Maximum number of characters in thread title

  • Context: Complaint 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Wrichik Basu
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
8 replies · 2K views
Messages
2,188
Reaction score
2,694
The maximum number of characters allowed in a thread title seems to be 70. I have often faced trouble while trying to maintain this limit and make a meaningful title at the same time. Can this be increased to 100 characters at least? The limit for the thread summary is 250 characters, so 100 characters for the title seems to be a good number.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
fresh_42 said:
What can you say in 100 what you couldn't in 70?
Consider this title: "Java is introducing jpackage: a command-line tool for creating executables from jar files" (89 characters). I can replace "creating executables from" with "packaging", and that makes it 73 characters. I can further replace "Java is" with "Java's", but I am not very fond of contractions in the title.

Someone will surely be able to contract the title further, but I cannot keep posting titles here, requesting people to shorten it out.
fresh_42 said:
Nobody wants to read a novel in the title.
You have an insight article with the title "A Journey to The Manifold SU(2): Differentiation, Spheres and Fiber Bundles". In my opinion, this is not a novel, although it is 75 characters long.

100 is just a round figure. Even making the length 80 or 90 characters will be helpful in most cases.
 
Wrichik Basu said:
The maximum number of characters allowed in a thread title seems to be 70.
I've noticed that after I create a new thread with its title, etc., that I can go back later and edit the title and make it longer. Have you tried that? Maybe give that a try to see what the maximum is for an edited title. It may be a Mentor superpower, or it may be available to everybody...
 
  • Love
Likes   Reactions: Wrichik Basu
berkeman said:
I've noticed that after I create a new thread with its title, etc., that I can go back later and edit the title and make it longer. Have you tried that?
Nope, because I didn't know the title can be made longer if I edit it later. Just tried it in this thread, and the limit was 150 characters. Thanks a ton! Problem solved.
 
Wrichik Basu said:
Consider this title: "Java is introducing jpackage: a command-line tool for creating executables from jar files" (89 characters). I can replace "creating executables from" with "packaging", and that makes it 73 characters. I can further replace "Java is" with "Java's", but I am not very fond of contractions in the title.

Someone will surely be able to contract the title further, but I cannot keep posting titles here, requesting people to shorten it out.
".exe files from .jar files by jpackage" Where is the problem?
You have an insight article with the title "A Journey to The Manifold SU(2): Differentiation, Spheres and Fiber Bundles". In my opinion, this is not a novel, although it is 75 characters long.
That is title (insight) and subtitle (part 1). Transcripted to a thread it would have been title and summary.
100 is just a round figure. Even making the length 80 or 90 characters will be helpful in most cases.
And I think 50 would be sufficient. Also a nice round number. Babylonians might have considered 60 a nice round number. Or 32 measured in bytes. Or 36, a word. This is meanwhile hardly an argument. The rule for titles is: the shorter the good.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pbuk
Wrichik Basu said:
Nope, because I didn't know the title can be made longer if I edit it later. Just tried it in this thread, and the limit was 150 characters. Thanks a ton! Problem solved.
But please keep in mind that lots of long thread titles will clutter up the forum, so still try to keep the title fairly brief but very descriptive. Just as 1-2 word titles are not descriptive and may prevent folks from clicking into the thread, a long verbose title may have the same effect. :wink:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Wrichik Basu