Is it possible to create linear acceleration using nothing but different moments of inertia beteen a wheel and axle?

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter BishopBrain
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Mechanics
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the mechanics of linear acceleration in a hypothetical scenario involving a character named Axel from the Twisted Metal video game series, who is attached to tractor wheels. Participants debate whether Axel can achieve movement solely through different moments of inertia between himself and the wheels, even if his center of mass (CoM) is aligned with the axis of rotation. It is concluded that while Axel can move if his CoM is off-axis, he would flip end over end, and the system would behave similarly to a Segway, which requires a motor for practical movement.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of rotational dynamics and moments of inertia
  • Familiarity with the concept of center of mass (CoM)
  • Basic knowledge of torque and its effects on motion
  • Experience with free-body diagrams for analyzing forces
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the principles of rotational dynamics in physics
  • Study the mechanics of Segways and their motorized systems
  • Explore the concept of torque and its application in balancing systems
  • Learn how to construct and analyze free-body diagrams for complex systems
USEFUL FOR

Physics enthusiasts, mechanical engineers, game developers, and anyone interested in the mechanics of motion and balance in dynamic systems.

BishopBrain
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
Is it possible to create linear acceleration using nothing but different moments of inertia beteen a wheel and axle?
The Twisted Metal video game series includes a character aptly named Axel, whose vehicle is just himself strapped to a pair of tractor wheels. This is the guy:

axel.jpg

Most of my friends assume that in real life, he probably wouldn't be able to drive anywhere unless his feet were incredibly heavy, so that gravity would apply torque as his lower half swung forward--similar mechanics to a monocycle.

But one of us claimed that even if Axel's center of mass lay perfectly on the axis of rotation of the big wheels , he would still be able to move a little bit if he were so heavy that the moment of inertia of himself was significantly greater than the moment of inertia for his wheels. Axel would still be spinning sickeningly, but his contraption could move about at least a little bit.

Is this correct? Can two very-different wheels applying torque to one another via an axle generate linear motion from friction, even in the absence of any external forces tangential to the axle? We were skeptical, but couldn't figure out how to set up the system to test the math.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If he's rigidly attached to the wheels and he can flex his body to keep his center of mass forwards of the rotation axis then sure he can roll. He'd flip end for end as he does it, though, and I'm guessing the vehicle acts more like a Segway.

Obviously Segways are possible, but you need a motor.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lnewqban
Welcome!
What are those things attached to the shoulders?
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BishopBrain
Lnewqban said:
What are those things attached to the shoulders?
Machine guns or missiles, I forget which.

Ibix said:
If he's rigidly attached to the wheels and he can flex his body to keep his center of mass forwards of the rotation axis then sure he can roll. He'd flip end for end as he does it, though, and I'm guessing the vehicle acts more like a Segway.

Obviously Segways are possible, but you need a motor.
Yes, in game he's motorized like a Segway. In-game he's also perfectly upright at all times, which is not terribly realistic...

The crux of my question is, if motorized and if his CoM is always on-axis, is movement possible for Axel. If he has a CoM off-axis, then he clearly can (in any number of ways), and I know how to draw up the free-body diagram to analyze it.
 
Last edited:
BishopBrain said:
The crux of my question is, if motorized and if his CoM is always on-axis, is movement possible for Axel.
Sure, but the wheel hubs (with him) will spin opposite to the wheels.
 
There is some similarity with a tight rope walker carrying a pole.

The walker can accelerate his center of gravity rightward or leftward by exerting torque against the pole while his feet exert a counter torque on the rope.