Polling for estimates of probability our universe is infinite

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the subjective probability estimates regarding whether the universe is infinite or finite, with many participants favoring an infinite, flat universe. One contributor estimates a 20% probability for an infinite universe and 80% for a finite one, influenced by specific cosmological data. The contributor also suggests that if the universe is finite, it is likely hyper-spherical, while an infinite universe would be flat. There is acknowledgment that current data cannot definitively distinguish between flatness and a nearly flat curvature, leading to speculation about a 50-50 probability among those who prioritize flatness. The poll intended to gather estimates was ultimately canceled due to a lack of participation.
Buzz Bloom
Gold Member
Messages
2,517
Reaction score
465
I have noticed that many PF participants seem to favor a cosmological model that our universe is infinite (and flat), but some (like myself) favor a finite universe. I have become curious about the subjective probability distribution, so I am hoping that many PF participants will post their subjective estimate of the probability P that it is infinite (or Q=1-P that it is finite).

Here are my own personal subjective probability estimates.

P = 0.2. This means the probability the universe is infinite is 20%, and the probability it is finite is 80%. The data that has mostly influenced my estimates is
I also believe that if the universe is finite, is is hyper-spherical rather than some other topological shape. Also, if it is infinite, it is flat and not hyperbolic.

I also understand that there are many who have reasons to believe the universe is flat, but with the understanding that the current cosmological data cannot possibly distinguish between flatness and a non-flat curvature that is so close to flat that it is not possible to have evidence that distinguishes between these two possibilities. I am wondering if they find this point of view to be interpreted to mean that the probability is close to: 50% that the universe is finite and hyper-spherical, and 50% that is infinite and flat or hyperbolic. I would guess that those who believe in the importance of the flatness problem are likely to have this 50-50 view.

At the present time I do not know how long I will want to keep the poll open. At some point when I feel I have enough contributions, i will calculate and post the mean and standard deviation values.

ADDED May 29
I have decided to cancel this poll since there were NO votes cast during the two weeks since I posted the poll.
 
Last edited:
Space news on Phys.org
Certain to be between 0 and 1, as in [0,1].
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
Abstract The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has significantly advanced our ability to study black holes, achieving unprecedented spatial resolution and revealing horizon-scale structures. Notably, these observations feature a distinctive dark shadow—primarily arising from faint jet emissions—surrounded by a bright photon ring. Anticipated upgrades of the EHT promise substantial improvements in dynamic range, enabling deeper exploration of low-background regions, particularly the inner shadow...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recombination_(cosmology) Was a matter density right after the decoupling low enough to consider the vacuum as the actual vacuum, and not the medium through which the light propagates with the speed lower than ##({\epsilon_0\mu_0})^{-1/2}##? I'm asking this in context of the calculation of the observable universe radius, where the time integral of the inverse of the scale factor is multiplied by the constant speed of light ##c##.

Similar threads

Back
Top