# Need help with statics problem -- Structure to hold 1300 pounds

## Summary:

Trying to build a structure but not sure if i am doing it correctly

## Main Question or Discussion Point

So given a force F that is at r1/2, distances y, r1,r2,and r3. What is x?

Related General Engineering News on Phys.org
berkeman
Mentor
What is the context of your question? Is this for schoolwork?

Im trying to build a structure that can hold a 1300 lb supersack full of walnuts for work.

phinds
Gold Member
2019 Award
What is x?
Since you have given us no idea what constrains you want to put on x, how could we know? What is it you are trying to achieve?

davenn
Does x need to have a constraint? Its a statics problem. I figured you sum up the forces in the x direction, sum up the forces in the y direction and sum of the moments and solve for x. Seems pretty straight forward im just trying to check if i did it right so i want to see how someone who knows what they are doing, does it? The one thing i realized i left out is the angle of those angled beams. They should be 45 degrees.

Last edited by a moderator:
phinds
Gold Member
2019 Award
Does x need to have a constraint? Its a statics problem. I figured u sum up the forces in the x direction, sum up the forces in the y direction and sum of the moments and solve for x. Seems pretty straight forward im just trying to check if i did it right so i want to see how someone who knows what they are doing, does it? The one thing i realized i left out is the angle of those angled beams. They should be 45 degrees.
??? x is a DISTANCE, not a force, at least the way you have it drawn.

Yes exactly. Its a distance. I need to figure out how long that beam should be so thing thing doesnt fall over from the weight.

davenn
Gold Member
2019 Award
Yes exactly. Its a distance. I need to figure out how long that beam should be so thing thing doesnt fall over from the weight.
and what are you wanting to build the structure from ?
anything less than very strong and it will buckle long before it topples over

phinds
Gold Member
2019 Award
Yes exactly. Its a distance. I need to figure out how long that beam should be so thing thing doesnt fall over from the weight.
Well, that's trivial. x has be be a minimum of r1/2 + r2 - r3. In practice you'll want it a bit longer. Personally, I'd go with x = r1 + r2 - r3

jrmichler
Mentor
You want to hold a 1300 load, but don't know how to keep it from tipping over. I strongly suggest talking to a real engineer.

BTW, those angle braces do exactly nothing for the strength of the vertical column. Can you explain why?

Well, that's trivial. x has be be a minimum of r1/2 + r2 - r3. In practice you'll want it a bit longer. Personally, I'd go with x = r1 + r2 - r3
If it was my job, I would want the front support at least 2 feet past the center of gravity of the 1300 lb load. Preferably a little more, or a lot more depending on the height. And anchor it to the floor.

phinds
Gold Member
2019 Award
You want to hold a 1300 load, but don't know how to keep it from tipping over. I strongly suggest talking to a real engineer.

BTW, those angle braces do exactly nothing for the strength of the vertical column. Can you explain why?

If it was my job, I would want the front support at least 2 feet past the center of gravity of the 1300 lb load. Preferably a little more, or a lot more depending on the height. And anchor it to the floor.
Sure, but he gave a very simplistic problem and I gave him a simplistic answer.

You want to hold a 1300 load, but don't know how to keep it from tipping over.
As far as that goes, what keeps it from tipping over sideways?

and what are you wanting to build the structure from ?
anything less than very strong and it will buckle long before it topples over
Its being built out of steel

As far as that goes, what keeps it from tipping over sideways?
Well it will have two of those side frames about 4 ft apart with connected cross beams

Well it will have two of those side frames about 4 ft apart with connected cross beams
One at each corner

We need to be able to drive a forklift to be able to rest straps from the supersack on the top bars sticking out

Sure, but he gave a very simplistic problem and I gave him a simplistic answer.
I wanted to see how you would use statics. Like sum the forces and the moments. I wanted to see how its done

berkeman
Mentor
Thread closed temporarily for Moderation (safety issues).

Because if the inexperience of the OP and the heavy loads involved, this thread will remain closed. Thanks to all who responded.

Last edited: