Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the idea of rethinking the names and borders of U.S. states, exploring historical naming inconsistencies and proposing various humorous and unconventional suggestions for state consolidation and renaming. The scope includes conceptual and theoretical considerations rather than practical proposals.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest merging states with directional names, such as North and South Dakota or North and South Carolina, into single entities.
- There are proposals to combine Virginia and West Virginia, citing historical context.
- One participant humorously suggests ceding New Mexico back to Mexico for naming consistency.
- Another participant questions whether New York, New Jersey, and New Hampshire should be ceded back to England, extending the idea of renaming based on historical ties.
- Suggestions include renaming Hawaii to "West Los Angeles" and ceding Alaska to Canada to fit a new logical map scheme.
- Some participants propose a radical renaming scheme, suggesting states be numbered sequentially like streets.
- There are humorous suggestions to eliminate smaller states like Maryland and Delaware or merge states with similar names or characteristics, such as Illinois, Indiana, and Iowa.
- Participants share updated maps reflecting their proposed changes, including various territorial adjustments.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
The discussion features multiple competing views and humorous suggestions, with no consensus reached on any specific proposal. Participants engage in playful banter and explore a variety of ideas without settling on a definitive plan.
Contextual Notes
Participants express nostalgia and humor in their suggestions, which may not reflect serious political or geographical considerations. The discussion includes speculative ideas that rely on historical context and personal opinions.
Who May Find This Useful
Readers interested in geography, U.S. history, or humorous takes on state names and borders may find this discussion engaging.