Number of Posts Not Increasing - Is There an Issue?

  • Thread starter Thread starter adjacent
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the issue of post counts not increasing for certain users, particularly in the General Discussion (GD) forum, where posts do not contribute to total counts. Participants question the rationale behind this policy, suggesting it could discourage engagement and questioning whether it is a bug or intentional. There are calls for alternative recognition systems, such as reputation and awards, to replace post counts, along with suggestions for a notification system similar to social media. The conversation also touches on the importance of post counts for indicating user activity, especially for new members. Overall, the thread highlights concerns about user engagement and the effectiveness of current forum metrics.
adjacent
Gold Member
Messages
1,552
Reaction score
62
I don't know whether this is a bug or not,but I've just noticed the number of posts made by me didn't increase.Is there any problem?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Posts in GD don't count in the total given.
 
Why don't they just hide post count? What's the point of it?
 
It encourages some users to stay here and post more, and it gives a rough idea how active a user was in the past.
 
Hmm...I've been meaning to report this for sometime but was too lazy to create a thread-
The posts in the sub-forums of fun and games ie. photography forum etc. seem to count even though they belong to the Lounge...is this a bug or is it intentional?
 
ainster31 said:
Why don't they just hide post count? What's the point of it?

Along with what mfb said, I would add that it gives newbies in particular a sense of who is active on the forums. Certainly the amount of activity doesn't necessarily imply good answers, but it certainly shows that someone is interested in the discussions and it also shows that the poster hasn't made enough a lot of posts without haveing made enought bone-headed ones to get thrown off the forum :smile:
 
Enigman said:
Hmm...I've been meaning to report this for sometime but was too lazy to create a thread-
The posts in the sub-forums of fun and games ie. photography forum etc. seem to count even though they belong to the Lounge...is this a bug or is it intentional?

I'll look into this
 
I think it would be a good idea to have "reputation" and awards instead of post counts like in other forums.

Furthermore,it will be very helpful if there is a notification system like in facebook(but not exactly).The notification system should only notify the user if someone "tags" him/her in a post like this : @username etc.
 
Last edited:
We have recognition awards, there are Science Advisors, Homework Helpers, and right now we are having our annual member's choice awards.

What we don't want is to be like Facebook.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #10
geezez, Evo. 25K posts??

i can't even count that far. maybe to the log of it.
 
  • #11
Now remember only her posts outside of GD are counted.
 
  • #12
Now you all know the real reason why we don't count posts in GD: if we did, Evo's post count would overflow and cause the server to crash. :eek:
 
  • #13
what's "GD"? "G## D#mmit"? "General Dynamics" (not much different)?

sorry to be clueless.
 
  • #15
rbj said:
what's "GD"? "G## D#mmit"? "General Dynamics" (not much different)?

sorry to be clueless.
You have more than 2200 posts and you seem to be a very old member of this forum(join date:2003).Still,you don't know what's GD?
 
  • #16
adjacent said:
You have more than 2200 posts and you seem to be a very old member of this forum(join date:2003).

a while ago i was also a Sci Adviser until i asked Greg to take me offa the list (hey DaleSpam, i think i was the first to nominate you for Sci Adviser back in 2009 or something like that).

Still,you don't know what's GD?

hey, listen, anyone can be clueless. and even hypocritical, in a recent cosmology thread about fine-tuning, i was similarly surprized when someone said he didn't know what i meant by "FTU". i would have thought that "FT" should have been obvious. so me a hypocrite. and clueless.

so now i know. so posts to the General Discussions forum don't tally up in the vote count?
 
  • #17
rbj said:
so posts to the General Discussions forum don't tally up in the vote count?
Right.
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
64
Views
4K
Replies
31
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Back
Top