Object falling through liquid with quadratic drag force

6 replies · 2K views · last reply
Michael_0039
Messages
59
Reaction score
7
Homework Statement
Object inside liquid
Relevant Equations
T=k*v^2
F=m*a
Homework Statement: Object inside liquid
Homework Equations: T=k*v^2
F=m*a

We hold an object with a mass (m) inside a liquid. On t=0 we free the object. Except the weight there is another one force, the friction of the liquid, witch is T=k*v^2 ( v=instant speed, and k=constant > 0). Also, we assume Lift force of liquid = 0. Which is the v(t) and limit speed of the object ? Attachment a pdf with my notes, and a schematic.
 
Attachments
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

You started to work on the problem, but didn't get very far. Can you write the sum of the forces on the object? And that will lead you to an equation for the acceleration, which leads you to the velocity and position as functions of time. Please show your work. Thank you.
 
berkeman said:
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

You started to work on the problem, but didn't get very far. Can you write the sum of the forces on the object? And that will lead you to an equation for the acceleration, which leads you to the velocity and position as functions of time. Please show your work. Thank you.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten free-body diagram of a dark object in a fluid, with an upward drag force T = ku^2 (k>0) and a downward weight W = mg. Text reads: Fluid; for t = 0 sec, u0 = 0 m/s; T: fluid friction; buoyancy = 0; (a) u(t) = ?; (b) limit speed = ?
    pic1.PNG
    102.7 KB · Views: 414
But that is not showing your work on setting up the force balance equation and finding the acceleration, velocity, and position functions...
 
Thanks for your answer :) !
I will look it again, maybe Ι made calculus mistake. Following, is my try but my asnwer in page 7 is not the one I expected.
Handwritten free-body diagram of a small mass in a fluid with an upward friction force T = ku^2 (k > 0) and downward weight W = mg; right side lists t = 0 sec, v0 = 0 m/s, buoyancy = 0, and questions (a) u(t) = ? and (b) limit speed = ?


Handwritten derivation of a falling object with quadratic drag: ΣF = ma gives a = g - (k/m)u^2, separated and integrated to -(m/k) times the integral of 1/(u^2 - gm/k) du equals the integral of dt, then partial fractions with A = 1/(2√(gm/k)) and B = -1/(2√(gm/k)).

Handwritten calculus derivation on lined paper: integrating -u/k times 1/(2 sqrt(gu/k)) times 1/(u - sqrt(gu/k)) minus 1/(u + sqrt(gu/k)) du equals integral of dt from 0 to t, leading to a logarithmic expression evaluated from 0 to u equal to t.

Handwritten derivation of a time-integral result with logarithmic terms involving u, k and sqrt(g_u/k), rewritten over three lines with prefactor -u/k times 1/(2 sqrt(g_u/k)).

Handwritten derivation on lined paper: ln|(u + sqrt(gμ/k))/(sqrt(gμ/k))| - ln|(u - sqrt(gμ/k))/(-sqrt(gμ/k))| = t / ((μ/k)(1/(2sqrt(gμ/k)))), rewritten as a single logarithm equal to t over the same expression, then exponentiated to a form with e raised to that expression.

Handwritten algebra on lined paper: a fraction of (u + sqrt(gρ/k))(-sqrt(gρ/k)) over (u - sqrt(gρ/k))(sqrt(gρ/k)) equals e raised to (u/k times t over 1/(gρ sqrt(gρ/k))), with following lines simplifying the expression to -u + sqrt(gρ/k) equals e to the power (...) times (u - sqrt(gρ/k)).

Handwritten derivation on lined-free paper: e^(...)·u + u = e^(...)·sqrt(gμ/k) + sqrt(gμ/k), then u(e^(...)+1) = (e^(...)+1)sqrt(gμ/k), with a boxed result u = sqrt(gμ/k) and then u = sqrt(W/k).
 
Last edited:
Though your final solution is not wrong because it verifies the ODE you have done some mistakes in the process.
One mistake is that you don't consider the constant of integration. And from page 5 and after you start doing serious algebraical mistakes. The most serious mistake is that you remove the absolute value, WITHOUT FIRST to take cases, regarding the velocity ##u##.
In the following I have put ##\alpha=\sqrt\frac{mg}{k}## (and ##c=(…)##, so continuing from 5 the correct step is
$$\frac{|u+\alpha|}{|u-\alpha|}=e^{ct}$$ (1)

Now consider cases
1) ##\alpha>u>0##
2)##u=\alpha##
3)##u>\alpha##
and remove properly the absolute values in equation (1) in order to continue properly for each case
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Michael_0039