Learn to be a Jerk - Desperate for Change

  • Thread starter Thread starter khemix
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Jerk
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The thread discusses the challenges of being perceived as "too nice" and the desire for change in personal behavior, particularly in situations where participants feel taken advantage of. The conversation explores themes of assertiveness, self-worth, and interpersonal dynamics, with a focus on a specific incident involving a damaged television and the response to it.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses frustration over being too nice and feeling that it leads to negative outcomes, citing a specific incident with a cable technician.
  • Another participant suggests that the original poster could pursue compensation from the cable company rather than the technician directly.
  • Some participants argue that being assertive does not require being rude or aggressive, emphasizing the importance of polite communication.
  • There are differing views on whether kindness is perceived as weakness, with some asserting that it is often exploited by others.
  • One participant reflects on personal experiences of balancing kindness with assertiveness, suggesting that physical fitness has contributed positively to their self-image.
  • Another participant challenges the original poster's self-perception, suggesting that low self-worth may be influencing their behavior.
  • Some participants agree that being overly accommodating can lead to being seen as a pushover, while others defend the value of kindness.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement and disagreement regarding the nature of kindness and assertiveness. While some advocate for a more assertive approach, others emphasize that kindness can coexist with assertiveness. The discussion remains unresolved on the best way to navigate these interpersonal dynamics.

Contextual Notes

Participants reference personal experiences and feelings, which may not be universally applicable. The discussion includes varying definitions of kindness and assertiveness, and the implications of these traits on self-worth and interpersonal relationships are not fully explored.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals struggling with assertiveness in personal or professional relationships, those interested in self-improvement, and anyone navigating the balance between kindness and self-advocacy may find this discussion relevant.

  • #31
i haven enough self-respect (whatever that really is) and i value myself enough. my mom is not abusive, today i just really pushed her buttons. i don't think i have issues with testosterone because i am quite aggressive otherwise (just not with people, except sometimes family). i think i have enough confidence, i talk to people on the bus all the time about weather and sports.

i don't know if i fear dissaproval, i just really emphasize with whoever i talk and read their emotions. i don't desperately want them to like me, its just that i don't want them feeling down.

Chi Meson said:
What they said, you jerk! (Is this helping?)

As far as being "too nice," I sympathize. Is your nicety also combined with an ironically quick temper? Mine is.

This is me:
nice nice nice nice nice nice nice nice A-HOLE sad nice nice nice nice nice

you're the only one who strikes a chord with me. yeah, i have an ironic quick temper. there will be one day where i treat people like total crap... as if i don't care, then act nice for 2 weeks.

ill try running, but i honestly don't see how it will solve any of my problems.

Leah said:
Being a jerk is not too pleasing to me. I'd rather have a nice guy figure out the problem. And you do have a problem with the tv repair, so just be nice like you are and allow the company to solve it. As my mother has told me before..you catch more flies with honey than vinegar.

i think being a jerk is pleasing actually. i don't mean the kind that gets in your face and talks obnoxiously, but the care free attitude grabs everyones attention. its been my experience that people like jerks, as if they try extra hard to befriend them... and value them more once all the work was put in. i actually tried this out with my friend at work when we were dealing with customers. i pretended to ignore this moderately attractive girl while discussing products and she was talking to me a lot. as soon as i caved in and smiled, telling her i heard everything she said, she was gone.

anyway i don't want to become a complete a-hole, even if it gets me more friends. but i do want to be able to stick up for myself.
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
  • #32
khemix said:
my mom is not abusive, today i just really pushed her buttons.

Seriously, I thought you were trolling. But if you are sincere you should seek help. Your mother is abusive. Healthy people don't have a slap me button.
 
  • #33
khemix said:
my mom is not abusive, today i just really pushed her buttons.

Actually, if someone hits you and calls you a name like that over a television, or over anything else really, yeah, that's abusive. Not, like, the FBI has to be sent into your town to take every child into custody kind of abusive as in the FLDS church in Texas, but that specific event is an abusive incident. I mean you would never do that to someone else, would you? Perhaps part of the reason why you're attentive to the feelings of others is that you feel as though sometimes your mom is not attentive to your feelings.

But it sounds to me as though, separate from anything having to do with attending to other people's feelings, you have issues with being too timid. I have some timidity in my nature as well and I'd say that some of the best things that have helped me to overcome that have been cases when I've had a stupid, short-tempered boss who I've gotten into a shouting match with when I'm certain he's treating me unfairly (I've had the misfortune to have several bosses like this.) But unfortunately, I can't think of any way to reproduce that kind of experience on purpose.
 
  • #34
i don't know guys, maybe this is just passive aggressive behaviour against the mom. going behind her back and trying to let the guy off for destroying her property... that's kind of a jerk thing to do when looked at from her perspective.
 
  • #35
Redemption time. Call the company and say that the guy knocked over your tv. The only way to be a jerk is to do it now and not get screwed out of 2000$!
 
  • #36
Proton Soup said:
i don't know guys, maybe this is just passive aggressive behaviour against the mom. going behind her back and trying to let the guy off for destroying her property... that's kind of a jerk thing to do when looked at from her perspective.

Ironically, you just suggested that khemix is passive-aggressive in a passive-aggressive fashion, speaking of him in the third person as though he isn't going read what you're writing. (Not saying that what you suggest is impossible, just pointing out the irony.)
 
  • #37
CaptainQuasar said:
Ironically, you just suggested that khemix is passive-aggressive in a passive-aggressive fashion, speaking of him in the third person as though he isn't going read what you're writing. (Not saying that what you suggest is impossible, just pointing out the irony.)


that's OK, i like irony.
 
  • #38
khemix said:
i haven enough self-respect (whatever that really is)
No, you clearly don't.
khemix said:
and i value myself enough.
Again, you clearly don't. You value the cable guy's happiness and approval over the work you/your mother put into earn the money to purchase the television.
khemix said:
my mom is not abusive, today i just really pushed her buttons.
Yes, she is. As a father I will say that (I hope) I will never strike my son in anger. I do believe in spanking or a slap as a punishment for some misbehavior, as long as the rules are clearly delineated beforehand. To slap your child in anger is abuse, plain and simple. If this has happened on more than one occasion, I would recommend talking to your local law enforcement about it. If this is the only time it has ever happened, I would recommend finding someone you trust to talk to about it, so at least someone outside the family knows what happened. Further, a parent calling a child a (female body part) is verbal abuse, no matter how you look at it.
khemix said:
i don't think i have issues with testosterone
I would speak to a doctor about this one. Maybe see if you can get an appointment with a psychologist.
khemix said:
because i am quite aggressive otherwise (just not with people, except sometimes family). i think i have enough confidence, i talk to people on the bus all the time about weather and sports.
Being able to make small talk is not the same as having confidence, self respect, or standing up for yourself.
khemix said:
i don't know if i fear dissaproval, i just really emphasize with whoever i talk and read their emotions.
You value their feelings/emotions more than your own.
khemix said:
i don't desperately want them to like me, its just that i don't want them feeling down.
Again, you would rather yourself feel down than them (anyone else noticing a pattern here)
khemix said:
yeah, i have an ironic quick temper. there will be one day where i treat people like total crap... as if i don't care, then act nice for 2 weeks.
Self esteem issues, maybe mildly bipolar? See a professional, we can't diagnose you online.
khemix said:
i think being a jerk is pleasing actually.
Not as pleasing as real self esteem and self respect.
khemix said:
i don't mean the kind that gets in your face and talks obnoxiously, but the care free attitude grabs everyones attention. its been my experience that people like jerks, as if they try extra hard to befriend them... and value them more once all the work was put in. i actually tried this out with my friend at work when we were dealing with customers. i pretended to ignore this moderately attractive girl while discussing products and she was talking to me a lot. as soon as i caved in and smiled, telling her i heard everything she said, she was gone.
I think you misperceive people who have confidence, and stand up for themselves as jerks. The two are not the same thing, get that notion out of your head.
khemix said:
anyway i don't want to become a complete a-hole, even if it gets me more friends. but i do want to be able to stick up for myself.
About the only sensible thing you said in this post.

Sorry if I'm being particularly blunt or tactless, but I'm being as honest as I can. Hopefully you will consider what I've written.
 
  • #39
khemix said:
you're the only one who strikes a chord with me. yeah, i have an ironic quick temper. there will be one day where i treat people like total crap... as if i don't care, then act nice for 2 weeks.
Too emotional, too empathetic. It's a horrible characteristic to have as an adolescent. Things will get better if you want them too, but give it time. You must must must do something that you can get good at. It doesn't need to impress everyone, but it should do more that just impress yourself. Rock climbing, mountain biking, skateboarding whatever, but don't force yourself. In the back of your head, you have to hear yourself saying, "yeah, I'd like to do that." Otherwise it's not fun, just another task.

It needs to be an endurance kind of exercise. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endorphin" do exist, and they are the cheapest anti-depressant on the market. I run. You don't have to, but everything else is more expensive. And yes, the physique you get is important.

ill try running, but i honestly don't see how it will solve any of my problems.
you may be surprised. give yourself 2 weeks, five times a week, 20 minutes, slow. Don't time anything at first, don't bother stretching or all that crap, just go, start slow. If your get tired, slow down to a crawl but don't stop.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #40
Thread locked pending moderation.

Zz.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 76 ·
3
Replies
76
Views
13K
  • · Replies 76 ·
3
Replies
76
Views
8K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
6K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
11K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
6K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
5K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
2K