Is the Cheerios Effect Analogous to Gravity?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter InquiringMind
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Gravity
1 reply · 3K views · last reply
InquiringMind
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Is the warping of the fabric of space by masses, similar to the warping of the milk surface, that pulls those last few Cheerios together.:biggrin:

Green grid sheet curved downward by a large grey sphere, with a small moon at upper left and an asteroid on an orange curved path pulled toward Earth. Labels: "Moon orbiting around Earth's gravity well" and "Asteroid being pulled off its path into Earth's gravity well".


Photo of a red-rimmed bowl of milk with small Cheerios floating on the surface, several clustered together in groups near the edge.
 
The way Cheerios are attracted in a bowl of milk is actually a lot closer to how electromagnetic attraction/repulsion works. You can draw some parallels with gravity, and indeed, gravity works like a purely attractive version of electromagnetism to first order. But once you get into details, there are quite a few places where the analogy starts to break-down. Most importantly, gravity is related to curvature in space and time. Cheerios start to pull together even if they are static. There is a force pulling on them. Gravity requires motion. Granted, objects are moving mostly through time in all practical situations, but you still can't look it as just an attractive force. The objects don't actually experience a force, but rather continue in what appears to them to be a "straight line", called a geodesic.