Is Montreal Unique Among Canadian Cities?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wasteofo2
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Canada Rest
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the unique characteristics of Montreal compared to other Canadian cities, focusing on aspects such as smoking regulations, taxation, cultural elements, and social issues like homelessness. Participants share their observations and experiences, exploring whether these traits are common across Canada or specific to Montreal.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant notes a high prevalence of smoking in Montreal, contrasting it with stricter regulations in New York, while others mention varying smoking laws across Canadian provinces.
  • Tax rates in Montreal are discussed, with one participant stating a 15% total tax, which aligns with norms in Canada except for Alberta, while another points out that the UK has even higher VAT.
  • The absence of delis in Montreal is questioned by another participant, suggesting that the original poster may not have explored the city thoroughly.
  • Hip-hop's popularity is debated, with some asserting that it varies by location and that there is a segment of the youth in Montreal that enjoys the genre.
  • Concerns about homelessness are raised, with participants noting that while it is visible in Montreal, it is also a significant issue in other cities like Toronto and Halifax.
  • Gasoline prices and environmental policies are mentioned, with one participant referencing CO2 pollution and another providing current gas prices in Halifax.
  • Comparisons are made between Canadian and American healthcare and taxation systems, with some participants expressing pride in Canada's universal healthcare and lower inequality.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the characteristics of Montreal and other Canadian cities, indicating that there is no consensus on whether Montreal is unique or how it compares to other cities in Canada.

Contextual Notes

Participants' observations are influenced by personal experiences and regional differences, leading to varying interpretations of cultural and social norms across Canadian cities.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in Canadian culture, urban studies, or comparative social issues may find the discussion relevant.

  • #31
JasonRox said:
If the US is so great, why does everyone complain?
People complain everywhere, moron. If you don't like it, stay out. Nobody cares about your opinion here, I assure you.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
ok this is getting rediculous, obviously no one that says Amarica is number 1 has ever lived in Canada, and vice versa, you are all ignorant of the other side, i have lived in both countries, i prefer Canada, we both have our advantages and disadvantages

now its just time to stop this bull****, no one is ever going to win
 
  • #33
i_wish_i_was_smart said:
ok this is getting rediculous, obviously no one that says Amarica is number 1 has ever lived in Canada, and vice versa, you are all ignorant of the other side, i have lived in both countries, i prefer Canada, we both have our advantages and disadvantages

now its just time to stop this bull****, no one is ever going to win
So you expect me to sit silent while some idiot Canadian spouts off about how great he thinks his country is (that is, if Montreal is even part of Canada in the next few years) and how terrible the US is? I've been to Canada and I couldn't wait to leave. Terrible place, unfriendly people.
 
  • #34
your just doing the same ****ing thing you dumbass, you just happen to say the other point of view, besides this is WAY off topic
 
  • #35
i_wish_i_was_smart said:
your just doing the same ****ing thing you dumbass, you just happen to say the other point of view, besides this is WAY off topic
Maybe you should blame your buddy that, since I don't see what the cost of the underfunded falling apart Canadian "healthcare" system has to do with Montreal vs. the rest of Canada
 
  • #36
who said he was my buddy
MAYBE you should just shut up, cause whatever you say isn't getting either of us anywhere
 
  • #37
fourier jr said:
check this quote out, from a "Canadian hero", our 1st French-Canadian Prime Minister:
"You must not take the Militia seriously, for though it is useful for suppressing internal differences, it will not be required for the defence of the country, as the Monroe Doctrine [proclaiming US military hegemony in the Americas] protects us against enemy aggression." - Wilfred Laurier, PM 1896-1911



isn't that the most pathetic thing you've ever heard? Laurier inviting an American invasion if we get invaded. & this is one of the "good guys" in Canadian history...

Yeah, really. Get your own military.

what small government? Bush has been giving out huge subsidies to the military contractors, which is indirectly a huge subsidy to high-tech industry, biggest deficit ever by a long shot, telling gays/lesbians they can't get married, etc etc. that's all big-government stuff. i don't know where Americans get the idea that they've got small government... :confused:

Please reread the post. I was specifically talking about my local (town)government. :rolleyes:
 
  • #38
JasonRox said:
If the US is so great, why does everyone complain?

I'm not complaining. :smile: The one's complaining are probably looking for a handout.

There are more people trying to get into this country than trying to leave, what's that tell ya.
 
  • #39
I think Canada should join USA anyway.In some ways Canada already is absorbed into the USA.
 
  • #40
tumor said:
I think Canada should join USA anyway.

well I think you should get sent to a psychiatric prison for thinking that. i wonder if you agree with (defence minister) bill graham, who thinks NAFTA should be expanded to include social policy. i wonder how you would like it if we had the KKK (currently a terrorist organisation) & NRA & gun nuts everywhere :rolleyes:


You're right about Canada being absorbed economically and politically though, as Clayton Yeutter predicted in 1987, but it's not like it can't be reversed.
 
Last edited:
  • #41
Jeeez! maybe I do have tumor on my brain? what was I thinking. :blushing:
Yeah! right! Canada does not have racist freaks,just go for a ride 50 miles out of any big city and you see racist yahoos and hillbillies (not with guns I agree) but with baseball bats.
By the way our social policy is slowly dismantled to conform to the USA "standarts".
 
  • #42
sure we have our racist and what not freaks, but you hardly ever hear of hate crimes, mostly its just people joking about other races, we don't take it as far as you do.
now why doesn't the US just change its name to Canada, we already engolf you in our enormous size(it makes as much sense as what you stated)
and more people are trying to get in america because they are filled with the false sense that it will sop there misery, so they sell everything they own, move there, in a matter of months are broke and can't leave because they have no money to go back, I've heard many testamonies
 
  • #43
All i have to say is describe i the following image

just think about it
 
  • #44
Alright let's take it easy guys.

Let's get back on topic.

Note: I'm an idiot just like everyone else, so let's drop it now. I don't want a flame war.

EDIT: Montreal is the international comedy centre. All the top stand-up comedians got there. When I say international, I mean comedians from all over the world. Most people think this refers to the people they heard about, but that is not the case here. You get Irish people making Irish jokes, etc...
 
  • #45
Have your pissing contest elsewhere.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
10K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
7K