Modeling with exponential and logarithmic functions help?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around applying Newton's Law of Cooling to determine the time of death based on temperature readings taken at specific times. The problem involves understanding the relationship between the temperature of a deceased individual and the ambient temperature over time.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the correct interpretation of variables in the cooling equation, particularly the definition of time in relation to the time of death and the coroner's arrival. There are attempts to solve for the cooling constant k and the time of death using temperature data.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on how to set up the equations correctly, while others are exploring different interpretations of the variables involved. There is an ongoing exchange of ideas about the best approach to take in solving for k and t, with no explicit consensus reached yet.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the importance of clarifying the definitions of variables, particularly the initial temperature and the reference time for t. There is also a recognition of the need to derive two equations from the temperature readings at different times to solve for the unknowns.

camp3r101
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Modeling with exponential and logarithmic functions help?

Homework Statement


Use Newton's Lay of Cooling, T = C + (T0 - C)e-kt, to solve this exercise. At 9:00 A.M., a coroner arrived at the home of a person who had died during the night. The temperature of the room was 70 degrees F, and at the time of death the person had a body temperature of 98.6 degrees F. The coroner took the body's temperature at 9:30 A.M., at which time it was 85.6 degrees F, and again at 10:00 A.M., when it was 82.7 degrees F. At what time did the person die?


Homework Equations


T = C + (T0 - C)e-kt
If you do not know what the variable's mean...these are their meanings:
T = temperature of a heated object
C = constant temperature of the surrounding medium (the ambient temp)
T0 = initial temperature of the heated object
k = negative constant associated with the cooling object
t = time (in minutes)

The Attempt at a Solution


I tried solving for k by doing:
Steps (I plugged all the values into their corresponding places):

85.6 = 70 + (98.6 - 70)e-k(30)
15.6 = 28.6e-30k
0.5454545455 = e-30k
ln(0.5454545455) = ln(e-30k)
ln(0.5454545455) = -30k
k = (ln(0.5454545455)/(-30))
k = 0.0202045268


After getting this...i do not know what to do next...of even if I did the process of anything correctly as yet.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


camp3r101 said:

Homework Statement


Use Newton's Lay of Cooling, T = C + (T0 - C)e-kt, to solve this exercise. At 9:00 A.M., a coroner arrived at the home of a person who had died during the night. The temperature of the room was 70 degrees F, and at the time of death the person had a body temperature of 98.6 degrees F. The coroner took the body's temperature at 9:30 A.M., at which time it was 85.6 degrees F, and again at 10:00 A.M., when it was 82.7 degrees F. At what time did the person die?


Homework Equations


T = C + (T0 - C)e-kt
If you do not know what the variable's mean...these are their meanings:
T = temperature of a heated object
C = constant temperature of the surrounding medium (the ambient temp)
T0 = initial temperature of the heated object
k = negative constant associated with the cooling object
t = time (in minutes)
Excellent! Writing them all out like this is a very good idea- even on your home work paper. Not every one uses the same symbols. One criticism- you say "t= time (in minutes)" but do not say "time from what?" From what you write later, t appears to be the time (in minutes) after 9:00. You should say that.

The Attempt at a Solution


I tried solving for k by doing:
Steps (I plugged all the values into their corresponding places):

85.6 = 70 + (98.6 - 70)e-k(30)
NO. You don't know what the temperature of the body was at 9:00- you are told that " at the time of death the person had a body temperature of 98.6 degrees F" and you don't know when the time of death was. If you had said "t= time (in minutes) after death until the Coroner arrived, at 9:00", you would have
85.6= 70+ (98.6- 70)e-k(t+ 30)
and
82.7= 70+ (98.6- 70)e-k(t+ 60)

That gives you two equations to solve for k and t. Subtracting t minutes from 9:00 gives you the time of death.

15.6 = 28.6e-30k
0.5454545455 = e-30k
ln(0.5454545455) = ln(e-30k)
ln(0.5454545455) = -30k
k = (ln(0.5454545455)/(-30))
k = 0.0202045268


After getting this...i do not know what to do next...of even if I did the process of anything correctly as yet.
 


HallsofIvy said:
Excellent! Writing them all out like this is a very good idea- even on your home work paper. Not every one uses the same symbols. One criticism- you say "t= time (in minutes)" but do not say "time from what?" From what you write later, t appears to be the time (in minutes) after 9:00. You should say that.

Oh yeah...sorry I didn't think about that. It helps to clarify those things sometimes. I'll remember.

NO. You don't know what the temperature of the body was at 9:00- you are told that " at the time of death the person had a body temperature of 98.6 degrees F" and you don't know when the time of death was. If you had said "t= time (in minutes) after death until the Coroner arrived, at 9:00", you would have
85.6= 70+ (98.6- 70)e-k(t+ 30)
and
82.7= 70+ (98.6- 70)e-k(t+ 60)

Ohhh I see now haha

That gives you two equations to solve for k and t. Subtracting t minutes from 9:00 gives you the time of death.

Which values of k ant t do I use to find the time of death?
Do I use both; do I add both t values together and then subtract from 9:00 ??
 


HallsofIvy said:
If you had said "t= time (in minutes) after death until the Coroner arrived, at 9:00", you would have
85.6= 70+ (98.6- 70)e-k(t+ 30)
and
82.7= 70+ (98.6- 70)e-k(t+ 60)

camp3r101: while what HallsofIvy said is correct, I wouldn't do it this way, because you defined T0 as the initial temperature of the object... that is to say, the temperature at t = 0. I would define t as simply the number of minutes after death. So the equations I would write are
85.6 = 70 + (98.6 - 70)e^{-kt}
for 09:30am, and
82.7 = 70 + (98.6 - 70)e^{-k(t + 30)}
for 10:00am.

camp3r101 said:
Which values of k ant t do I use to find the time of death?
Do I use both; do I add both t values together and then subtract from 9:00 ??
No. (The hints I'm going to give may be too much, so apologies to the mods in advance.)

Take my 1st equation and simplify it a bit:
15.6 = 28.6e^{-kt}

Take my 2nd equation and simplify:
12.7 = 28.6e^{-k(t + 30)}
12.7 = 28.6e^{-kt - 30k}

Use property of exponents:
12.7 = \frac{28.6e^{-kt}}{e^{30k}}

Notice the numerator? That equals 15.6, from the first equation, so we substitute:
12.7 = \frac{15.6}{e^{30k}}

Now I'll shut up. Solve for k, and plug this in back into
15.6 = 28.6e^{-kt}
and solve for t. Remember that this t value corresponds to 09:30am, so subtract to find the time of death.
 
Last edited:


eumyang said:
camp3r101: while what HallsofIvy said is correct, I wouldn't do it this way, because you defined T0 as the initial temperature of the object... that is to say, the temperature at t = 0. I would define t as simply the number of minutes after death. So the equations I would write are
85.6 = 70 + (98.6 - 70)e^{-kt}
for 09:30am, and
82.7 = 70 + (98.6 - 70)e^{-k(t + 30)}
for 10:00am.


No. (The hints I'm going to give may be too much, so apologies to the mods in advance.)

Take my 1st equation and simplify it a bit:
15.6 = 28.6e^{-kt}

Take my 2nd equation and simplify:
12.7 = 28.6e^{-k(t + 30)}
12.7 = 28.6e^{-kt - 30k}

Use property of exponents:
12.7 = \frac{28.6e^{-kt}}{e^{30k}}

Notice the numerator? That equals 15.6, from the first equation, so we substitute:
12.7 = \frac{15.6}{e^{30k}}

Now I'll shut up. Solve for k, and plug this in back into
15.6 = 28.6e^{-kt}
and solve for t. Remember that this t value corresponds to 09:30am, so subtract to find the time of death.

DANNGGG! You guys are soo much help! Much thanks to you!
I see what steps I didn't take. Thanks again! :)
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 131 ·
5
Replies
131
Views
11K
Replies
2
Views
11K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K