Light is NOT constant relative to the source.

1 reply · 1K views · last reply
glover_m
Messages
9
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Two diagrams (a) and (b) of a pair of stars A and B orbiting centre C, with instantaneous velocity arrows and a 'To Earth' arrow; labels A1 and A2 mark stellar positions, and a radius r is shown.


Homework Equations



How do you come up with 2ud/(c^2-u^2)

The Attempt at a Solution



Here's my issue with this problem: I would expect that for the light from A1 to reach Earth it would be d/u-c, and the time for the light of A2 to reach Earth would be d/u-c + T/2 = d/(u-c)
+ pir/u

Therefore Delta A would be (pi)(radius)/u

This isn't the case however, am I missing something? Shouldn't the difference in times be equal to half the period of rotation?
 
glover_m said:
Here's my issue with this problem: I would expect that for the light from A1 to reach Earth it would be d/u-c, and the time for the light of A2 to reach Earth would be d/u-c + T/2 = d/(u-c)
+ pir/u

shouldn't it be d/(u+c) from A1, since the star is moving towards the earth.
If you use that you get the difference from your text.