the invariant masses of the (two?) pions that is plotted, why is there a continuous range?

IAN 25 said:
Okay, I understand what the invariant mass of the system is
Based on the next part of your post, you don’t.

IAN 25 said:
but if it is the sum of the invariant masses of the (two?) pions that is plotted, why is there a continuous range?
It is not the sum of the invariant masses of the pions. It is the invariant mass of the system of pions (in this case the system consists of three pions).

To me invariant mass means invariant, whether its a sum for several particles or not; the masses have discrete values and

E2 -(pc)2 = m2c4 for each particle (or for a sum of particles)

which as I understand it, is a scalar invariant - which has the same value in all inertial frames, does it not?
So, how can you have a continuous range of energies on this plot, unless its (rest mass + kinetic ) energies. That I could understand. The Ek of the pions getting bigger until the threshold for the mass of the Rho is reached.

Again. It is not the invariant masses of the particles added together. It is the invariant mass of the system, i.e., ##E^2 - p^2## for the system as a whole (in reasonable units where c=1).

I still don't see why this gives a range of rest mass energies. That's the point I am trying to understand - the continuous range?

Because:
$$(E_1 + E_2)^2 - (\vec p_1 + \vec p_2)^2 = E_1^2 - \vec p_1^2 + E_2^2 - \vec p_2^2 + 2( E_1 E_2 - \vec p_1 \cdot \vec p_2) = m_1^2 + m_2^2 + 2( E_1 E_2 - \vec p_1 \cdot \vec p_2) \neq (m_1 + m_2)^2.$$

If the pions are at rest relative to each other, the invariant mass of the system is simply the sum of their rest masses. If the pions move relative to each other, the invariant mass of the system (=the total energy in the center of mass frame) is higher.

Got it! I can follow the algebra but the two worded sentences of physics (mfb) add clarity. Thank you both.

Just to add some more food for thought.

You can always consider the rest frame of one of the pions where the expression from my previous post takes the form
$$M^2 = m_1^2 + m_2^2 + 2 m_1\sqrt{m_2^2 + p_2^2} \geq (m_1+m_2)^2,$$
with equality holding only when ##p_2 = 0##, i.e., when the pions are at relative rest.

Yes that is an interesting example. In you original expression, it is clearly the term 2(E1 E2 - p1. p2 which provides the range of kinetic energies of the pions observed either side of the peak in the laboratory frame.

Orodruin said:
As a curiosity, a system of two photons have a non-zero invariant mass (unless they are collinear). The Higgs was discovered as a peak in the photon-photon invariant mass spectrum at 125 GeV.

I did read an article featuring this in the UCL Physics department Annual Departmental Review in the year concerned.

mfb said:
If the pions move relative to each other, the invariant mass of the system (=the total energy in the center of mass frame) is higher.

If they move relative to each other, I can see there will be more kinetic energy in the C.M. frame. However, the sum of their momenta will be zero in that frame. So, the expression (E1 + E2 )2 - (p1 + p2)2 will not change as a result will it? Since, the momentum term is zero. Or is the rest mass energy available in the laboratory frame bigger as a result? If so is it because of the 2(E1 E2 - p1 . p2) term, which appears in the invariant rest mass expression in the latter frame?

I am still a bit confused as to how you can have more energy in the C.M. frame if the momenta sum to zero in that frame.

IAN 25 said:
So, the expression (E1 + E2 )2 - (p1 + p2)2 will not change as a result will it?
Yes it will. You said it yourself, the ##E_i## increase because there is more kinetic energy.

Of course, yes. Right , thanks.

## 1. What is the significance of invariant mass plots in particle physics?

Invariant mass plots are used to identify and study new particles, as well as to confirm the existence of previously discovered particles. They also provide information about the properties of particles, such as their mass and decay modes.

## 2. How are invariant mass plots created?

Invariant mass plots are created by analyzing the energy and momentum of particles produced in high-energy collisions. By combining this information, the mass of the particles involved can be determined and plotted on a graph.

## 3. What is a resonance particle and how is it identified using invariant mass plots?

A resonance particle is a short-lived, high-energy particle that is produced in particle collisions. It can be identified through its distinctive peak in an invariant mass plot, which indicates its mass and decay products.

## 4. How do invariant mass plots help in the search for new particles?

Invariant mass plots provide a way to visualize and analyze large amounts of data from particle collisions. This allows scientists to look for patterns and anomalies that may indicate the presence of new particles or interactions.

## 5. What are some limitations of using invariant mass plots in particle physics research?

One limitation is that invariant mass plots can only provide indirect evidence of the existence of particles, and further experiments are needed to confirm their existence. Additionally, the resolution of the plots can be limited by experimental uncertainties and background noise, making it difficult to accurately identify new particles.

• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
1
Views
1K
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
1
Views
1K
• Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
10
Views
1K
• Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
4
Views
958
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
8
Views
4K
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
8
Views
986
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
7
Views
2K
• Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
848
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
7
Views
1K
• High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
41
Views
8K