Is the universe truly expanding?

  • Thread starter tressure
  • Start date
  • #1
31
0
Hello everyone, i am just bothered by the theory that our universe is expanding, if so i want to know, what substance is filling the void as our universe expands, and where does this substance come from,

Thank you
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
What is "the void" to which you refer, please?
 
  • #3
3,379
944
Space is expanding, but I don't know of any theory which infers that additional matter is being created as a result.
 
  • #4
31
0
For a thing to grow in size, expand ; something must be added into it... like a balloon. If you want a balloon to expand, u simply blow air into it. Dont you think the same thing should be happening if our universe is expanding?
 
  • #5
3,379
944
You could expand a balloon by placing it inside a contanier with less air density.
 
  • Like
Likes Yashbhatt
  • #6
31
0
What is "the void" to which you refer, please?
okay, you do know that as something expqnd space is created, and has to be filled up by something, when i say void, i refer to this space wich has to eventually be replaced by something
 
  • #7
31
0
okay, now you do know that space is vaccume, can you get less pressure/ density than vaccume?.
 
  • #8
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
Cosmological space is mostly a hard vacuum with 10^-6 molecules per cubic centimeter, or, inverting, 10^6 cubic centimeters per molecule.
 
  • #9
31
0
... i just wish you could answer my question, that is, what is getting filled into the space if it is growing
 
  • #10
3,379
944
Nothing additional has to be filling in the space, whatever atoms it already contains just get more spread out.
Same thing as when you place your balloon in a low pressure container.
You didn't need to put more air into the balloon, but it still got bigger.
 
Last edited:
  • #11
31
0
Okay, i assume you know about multiverse, there should be a boundry, that bounds everthing in our universe. If the universe is not expanding and its contants are being spread out, dont you think they would by now have spread outside of the universe?
 
  • #12
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
You are correct that there is a boundary between the universe and the hypothetical multiverse. That boundary is the limit of causation at lightspeed for the age of the universe. Practically, it is how far we can see, the universe's horizon.
 
  • #13
3,379
944
The multiverse is not known to be a fact, it's a possible explanation for some of the properties our universe has, but the existence of it has never been tested for,
Some think it cannot ever be tested for, and therefore it isn't really a scientific proposition at all.
However the expansion of the universe is a measurable fact.

... Must go now, I have visitors, I'm sure somebody else will like to assist wit your quesiton
 
  • #14
31
0
You are correct that there is a boundary between the universe and the hypothetical multiverse. That boundary is the limit of causation at lightspeed for the age of the universe. Practically, it is how far we can see, the universe's horizon.
ARe you saying that this boundry is not fixed?
 
  • #15
31
0
T
The multiverse is not known to be a fact, it's a possible explanation for some of the properties our universe has, but the existence of it has never been tested for,
Some think it cannot ever be tested for, and therefore it isn't really a scientific proposition at all.
However the expansion of the universe is a measurable fact.

... Must go now, I have visitors, I'm sure somebody else will like to assist wit your quesiton
THanx
 
  • #16
31
0
You are correct that there is a boundary between the universe and the hypothetical multiverse. That boundary is the limit of causation at lightspeed for the age of the universe. Practically, it is how far we can see, the universe's horizon.
I Think it is,logical to say that if realy the contants of the universe are moving apart and the universe is not expanding, then a few galaxies would be at that edge or outside
 
  • #17
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
Actually the large structures of the universe, galaxies and clusters and super clusters, are gravitationally bound together. It is the space between them that is expanding.
 
  • #18
31
0
Actually the large structures of the universe, galaxies and clusters and super clusters, are gravitationally bound together. It is the space between them that is expanding.
If thats the case then, whats being injected into space inorder for it to expand, i mean it cant just expand and expand, some substance has to be added into it!
 
  • #19
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
What is space? Was there space before the Big Bang? Will there be space during the hypothetical Big Crunch?
 
  • #20
31
0
What is space? Was there space before the Big Bang? Will there be space during the hypothetical Big Crunch?
Space is vaccum, does this vaccum expand? Where does it come from? if we measure it to be 15 today, and tomorrow it is 20 where did the extra 5 come from???
 
  • #21
31
0
What is space? Was there space before the Big Bang? Will there be space during the hypothetical Big Crunch?
No. Space i a property of big bang, remember reason why space is said to be expanding is due to.the observation that after it banged everything flew apart, but flew apart into what?
 
  • #22
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
No. Vacuum is the absence of stuff. Yes, stuff is roughly constant, already a very low density of stuff per space.
 
  • #23
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
It is NOT an observation! If there is only one singular thing then there doesn't have to be any space. If that singular thing is unchanging then there doesn't have to be any time.
 
  • #24
31
0
No. Vacuum is the absence of stuff. Yes, stuff is roughly constant, already a very low density of stuff per space.
IM gonna go to bed now. Thank you so much for helping solve this, i hope we can continue some time... cheers
 
  • #25
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
111
I commend to you Stanford University's Professor Leonard Susskind's streamed lecture series.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLQrxduI9Pds1fm91Dmn8x1lo-O_kpZGk8
He starts with classical mechanics and works through quantum entanglement, I believe the end of the formal series, and extends it with topics of current interest, Explanation of the Higgs Mechanism and The Holographic Principle.
 

Related Threads on Is the universe truly expanding?

  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
46
Views
9K
Replies
21
Views
17K
  • Last Post
3
Replies
69
Views
15K
  • Last Post
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
25
Views
7K
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
20
Views
7K
Top