Is Centrifugal Force Real or Fictitious?

In summary, a non-inertial observer measures the same physical forces as an inertial observer, but must also take into account fictitious forces, such as the position-dependent centrifugal force, in order to apply the inertial laws of motion. These fictitious forces are also known as inertial forces and are proportional to the mass of the body. Centrifugal force can be understood in two different ways - as a pseudoforce in non-inertial frames or as a real force in the Newton's-3rd-law pair of the centripetal force.
  • #1
19,455
10,061
Definition/Summary

A non-inertial observer measures the same "real" (physical) forces as an inertial observer does, but if he wants to apply the inertial laws of motion, he must add "fictitious" (non-physical) forces.

One of these "fictitious" forces is a position-dependent centrifugal force ([itex]m\omega^2r[/itex]), which must be used by any rotating observer.

For a body stationary relative to a uniformly rotating observer, it is the only "fictitious" force; for a relatively moving body, there is also a velocity-dependent Coriolis force; for a non-uniform rotating observer, there is also a position-dependent Euler force.

These "fictitious" forces are confusingly also called inertial forces (even though they only appear in non-inertial frames) because they are proportional to the mass (the "inertia") of the body.

(By comparison, centripetal force is a "real" force. It is not a separate force, it is another name for an existing physical force, such as tension or friction, which makes a body move in a circle.)

Equations

CENTRIFUGAL FORCE (position-dependent and radially outward) at distance [itex]r[/itex] from axis of rotation of an observer with instantaneous angular speed [itex]\omega[/itex]:
[tex]m\omega^2r[/tex]

CORIOLIS FORCE (velocity-dependent and "magnetic") on velocity [itex]\mathbf{v}_{rel}[/itex] relative to the rotating frame of an observer with instantaneous angular velocity [itex]\mathbf{\omega}[/itex]:
[tex]-2m\mathbf{\omega}\times\mathbf{v}_{rel}[/tex]

EULER FORCE (position-dependent and tangential) at distance [itex]r[/itex] from axis of angular acceleration of an observer with instantaneous angular acceleration [itex]\alpha[/itex]:
[tex]m\alpha r[/tex]

Extended explanation

The Principle of Equivalence (the basis of Einstein's General Theory of Relativity) says that anyone can be a valid observer, but that the inertial equations of motion may have to be adjusted to introduce imaginary (non-physical) forces.

Centrifugal force on a body is such a non-physical force.

In particular, a rotating observer invents an imaginary (non-physical) centrifugal force to explain why objects appear to move round him. :smile:

"Centrifugal" means "away from the centre" … it comes from the Latin word fugo (I flee) … as does "refugee". It is the opposite of "centripetal", which means "toward the centre" (and comes from the Latin word peto, I seek … as does "petition").

On an object moving in a circular path, there is no centrifugal force as viewed by an inertial observer.

Centrifugal force on such an object only exists for non-inertial observers.

However, both inertial and non-inertial observers recognise a centrifugal force from such an object, on whatever is keeping it in the circle.

Two different meanings:

Most standard physics textbooks use the "modern" meaning of centrifugal force as a pseudoforce, existing only as an artefact of viewing things in a non-inertial frame.

It is not a "real" (physical) force, since it has no agent.

The "old-fashioned" meaning of centrifugal force as the Newton's-3rd-law pair ("reaction force") of the centripetal force is completely "real", in any frame.

These two different types of centrifugal force act on different bodies.

Whirling on a string:

An observer holding onto a string which is whirling him in a circle feels a force along his arm toward the centre of the circle.

However, he knows that he is not moving toward the centre.

So he also feels a force in the opposite direction, balancing the force along his arm.

In that sense, he genuinely feels a centrifugal force. :smile:

In a turning car:

The driver of a car turning sharply left notices that unsecured objects slide to the right … away from the centre of the turn.

In the driver's rotating (non-inertial) frame of reference, that can only be explained by a force to the right.

It is a centrifugal force, acting on everything in the car, but nothing physical is causing it.

If the driver regards that force as real, then he may apply the inertial laws of motion. :smile:

* This entry is from our old Library feature. If you know who wrote it, please let us know so we can attribute a writer. Thanks!
 
  • Like
Likes Jared Edington
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Thanks for the overview of centrifugal force!
 

Related to Is Centrifugal Force Real or Fictitious?

1. What is centrifugal force?

Centrifugal force is a fictitious force that is experienced by an object moving in a circular path. It is directed away from the center of the circle and is caused by the object's inertia.

2. How is centrifugal force different from centripetal force?

Centrifugal force and centripetal force are often confused, but they are actually two different forces. Centripetal force is the force that keeps an object moving in a circular path, while centrifugal force is the outward force that is experienced by the object.

3. What is the relationship between centrifugal force and angular velocity?

The magnitude of centrifugal force is directly proportional to the square of the object's angular velocity. This means that as the angular velocity increases, the centrifugal force also increases.

4. Is centrifugal force a real force?

No, centrifugal force is not a real force in the sense that it does not result from a physical interaction between two objects. It is a perceived force that arises from the object's own inertia and the circular motion it is experiencing.

5. How is centrifugal force used in everyday life?

Centrifugal force is used in many everyday devices, such as washing machines, clothes dryers, and amusement park rides. It is also used in engineering and design, particularly in the development of centrifuges for separating mixtures of substances.

Similar threads

Replies
22
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
19
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
40
Views
3K
Replies
37
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Back
Top