Is Killing Human Beings Wrong/Immoral?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Another God
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Human
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the morality of killing versus murder, with participants debating whether killing can ever be justified based on circumstances. Key points include the distinction between "killing" as a justifiable act and "murder" as senseless death. Many argue that killing may be acceptable in self-defense or in cases like euthanasia, while others emphasize that killing should be avoided unless absolutely necessary. The conversation also touches on the complexities of moral judgments, with some asserting that morality is not strictly binary and depends on context. The death penalty is a contentious topic, with opinions divided on its morality and effectiveness, particularly in light of wrongful convictions. Participants express concerns about the implications of defining rights, particularly the "right to life," and how these definitions vary across different ethical frameworks. The overarching theme reflects a struggle to reconcile personal beliefs about morality with societal laws and the consequences of actions.

Is Killing humans wrong?

  • It is always wrong.

    Votes: 3 21.4%
  • There is nothing wrong about it.

    Votes: 1 7.1%
  • It is wrong or right depending on the situation.

    Votes: 10 71.4%

  • Total voters
    14
  • #51
Originally posted by FZ+
Why do we all want to live?
Evolution probably, but there doesn't really need to be an answer for this. It's like asking what happiness is. We don't really need an answer, you just need to ask people "Are you happy?" And they know what you mean.

Why do we want to live? I dunno, but I sure as hell know that I want to.

Heh. I might say this in some systems the above is suppressed, and killing is made "right". The armed forces are an example. In that case, we find not following orders (The goodness of the opponent does really come into it, IMHO.) to be more subversive to our prime desires, to the mission, or the team, or whatever.
I think that this is because killing others isn't as prime a directive. It is more accurately a concession in light of the prime directives. They being "I don't want to die" and "I want to have friends/family/others around me with whom to share my life."

In a military outfit, you have those people around you, and they are directly concerned with keeping you alive. Of course you will work together to kill other people who are not 'Us': They may try to kill you and your incredibly close friends.
 
Back
Top