Optical path difference between two reflected rays

AI Thread Summary
The optical path difference between two reflected rays at the air-soap and soap-glass interfaces is calculated, revealing a discrepancy in the expected value. The first ray has an optical path length of lambda_soap/2, while the second has a length of 2n_soap d + lambda_glass/2. The derived optical path difference is expressed as Δ = 2n_soap d + lambda_glass/2 - lambda_soap/2, leading to an incorrect result of approximately 7.49 lambda_soap instead of the expected 5.16 lambda_soap. The discussion highlights that the error arose from mistakenly counting the index of refraction of soap twice. Clarification on how to properly account for wavelengths in different media resolves the confusion.
lorenz0
Messages
151
Reaction score
28
Homework Statement
A soap water film ## n = 1.46 ## with a thickness of ## d = 10^{-6} m ## is placed on a glass plate with a refractive index of ## n = 1.6.## The film is perpendicularly illuminated by green light with a wavelength of ## 566 nm.## What is the optical path difference between the rays reflected from the two sides of the film, expressed in terms of the wavelength of the light inside the film?
Relevant Equations
##\Delta=\sum_i n_i d_i ##
The ray that is reflected at the air-soap interface has an optical path length of ##lambda_{soap}/2##, while the one refracted in the soap has an optical path length of ##2 n_{soap} d+\frac{lambda_{glass}}{2}## due to its traversing the soap film and also reflecting on the soap-glass interface. Thus the optical path difference between the two rays is ##\Delta=2 n_{soap} d+\frac{lambda_{glass}}{2}-\frac{lambda_{soap}}{2}## which can also be written as ##\Delta=\frac{2 n_{soap} d+\frac{lambda_{glass}}{2}-\frac{lambda_{soap}}{2}}{lambda_{soap}}lambda_{soap}\approx 7.49 lambda_{soap}##, which according to the stated solution is wrong, since it should be ##5.16 lambda_{soap}.## I would be grateful if someone could tell me where I am going wrong. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
There is phase change of 180° when the light reflects at the vacuum-soap interface and at the soap-glass interface so these cancel when you subtract. What's left?
 
That was my initial guess (that the phase shifts cancel out), and in that case it seems to me that ##\Delta=\frac{2n_{soap}d}{lambda_{soap}} lambda_{soap}=\frac{2 n^2_{soap}d}{lambda_0} lambda_{soap}##, so it still is not in agreement with the stated solution
 
lorenz0 said:
That was my initial guess (that the phase shifts cancel out), and in that case it seems to me that ##\Delta=\frac{2n_{soap}d}{lambda_{soap}} lambda_{soap}=\frac{2 n^2_{soap}d}{lambda_0} lambda_{soap}##, so it still is not in agreement with the stated solution
That's because you counted the index of refraction of soap twice. The number of wavelengths you can fit in distance ##d## in vacuum is $$N=\frac{2d}{\lambda_{vac}}.$$ How many wavelengths can you fit in the same distance ##d## when the wavelength is ##\lambda_{vac}/n_{soap}##?
 
@kuruman Got it. Thank you very much
 
Thread 'Collision of a bullet on a rod-string system: query'
In this question, I have a question. I am NOT trying to solve it, but it is just a conceptual question. Consider the point on the rod, which connects the string and the rod. My question: just before and after the collision, is ANGULAR momentum CONSERVED about this point? Lets call the point which connects the string and rod as P. Why am I asking this? : it is clear from the scenario that the point of concern, which connects the string and the rod, moves in a circular path due to the string...
Back
Top