The discussion revolves around whether a mechanical engineer or student can understand the operation of mechanisms and machines solely from images, such as photographs or drawings. Participants explore the subjects and activities that could enhance this ability.
Participants express differing views on the feasibility of understanding mechanisms from images alone, indicating a lack of consensus on this topic. There is agreement on the value of practical experience and study materials, but no unified approach is established.
Some responses depend on personal experience and assumptions about the learning process, which may vary widely among individuals. The discussion does not resolve the effectiveness of visual learning versus hands-on experience.
Yes. If you have to ask ... doesn't look too hopeful.flamengo said:Is it possible for a mechanical engineer or even a mechanical engineering student to know how a mechanism or a machine works only through an image (photography, drawing ...)? And if so, what subjects should I study to have this ability ?
You should disassemble all sorts of mechanical contrivances to see how the parts function as a whole. Preferably broken or unserviceable devices, because then you can endeavour to identify why they ceased operating—and can possibly attempt to repair them. Keep aware of safety considerations, and don't attempt to repair electrical equipment that requires mains power.flamengo said:Are there specific subjects that I should learn to develop this ability ?