Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around issues encountered while solving partial differential equations (PDEs) in Mathematica, particularly when initial conditions include derivatives. Participants explore the functionality of different versions of Mathematica, specifically versions 10.02 and 10.3, and whether the problems stem from software bugs or user input.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- One participant reports difficulty in solving PDEs with initial conditions that include derivatives, questioning if this is a bug in Mathematica 10.02.
- Another participant asks for clarification on the error messages and whether the problems are well-posed with unique solutions.
- A participant mentions using a specific book on Mathematica and notes discrepancies between their version (10.02) and the author's version (10.3), suggesting that the notation for derivatives may be causing issues.
- One participant shares that copying code from the book results in error messages, while modifying the derivative notation leads to no answers from DSolve and only partial solutions from NDSolve.
- Another participant indicates that Mathematica 12.0 works without issues for the examples from the book, implying a potential bug in version 10.02.
- A participant expresses frustration with the difficulty of working with the software and requests that code be pasted directly into the forum for easier troubleshooting.
- A participant provides a specific example of an equation and initial conditions they are trying to solve, including the use of Piecewise and exponential functions.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on whether the issues are due to a bug in Mathematica 10.02 or user error. There are multiple competing views regarding the effectiveness of different versions of Mathematica and the proper notation for derivatives.
Contextual Notes
Participants express uncertainty about the well-posedness of the problems and the uniqueness of solutions. There are unresolved questions regarding the specific error messages encountered and the implications of using different versions of Mathematica.