There is a growing concern about the moderation of speculative posts on Physics Forums (PF), with some users feeling that the platform is becoming overly restrictive. Notably, individuals like Caroline Thompson and Eugene Shubert have faced bans for presenting non-standard ideas, raising questions about the forum's commitment to open discussion. Moderators emphasize the importance of maintaining high academic standards, which leads to the removal of posts deemed overly speculative or lacking scientific foundation. The forum aims to differentiate between sound speculation and unfounded claims, often directing less rigorous discussions to the Theory Development subforum. Overall, PF is striving to be a reputable platform for serious scientific discourse, prioritizing accuracy and peer-reviewed content.
So welcome back!