News Plame Was Working On The Iran Nuclear Situation

  • Thread starter Thread starter edward
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Nuclear
Click For Summary
Valerie Plame was involved in a CIA operation focused on tracking weapons of mass destruction technology related to Iran when she was outed. The discussion highlights the implications of her outing on U.S. national security, particularly concerning Iran's nuclear program. There is contention over whether her outing was a significant breach, as some argue it did not lead to legal consequences for those involved. Critics point out that the investigation into her outing was flawed, with prosecutors unable to secure indictments due to insufficient evidence. Overall, the conversation underscores the complexities surrounding Plame's role and the broader implications of her exposure.
  • #31
Novak outed her. Judith Miller never produced an article about Plame, but spent some time in jail for refusing to reveal who outed Plame to her. Richard Armitage, Ari Fleischer, Carl Rove and Scooter Libby are known to have told reporters about Plame's work with the CIA, but only Scooter got tagged. He took a bullet for Cheney and the gang, and he'll be well-rewarded when this administration winds down. Libby tried to reverse the flow of information in his testimony, saying that Tim Russert told him that Plame was a CIA agent. That was a bit ridiculous, since the whole second-string of the Bush administration seemed to be piling on her. The number of people who committed treason in this case is astounding. The lack of prosecutions is saddening, and bodes ill for the country. Due to classification, we may never know how many of Plame's assets, associates, or potential recruits were imprisoned, tortured or executed once foreign intelligence agencies got the word that this "businesswoman" who traveled to their countries was actually a CIA NOC agent. We will never know just how much damage the Bushie's did to our intelligence-gathering and our ability to throttle back nuclear proliferation (her mission in the CIA).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Ooohh, sorry. Wrong answer. Novak only indicated that she worked at CIA. Joe Wilson disclosed that she was covert...
 
  • #33
chemisttree said:
Ooohh, sorry. Wrong answer. Novak only indicated that she worked at CIA. Joe Wilson disclosed that she was covert...


But Wilson did not do that until 2004. She was outed on July 14 03. It didn't matter what Wilson said by that time. Plame's outing and picture had been all over the news media for months.


And just to clarify your understatement.

Novak reported that the wife of former Ambassador Joseph C. Wilson is “an Agency operative on weapons of mass destruction"

"worked at" and "Agency operative on WMD" are two very different job descriptions. Janitors work there.

I don't get your point. Are you stating that Plames outing was OK because the information came from the Vice Presidents office? Or are you just nit picking details?

btw turbo-1's post did not even include the term covert.
 
Last edited:
  • #34
chemisttree said:
I'm diagnosing some derangement syndrome. Even when printed in black and white (in the same sentence) you cannot see the lie.

So what does traveling under a cover identity in true name mean? Do you loudly mention to all in earshot that you don't work for the CIA?
Under a cover identity in true name is self explanatory. Spies don't always wear disguises and use alliases :rolleyes:

Travelling with her husband gave her the cover identity - that is plain Mrs Wilson, there only because her husband is - to undertake covert missions on behalf of her gov't who then shafted her.
 
  • #35
Being married to a US ambassador is a TERRIBLE cover. They are the first to be suspected of espionage by the other side.

Travelling with her husband gave her the cover identity - that is plain Mrs Wilson, there only because her husband is - to undertake covert missions on behalf of her gov't who then shafted her.

Now that's just funny!
 
  • #36
chemisttree said:
Being married to a US ambassador is a TERRIBLE cover. They are the first to be suspected of espionage by the other side.



Now that's just funny!
Wow so every spouse of every diplomat in the world is a trained spy

Well in your world anyway :smile:
 
  • #37
Art said:
Wow so every spouse of every diplomat in the world is a trained spy

Well in your world anyway :smile:
As a credentialed diplomat, Joe Wilson would have at most been at most expelled from countries if he had been suspected of espionage. Plame would have been arrested, imprisoned, interrogated, and perhaps tortured if she was suspected to be involved in espionage. She may well have been executed. People don't realize that a NOC working for the CIA is one of the CIAs most valuable assets, and that they are at far greater risk than any agent with official cover. They, their assets, and their potential recruits are irreplaceable. The administration members who outed her deserve to be prosecuted as the traitors they are.
 
  • #38
turbo-1 said:
The administration members who outed her deserve to be prosecuted as the traitors they are.

My sentiments exactly. Only with a little more emphasis!
 
  • #40
But their IED's work fine I'm told.
 
  • #41
chemisttree said:
But their IED's work fine I'm told.
The US has heavily armed the Shia (friends of Iran) and the IEDs have been linked to the Sunni insurgency and Al Qaida activities. Can you explain why the Iranian government would want to arm the Sunnis and Al Qaida with IED's? That's the responsibility of Bush's friends in Saudi Arabia. Aside from mere assertions, the administration has provided no evidence that the government of Iran is shipping IEDs or their components into Iraq. Remember the WMDs that Saddam had that made him a threat to the region? Remember the yellowcake that Saddam tried to buy from Niger? Remember the aluminum tubing that HAD to be intend for use in centrifuges in an enrichment plant, despite the fact that the material was unsuited for that purpose? All flimsy fabricated "evidence" and all discredited. Every time a new piece of "intelligence" needs to be touted, the administration fabricates it and pushes it out to a friendly patsy who "discovers" it and feeds it back to them, so the administration can leak it to the Bob Novaks, the Judith Millers, and the Tucker Carlsons of the world, who repeat it with NO attempt at confirmation or investigative journalism. These are GOP shills, not reporters. Their idea of getting independent confirmation is asking Paul Wolfowitz whether Karl Rove is lying.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 75 ·
3
Replies
75
Views
12K
  • · Replies 36 ·
2
Replies
36
Views
5K
  • · Replies 490 ·
17
Replies
490
Views
40K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
6K
  • · Replies 49 ·
2
Replies
49
Views
7K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
4K