Li-Ion vs LiPo… why not both?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Flyboy
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the suitability of Li-Ion versus LiPo batteries for electric RC aircraft, particularly for endurance flights. LiPo batteries excel in high-power applications, while Li-Ion batteries offer better energy density for lower throttle use, making them ideal for long-range FPV drones. A proposed solution involves paralleling a small LiPo battery with a Li-Ion battery to provide the necessary current for takeoff, though this presents challenges due to differing voltages and current outputs. Concerns about added weight and complexity suggest that alternatives like using a catapult for takeoff may be more effective. Overall, while combining both battery types is theoretically possible, it requires careful design considerations and may not yield significant advantages.
Flyboy
Gold Member
Messages
423
Reaction score
626
TL;DR Summary
Can you parallel a Li-Ion and a LiPo battery?
I’m looking into electric RC aircraft, especially for endurance flights, and I keep running into a debate over what is the best battery design for a high-endurance/long range electric plane.

I have gathered that LiPo batteries are outstanding for high-power applications, such as racers, eVTOL, etc, where you need large amounts of power constantly.

On the other hand, Li-Ion batteries are increasingly used for high endurance FPV drones that are not running wide-open throttle, as the lower current output of the batteries is less of an issue, and the better energy density is advantageous.

I would love to use Li-Ion batteries for a future design where endurance and efficiency are the driving factors, but I am concerned about the limited current output, especially at takeoff. My thought was to parallel the main Li-Ion battery with a small LiPo battery that would provide the extra current needed for takeoff and climb out before switching to the Li-Ion, but I have seen no examples of this having been done before. Thus, I am wondering why it isn’t done. Obviously, there’s the issue of different cell voltages and current outputs, so directly paralleling them is probably not safe, but given the current state of solid state relays, it would seem to be a relatively simple task to make them separate circuits that would switch between them after you reach a safe cruising state.

I am not an electrical expert by any stretch of the imagination, so what am I missing aside from the additional weight and complexity?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Endurance flight is about keeping weight as low as possible, so it is probably much wiser to use longer runway (or start from a catapult, even DIY style) than to make model heavier.

1712007272045.png
 
I would come at it from another direction. You want a high power/weight ratio. You can do that by either getting the power up, or the weight down. A battery's power depends on its volume, but a battery also has a casing: a non-power producing region that scales as the area. But still adds weight. So one big battery is, all other things being equal, better than two smaller ones.

Exotic batteries, like Lithium-Polymer or Lithium-Metal-Phosphate do a little better than Lithium-Ion, but not hugely better. Enough better to justify the additional dead weight? I don't know, but probably not.

If you have someone who is willing to build a batter for you, I'd look into making the battery casing some other part of the aircraft, so it does double duty. Also, there is a trade-off between recharge capacity and power density. If you only wanted to charge it, say, 30 times, you could do better than one you want to change 500 times. Maybe.
 
Flyboy said:
...to parallel the main Li-Ion battery with a small LiPo battery that would provide the extra current needed for takeoff and climb out before switching to the Li-Ion
If it's to 'switch to', then it's a bit more complicated parallel then a simple 'parallel battery'. And given the different chemistry/parameters, some kind of switching/matching would be clearly required.

Doable, but not trivial. I too would rather recommend a catapult or such as @Borek already suggested.

Maybe you could take a look at (proper) military drones.
 
Last edited:
I have recently moved into a new (rather ancient) house and had a few trips of my Residual Current breaker. I dug out my old Socket tester which tell me the three pins are correct. But then the Red warning light tells me my socket(s) fail the loop test. I never had this before but my last house had an overhead supply with no Earth from the company. The tester said "get this checked" and the man said the (high but not ridiculous) earth resistance was acceptable. I stuck a new copper earth...
Thread 'Electromagnet magnetic field issue'
Hi Guys We are a bunch a mechanical engineers trying to build a simple electromagnet. Our design is based on a very similar magnet. However, our version is about 10 times less magnetic and we are wondering why. Our coil has exactly same length, same number of layers and turns. What is possibly wrong? PIN and bracket are made of iron and are in electrical contact, exactly like the reference design. Any help will be appreciated. Thanks. edit: even same wire diameter and coil was wounded by a...
Thread 'Beauty of old electrical and measuring things, etc.'
Even as a kid, I saw beauty in old devices. That made me want to understand how they worked. I had lots of old things that I keep and now reviving. Old things need to work to see the beauty. Here's what I've done so far. Two views of the gadgets shelves and my small work space: Here's a close up look at the meters, gauges and other measuring things: This is what I think of as surface-mount electrical components and wiring. The components are very old and shows how...
Back
Top