Length contraction & time dilation

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the concepts of length contraction and time dilation in the context of special relativity, specifically addressing the question of how it is theoretically possible for a person to travel a distance of one million light years within their lifetime.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the implications of traveling at relativistic speeds and how time and distance are perceived differently by stationary and moving observers. Some suggest considering the problem from multiple frames of reference, while others raise questions about the feasibility of such travel within a human lifetime.

Discussion Status

There are various attempts to clarify the concepts involved, with some participants providing hints about the nature of time and distance in relativity. The discussion includes calculations and considerations of how distances appear contracted to a moving observer, but no consensus has been reached on a definitive approach or solution.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the necessity of showing prior work or thoughts in accordance with forum rules, and some express confusion regarding the implications of traveling at or near the speed of light, including the effects of gravity and acceleration on the traveler.

monp
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Using the concept of length contraction and time dilation explain how is it possible to travel a distance of 1mln light years during the life of a single person?

thanks for any help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
monp said:
Using the concept of length contraction and time dilation explain how is it possible to travel a distance of 1mln light years during the life of a single person?

thanks for any help

Is this a homework problem or are you just curious?

There are two approaches.

Hint 1: The life-time they're talking about is the life-time of the person doing the traveling i.e. going really really fast in the context of special relativity!

Hint 2:The distance they're talking about is the distance as measured by someone not making the trip and so not moving really really fast.
 
monp said:
Using the concept of length contraction and time dilation explain how is it possible to travel a distance of 1mln light years during the life of a single person?

thanks for any help

As per the rules of the forum, you must show some of your thoughts or work before being helped.


To get you started: consider the situation from two different point of views.

Let's say from Earth, looking at a spaceship travellling at a huge speed toward a star one million light years away. How could the people make it to that star in their own lifetime even though the spaceship is not traveling faster than c? (describe things as seen from Earth, without changing frame!)

Then look at how things look from the point of view of the people in the spaceship.
 
i' ve calculated that the light need 3,15*1010^13seconds (which is actually about 998858 and nearly six months)to travel a distance of 1mln light years( which is 9,46*10^21meters). The lifetime of single person is about 70 years, which is 2,207*10^9seconds. The person to travle that distance in 70 years should have a velocity much bigger than speed of light which is actually impossible for me, also when this person reach the speed of light he or she will have the gravity of black hole, so I really can't imagine how is possible to travel such a big distance. please give me some explanation.
greatings
 
monp said:
i' ve calculated that the light need 3,15*1010^13seconds (which is actually about 998858 and nearly six months)to travel a distance of 1mln light years( which is 9,46*10^21meters).
Realize that for a moving observer, distances will appear contracted. Say the distance from Earth to Planet X is 1 million light-years (as measured in the earth-planet frame). If you are zooming along in your rocket at a speed of 0.99c (with respect to Earth), what would you measure that distance to be? How long would it take you to cover it, according to your clocks?

What if your speed was 0.999c? Or 0.9999c?

And so on...
 
monp said:
i' ve calculated that the light need 3,15*1010^13seconds (which is actually about 998858 and nearly six months)to travel a distance of 1mln light years( which is 9,46*10^21meters). The lifetime of single person is about 70 years, which is 2,207*10^9seconds. The person to travle that distance in 70 years should have a velocity much bigger than speed of light which is actually impossible for me, also when this person reach the speed of light he or she will have the gravity of black hole, so I really can't imagine how is possible to travel such a big distance. please give me some explanation.
greatings


Light need one milion years to travel one milion light years.
 
malawi_glenn said:
Light need one milion years to travel one milion light years.
which is 3,15*10^15seconds.

according to Doc Al's if i use the equation for the length contraction 'my road' will really shorter but it'll also be very long distance:/([9,46*10^21*(1-0,9999^2)^1/2]=1,33*10^20)don't have any new ideas
 
Last edited:
monp said:
which is 3,15*10^15seconds:!):smile:


yes of course, but why convert to seconds? Then convert 70years to seconds.. :)
 
malawi_glenn said:
Light need one milion years to travel one milion light years.
For a "stationary" observer who measures the distance to be 1 million light-years, the time for light to travel will be 1 million years. But not for a moving observer, who sees that distance "shortened" due to Lorentz contraction.
 
  • #10
Doc Al said:
For a "stationary" observer who measures the distance to be 1 million light-years, the time for light to travel will be 1 million years. But not for a moving observer, who sees that distance "shortened" due to Lorentz contraction.


yes of course.
 
  • #11
monp,
Again is this a homework problem or are you just curious?

Keep in mind that the word "relativity" in Special Relativity means that distances and durations you measure or define are relative to your velocity. You see two stars as 1 million ly apart. I --when in motion relative to you-- will see their distances as different. You seeing me traveling between these stars note that it takes me > 1 million years. I see time passing differently.

How different will depend on my speed relative to you.

You need to find a book or webpage on SR and work this out for yourself or you will not gain any understanding. Basically you look at the two events, Me leaving Earth, and Me arriving at the distant star.

You having stayed on Earth see these events as being [itex]\Delta x=1000000 ly[/itex] apart in distance and [itex]\Delta t = 1000000/V[/itex] years in duration where [itex]V[/itex] is my velocity in light-years per year (< 1 and so the speed of light c= 1).

Now work out what my [itex]\Delta x'[/itex] and [itex]\Delta t'[/itex] are using the Lorentz transformation formulas. Especially work out [itex]\Delta t'[/itex] in terms of [itex]\Delta x = 10^6 ly[/itex] and [itex]V[/itex].

Or better yet, work out the "effective velocity" (how far I travel as you see it divided by how much time I see passing) in terms of the actual velocity:

I give it here in an obscured form in terms of hyperbolic trig. You should work out the explicit formula and see if via calculator we get the same numbers:

[tex]V_{eff} = \cosh(\tanh^{-1}(V))[/tex]
[tex]V = \tanh(\cosh^{-1}(V_{eff}))[/tex]

But given I want to make the trip in say 10 years (my time) I need an "effective velocity" of 100,000 light-years per year. This then gives

[itex]V = \tanh(\cosh^{-1}(10^5)) \simeq 0.99999999994999999999874999999994[/itex] light-years/year i.e. % of the speed of light.

Note that the actual velocity is always less than 1=speed of light in these units.

BTW, Here is a much harder related problem. Assuming someone can only stand say 4 g's of sustained acceleration, how far could they travel in their lifetime of say 100 years assuming they don't need to slow down at their destination? (Note that [itex]1g \simeq 1.03 \frac{ly}{y^2}[/itex])
Assume they start from rest in the frame where we are defining the distance traveled.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 36 ·
2
Replies
36
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 63 ·
3
Replies
63
Views
6K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K