Point of Intersection of two lines

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
7 replies · 3K views
Jumpsmash
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Two tangents to an ellipse meet at a point T, find the coordinates of T.

The two equations are
(bcosΘ)x + (asinΘ)y= ab
(-bsinΘ)x + (acosΘ)y= ab


This has been really frustrating me as I feel it should be simple, but with the trigonometric parts I keep hitting a wall.

I have tried finding x in the first equation, which I worked out as X=(ab-asinΘy)/bcosΘ , and then substituting into the second equation to get a value for y, but I couldn't get it to condense to a reasonable form. I don't think this is the right approach and would appreciate someone pointing me in the right direction of how I should approach it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Jumpsmash said:
I have tried finding x in the first equation, which I worked out as X=(ab-asinΘy)/bcosΘ , and then substituting into the second equation to get a value for y, but I couldn't get it to condense to a reasonable form.
After substituting into the 2nd equation, multiply both sides by cosΘ. You'll be able to use the Pythagorean identity sin2 Θ + cos2 Θ = 1 to simplify things quite a bit.
 
If I work it through I seem to get once x has been substituted into the second equation

aby(cos^2Θ+sin^2Θ)= ab^2(cosΘ+sinΘ)
y=b(cosΘ+sinΘ)

I've quite probably lost the plot, but I have repeated this several times and come up with this. And given this result multiplying by cosΘ doesn't seem to help me. When I substitute this into the original equation I get an even more unwieldly result, and considering I have to use this point subsequently in what I'm doing I don't think it's right.
 
What you give for x simply isn't correct.
Multiply the first equation, (bcosΘ)x + (asinΘ)y= ab, by cosΘ, multiply the second equation, (-bsinΘ)x + (acosΘ)y= ab, by -sinΘ and add the two equations to eliminate y. There will be NO "b" in the result for x.
 
HallsofIvy said:
What you give for x simply isn't correct.
If you're referring to the OP:
X=(ab-asinΘy)/bcosΘ
... well, I got this too.

Jumpsmash said:
If I work it through I seem to get once x has been substituted into the second equation

aby(cos^2Θ+sin^2Θ)= ab^2(cosΘ+sinΘ)
y=b(cosΘ+sinΘ)

I've quite probably lost the plot, but I have repeated this several times and come up with this. And given this result multiplying by cosΘ doesn't seem to help me. When I substitute this into the original equation I get an even more unwieldly result, and considering I have to use this point subsequently in what I'm doing I don't think it's right.

What Halls is suggesting (linear combinations) is probably easier. But if you want to stick with substitution:
[tex]x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{b \cos \theta}[/tex]

Substitute this into the second equation:
[tex]-b\sin\theta \left( \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{b \cos \theta}\right) + a\cos\theta y = ab[/tex]

Cancel out the b:
[tex]-\sin\theta \left( \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{\cos \theta}\right) + a\cos\theta y = ab[/tex]

This is where I'm suggesting to multiply by cosΘ:
[tex]-\sin\theta \left( ab - a \sin\theta y \right) + a\cos^2 \theta y = ab\cos\theta[/tex]

From here you should be able to solve for y. It looks like you did, because you got
y = b cos Θ + b sin Θ
which is what I got.

Now substitute into
[tex]x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta y}{b \cos \theta}[/tex]
and get
[tex]x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta (b\cos\theta + b\sin\theta)}{b \cos \theta}[/tex]
and simplify.
 
Last edited:
Many thanks to both of you. I see the method by Halls and got the solutions through that. It did indeed seem quicker. With regard to the substitution, my apologies I did multiply through by cosΘ without realising and in fact reached the stage you showed. It was from there that I could not simplify it and thought I must have the wrong solution. From using the other method it appears x=a(cosΘ-sinΘ); but I still don't see how to simplify the equation for x from the subsitution to this form.
 
You mean simplifying x from here?
[tex]x = \frac{ab - a \sin\theta (b\cos\theta + b\sin\theta)}{b \cos \theta}[/tex]

Distribute:
[tex]x = \frac{ab - ab \sin\theta \cos\theta - ab\sin^2\theta}{b \cos \theta}[/tex]

Factor out an ab and cancel out the b:
[tex]x = \frac{a(1 - \sin\theta \cos\theta - \sin^2\theta)}{\cos \theta}[/tex]

Use the Pythagorean identity again (sin2 θ + cos2 θ = 1 -> 1 - sin2 θ = cos2 θ):
[tex]x = \frac{a(\cos^2 \theta - \sin\theta \cos\theta)}{\cos \theta}[/tex]

Can you finish from here?
 
Apologies for delay thought I sent this. Yes I can, many thanks.