Is passion enough to succeed in university physics and astronomy?

  • Context: Other 
  • Thread starter Thread starter starstruck_
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Astronomy Study
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concerns of a student regarding their performance in physics and astronomy as they transition to university. The student expresses anxiety about their current grades, the impact of personal challenges, and the balance of academic and extracurricular commitments. The conversation explores the relationship between passion for the subject and academic success, as well as strategies for managing workload and self-doubt.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • The original poster (OP) shares concerns about their declining physics grades and the impact of personal issues, such as family health and a robbery.
  • Some participants suggest that the OP should focus on time management and not let one subject detract from others, especially since they have already been accepted into university programs.
  • There is a discussion about the importance of understanding mistakes in physics problems, with some participants emphasizing the need to identify whether errors stem from second-guessing or misunderstanding the material.
  • Some participants encourage the OP to seek help from their teacher and to communicate their situation, suggesting that teachers may offer support or accommodations.
  • The OP expresses a desire to pursue physics despite doubts about their capabilities, questioning whether passion alone is sufficient for success in the field.
  • Several replies highlight the value of loving the subject and encourage the OP to focus on their passion for physics rather than the pressures of performance.
  • The OP acknowledges their tendency to avoid asking questions in class due to fear of judgment, which some participants suggest could hinder their learning.
  • There is a recognition that university will require hard work and focus, with some participants noting that the OP has demonstrated the ability to concentrate for extended periods when necessary.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the importance of passion for pursuing physics, but there is no consensus on the best strategies for overcoming academic challenges or the adequacy of passion alone for success in university. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the balance between personal circumstances and academic performance.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the potential impact of personal challenges on academic performance, but there are no specific resolutions to the OP's concerns about their grades or future in physics. The discussion reflects a variety of perspectives on managing workload and the emotional aspects of academic pressure.

starstruck_
Messages
185
Reaction score
8
Hey!So, I applied to some universities for Physics and astronomy before I ended up with my grade 12, first-semester mid-term mark of a 74 in physics. I had an 87 last year with the same teacher. I've been accepted everywhere I applied, which is great, but I'm scared that, because I'm not doing well now, I won't do well in university. At the same time, I don't want to give up on it either. I know if I put in the work (I'd want to put in the work because I like it) I probably can succeed. I know there's always the option of going into something else and then pursuing physics on the side but what are the chances that I'll even have time later in life to do that? They're pretty slim.Maybe a minor would work but it depends on if my parents will be okay with me doing that.

I really don't want to make excuses for my performance in physics but I've had a pretty heavy semester with English, Physics, Advanced Functions and Philosophy. Most of my concentration went into English because we have like 3 assignments due for English every week. So I haven't really been concentrating on physics or advanced functions for that matter. Philosophy isn't too bad.
I also almost lost my dad twice in the duration of this semester and then my house got robbed (lol my life is great).
There's also the fact that I'm in 6 different extra- curriculars - I don't know how I'm surviving, but I am.I had 2 and a half weeks of physics homework pending before the winter holidays, which I sat down for 7 hours yesterday and completed.What I noticed is that the homework came naturally to me, I understood everything- didn't even have to refer to my notes because everything made sense.
My physics teacher gives us questions from the homework - similar ones- but with different numbers and I mess up.

I don't know if it has to do with my confidence issues and always second guessing myself but I do horribly when I know I can do much better and this is what I'm afraid is going to carry on into university.
I'm scared that even if I end up with my degree, I won't have a high enough GPA to get into teaching.

Is loving something a good enough reason to pursue it? I've gotten into life sciences at a university too, just in case I chicken out from what I want to do but I really don't like life science. I can do well in bio and chemistry but it's just not the same.

What sucks even more, is that I've made it into one of the best North American universities for engineering, physics, and mathematics (for their physics and astronomy program), but I don't feel worthy of it looking at how poorly I'm doing right now. I'm so stuck.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think you have a lot on your mind and need to unload some of it and manage your time better. I can see focusing on your English but it shouldn't be to the detriment of your other courses. Since you've been accepted already just hang in there at school. Many seniors get senioritis around this time. They want to break the yoke of high school and begin going places and doing more exciting things.

With respect to your physics, I would rework those problems that you did poorly on and see exactly why you made your mistakes. Is it in the check (ie second guessing because you did the check wrong) or in the actual problem? Also, ask your teacher for help, really! Perhaps the teacher can point out the reason you made you mistakes from the experience of having taught for so long and seeing other students make the same mistake.

With respect to your Dad and your family, hang in there. This can be very tough and you need to be there for them. Tell your teachers your situation and perhaps they can give you extra time to get things done or reduce your assignments a bit.
 
starstruck_ said:
I really don't want to make excuses for my performance in physics but I've had a pretty heavy semester with English, Physics, Advanced Functions and Philosophy. Most of my concentration went into English because we have like 3 assignments due for English every week. So I haven't really been concentrating on physics or advanced functions for that matter. Philosophy isn't too bad.

Indeed, that isn't an excuse. You'll be expected to work very hard in university too. Now don't be too hard on yourself. You can work for 7 hours straight when necessary. That won't happen a lot in university, but it's good that you can do that because a strong focus is absolutely necessary.

My physics teacher gives us questions from the homework - similar ones- but with different numbers and I mess up.

You absolutely need to know why you mess up. Otherwise it will haunt you throughout university and you might get less grades than you deserve. So this is something you need to figure out.

Is loving something a good enough reason to pursue it?

Of course. Try to focus more on the love for physics, and the desire for new things. Don't focus so much on the pressure. Easier said than done, I know. But realize every second of the day that you're learning more about nature and the universe, and that's pretty damn cool.
 
jedishrfu said:
I think you have a lot on your mind and need to unload some of it and manage your time better. I can see focusing on your English but it shouldn't be to the detriment of your other courses. Since you've been accepted already just hang in there at school. Many seniors get senioritis around this time. They want to break the yoke of high school and begin going places and doing more exciting things.

With respect to your physics, I would rework those problems that you did poorly on and see exactly why you made your mistakes. Is it in the check (ie second guessing because you did the check wrong) or in the actual problem? Also, ask your teacher for help, really! Perhaps the teacher can point out the reason you made you mistakes from the experience of having taught for so long and seeing other students make the same mistake.

With respect to your Dad and your family, hang in there. This can be very tough and you need to be there for them. Tell your teachers your situation and perhaps they can give you extra time to get things done or reduce your assignments a bit.

Thank you so much for the advice! I've noticed I don't ask many questions in class now that you bring that up. Mostly because I'm scared of looking stupid - some of the kids already think I'm stupid though so oh well, I guess XD. My teachers are really big on preparing us for university so they go a little easy but don't provide extra time but that's alright, I can live with the lighter marking! Honestly, I just need to take a break, maybe get out of some of the extracurricular activities I'm in too! I like and enjoy physics way too much to let go and maybe, uni might be better for me! I do best on self-taught courses so I usually take summer school courses online and university involves teaching yourself a lot so I hope it works somewhat in my favour. I spoke to my physics teacher about my plans for university and what I want to do and he says he thinks I'll make it, that I'm just worrying for no reason. I really hope he's right :P.
 
micromass said:
Indeed, that isn't an excuse. You'll be expected to work very hard in university too. Now don't be too hard on yourself. You can work for 7 hours straight when necessary. That won't happen a lot in university, but it's good that you can do that because a strong focus is absolutely necessary.
You absolutely need to know why you mess up. Otherwise it will haunt you throughout university and you might get less grades than you deserve. So this is something you need to figure out.
Of course. Try to focus more on the love for physics, and the desire for new things. Don't focus so much on the pressure. Easier said than done, I know. But realize every second of the day that you're learning more about nature and the universe, and that's pretty damn cool.
The last part really helped me be more sure of what I'm doing. I've being told by friends and stuff that I'm probably not making a right decision, doing something just because I love it, but honestly, why would I want to do something I don't like and be stuck with it for however long, if I have the chance to go into what I really want, from the start. I know I can get somewhere with this if I stop stressing and ask for help => really need to work on doing that! Thank you! :)
 
Albert Einstein wrote, “Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.”.
Not sure if Einstein actually is the source of that or if it is an urban myth, but hmm ,makes sense.
 
starstruck_ said:
I know there's always the option of going into something else and then pursuing physics on the side but what are the chances that I'll even have time later in life to do that? They're pretty slim.
Depends on what you are after:

Horsehead-HaRGB.jpg

http://www.russsscope.net/
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: starstruck_
there should be few doubts and more of a concrete plan. A concrete plan.

courses are hard at university level, it is more about managing your time and dedicate time constantly to study. It helps to have groups of students to work with.
I have seen many posters on here say that it is difficult to be introduced to the material for the first time when you're in college, ie you should always try to learn some stuff beforehand. I tend to agree with this statement but obviously its not possible for everything.

I think for sure you would want to work on your mathematics as pure physics requires good understanding of mathematics. About losing your parent almost, I have already lost one when I was 14 and my father is in similar condition to yours, its very hard to study effectively in these situations if you can't control your emotions. Depression will not help.

I also saw your other thread where you said your parents aren't supportive of this decision, this is not good, you must tell them to support you and not be negative about it as it will affect you (my parent used to taunt me and mock my choice for economics as a major, it did not help believe me).

Lastly, do not go into any major you do not have a passion for, no matter what anyone says because I am sure you will end up getting a subpar gpa anyway. Make a practical plan for your life after the degree. Do not listen to other people as much because they are not YOU.

I see a lot of issues and personal stuff going on, also, why are you focusing on English when physics is your aim? :-) Maybe take some time off other subjects and focus more on maths and physics as this is your aim. (Think you've already been admitted to the program based on your old grades right? will your english grade determine university admission anymore or not? ). No matter what, all problems have some solutions and we all things we shall have to live with, be strong, honest and work smart/hard and you will be fine.
 
rootone said:
Albert Einstein wrote, “Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.”.
Not sure if Einstein actually is the source of that or if it is an urban myth, but hmm ,makes sense.

That is true, everyone is a genius. Unfortunately, I don't excel at anything so I guess I'm an exception.
 
  • #10
Bipolar Demon said:
there should be few doubts and more of a concrete plan. A concrete plan.

courses are hard at university level, it is more about managing your time and dedicate time constantly to study. It helps to have groups of students to work with.
I have seen many posters on here say that it is difficult to be introduced to the material for the first time when you're in college, ie you should always try to learn some stuff beforehand. I tend to agree with this statement but obviously its not possible for everything.

I think for sure you would want to work on your mathematics as pure physics requires good understanding of mathematics. About losing your parent almost, I have already lost one when I was 14 and my father is in similar condition to yours, its very hard to study effectively in these situations if you can't control your emotions. Depression will not help.

I also saw your other thread where you said your parents aren't supportive of this decision, this is not good, you must tell them to support you and not be negative about it as it will affect you (my parent used to taunt me and mock my choice for economics as a major, it did not help believe me).

Lastly, do not go into any major you do not have a passion for, no matter what anyone says because I am sure you will end up getting a subpar gpa anyway. Make a practical plan for your life after the degree. Do not listen to other people as much because they are not YOU.

I see a lot of issues and personal stuff going on, also, why are you focusing on English when physics is your aim? :-) Maybe take some time off other subjects and focus more on maths and physics as this is your aim. (Think you've already been admitted to the program based on your old grades right? will your english grade determine university admission anymore or not? ). No matter what, all problems have some solutions and we all things we shall have to live with, be strong, honest and work smart/hard and you will be fine.

I've somehow managed to convince my parents for astronomy ... okay not really. Someone else told them that a physics degree was a great idea so they started supporting me after that :|. But now I have their support! So, it's great! My mom told me she thinks I'm smart enough to make it for the first time ever ! So, that's a plus! I have a really bad habit of worrying and stressing out over little things. I really need to learn how to relax (luckily that school has therapy dogs!).
I've definitely heard about uni being really hard. The kids at my school that are doing physics (specifically the ones in the program I'm joining) said that they find it easy because they're doing the exact same stuff our teacher taught in grade 12 (maybe that's why my school finds physics hard). People at my old school are talking about how it's the easiest of the 3 sciences ... but I don't think it's supposed to be as easy as they're making it out to be, at least according to my physics teacher.
I definitely don't have a passion for anything else. As cliche as it sounds, I've been into Earth and space science since I was in junior kindergarten. My mom wouldn't let me bring home books about it so whenever my class had a library day, I would sit in the aisle and read as much as possible. I love it way too much to let go of it and I'm willing to push myself through the hell hole I'm about to enter next year. I'm so close to getting where I want to be, giving up because of my fears as an 18 year old seems kinda dumb to me, especially since I've planned for this since... forever really.

Yeah about English, I'm almost done! ( So close!) It's my last exam this semester so instead of concentrating on that, I'm going to bank on math and physics big time. On the other hand, unfortunately I got pushed into an extra curricular I do not want to do because of another extra curricular ( tutoring science) that I have planned for next semester - I need it for the other part of my application (I applied to a bachelor's of concurrent education WITH physics and astronomy). So, yikesss. I'm going to have to find a way out of this.
 
  • #11
Hey! Thank you all so much! I know no one asked for an update but I'm just so happy! My mark went up 8% in physics! :D
 
  • #12
Why wouldn't your mother let you bring home and read books about outer space?
 
  • #13
Randall Flagg said:
Why wouldn't your mother let you bring home and read books about outer space?
I really don't know, I never asked because I found a way around it. :/
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 102 ·
4
Replies
102
Views
9K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K