Looking for an English translation of Levi-Civita's 1926 paper "Sur l'écart géodésique" ("On the geodesic deviation")

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter JimWhoKnew
  • Start date Start date
JimWhoKnew
Messages
266
Reaction score
153
I don't know what is the right sub-form for this question, so I post it here.

I'm looking for an English translation of Levi-Civita's 1926 paper "Sur l'écart géodésique" ("On the geodesic deviation"). Surprisingly, I couldn't find any translation on the web, although it is cited by many texts dealing with Fermi's coordinates.
Here is a link from Wikipedia to the original text. The paper begins on page 433 (book's numbering). Free OCR scans of the individual paper can also be found, but I'm not certain whether they are legit.
I tried to obtain a translation by using chatgpt and claude. Claude provided a readable summary, but unsatisfactory. The display of equations and inline mathematical symbols is poor.

I believe that many have faced a similar problem before. Is there a good tool (AI or otherwise) that provides a fine sentence-by-sentence translation, with a nice (LaTeX-like) display of the math?

I'd expect that with today's capabilities, such a task should be trivial. Am I that wrong?

Help will be appreciated.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker
Physics news on Phys.org
maybe tools like Mathpix Snip could help, i read somewhere that they’re very helpful. it can turn those equations into clean LaTeX that you can input the data into Claude 3.5 Sonnet for a context-sensitive translation.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: JimWhoKnew
Try google gemini.... with "Translate to English, together with typeset equations, into a pdf."
but you'll probably have to break up the document into chunks....
e.g., i want a line by line translation of the introduction and section 1 , including typeset equations, maintaining the rough page layout (so I can compare with the original)... in pdf format.
... of course, you'll have to check for correctness and hopefully-no-hallucinations.

(A few weeks ago, I was impressed when I asked it to render my handwritten notes as typeset equations.)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: JimWhoKnew
Thanks @yisyelkencisi and @robphy.

The title of the thread was changed by the admins so it suits this specific forum better, but actually I'm interested in the more general question of finding an easy-to-use "mature" translation tool (and the new title may chase readers who are familiar with solutions away). If it was only the Levi-Civita paper, by the time it will take me to satisfactorily tweak the "general" engines, I can pay a French-speaking student for a manual translation.

Some commercial tools are available online. I thought that PF members may know more about this subject.
 
JimWhoKnew said:
Thanks @yisyelkencisi and @robphy.

The title of the thread was changed by the admins so it suits this specific forum better, but actually I'm interested in the more general question of finding an easy-to-use "mature" translation tool (and the new title may chase readers who are familiar with solutions away). If it was only the Levi-Civita paper, by the time it will take me to satisfactorily tweak the "general" engines, I can pay a French-speaking student for a manual translation.

Some commercial tools are available online. I thought that PF members may know more about this subject.

I subscribe to Gemini Pro.
What I had posted in my reply is what I had tried,

robphy said:
(I drag-dropped a pdf of the section from your pdf.)

i want a line by line translation of the introduction and section 1 , including typeset equations, maintaining the rough page layout (so I can compare with the original)... in pdf format.
Gemini Pro said:
Your line-by-line translation containing both the Introduction and Section 1 is ready!

I have combined the two sections into a single document, formatted line-by-line to match the page breaks and visual layout of the original text, including all typeset equations.
Here are low-resolution images of some of the output.
1777555364450.webp
1777555469699.webp
1777555601673.webp
 
Last edited: