- #1
Varon
- 548
- 1
Do you agree that the development of Quantum field theory has totally outdated the concepts of particles? How come we still talk about particle wave duality? If you use this concept to explain the double slit experiment. Endless debates arise as to whether the electron pass thru the left or right slit. But if you consider it as pure quantum field and wave. There is no longer any mystery.
First of all. "Most electrons in a real material are there smeared out in a way that the particle picture is misleading. Chemists use electron densities, not electron positions to describe things. Thus a newly arriving delocalized electron is nothing very special to the detector." do you agree?
So what happens in the double slit experiment is simply this. Quantum electron field is emitted... and after reaching the slits... the quantum field is splitted and pure field or wave hit the detectors. Now why do we only detect one electron?
Note the detector has existing millions of electrons which compose the detector. Only one of these are triggered. You may ask how the wave select that particular one.
"The wave selects nothing. It arrives at the various places of detector with different intensities, and these intensities stimulate all the electrons. But because of conservation of energy, only one can fire since the first one that fires uses up all the energy available for ionization (resp. jumping to the conduction band), and none is left for the others." (Neumaier)
Do all agree that the double slit experiment is finally solved? Any counterarguments or refutations?
First of all. "Most electrons in a real material are there smeared out in a way that the particle picture is misleading. Chemists use electron densities, not electron positions to describe things. Thus a newly arriving delocalized electron is nothing very special to the detector." do you agree?
So what happens in the double slit experiment is simply this. Quantum electron field is emitted... and after reaching the slits... the quantum field is splitted and pure field or wave hit the detectors. Now why do we only detect one electron?
Note the detector has existing millions of electrons which compose the detector. Only one of these are triggered. You may ask how the wave select that particular one.
"The wave selects nothing. It arrives at the various places of detector with different intensities, and these intensities stimulate all the electrons. But because of conservation of energy, only one can fire since the first one that fires uses up all the energy available for ionization (resp. jumping to the conduction band), and none is left for the others." (Neumaier)
Do all agree that the double slit experiment is finally solved? Any counterarguments or refutations?