Power surge video - why does the spark travel?
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
14 replies · 2K views
Physics news on Phys.org
Discussion
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
- 3,212
- 3,841
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2025 Award
- 4,603
- 4,325
That's my guess. Like a rail gun! The direction is always to make the current loop area increase, to reduce the change in magnetic flux enclosed as the current increases. Lenz's law, I believe.berkeman said:Maybe the Lorentz force pushing clouds of short-circuiting ionized air away from the power source? (I'm not sure I have the direction correct, but I think it would be away...?)
256bits
Gold Member
- 4,284
- 2,297
Is it a spark or combustion. I see what appears to be a smoke trail behind the flame.
Somewhat like line of gunpowder in the old westerns.
Somewhat like line of gunpowder in the old westerns.
- 11,327
- 8,758
The title of the video said storm, so my guess is just plain old wind.
My firm used to do rocket triggered lightning experiments as shown in the picture. The parallel paths in the picture are repeated strokes. The total time duration is probably 0.3 seconds. The mechanism of horizontal movement is simply a trail of ionized air being blown by the wind.
In the case of the video below, we have continuous arc rather than separate strokes, but still there is a patch of ionized air being blown by the wind. Some of the ions get left behind, but new ones are created each instant.
In this video at 2:53-3:04 ask yourself why this arc wants to move to the left and why a long U rather than a shorter one. IMO, it is once again simply wind.
p.s. I miss Jim Hardy too. He was the best.
My firm used to do rocket triggered lightning experiments as shown in the picture. The parallel paths in the picture are repeated strokes. The total time duration is probably 0.3 seconds. The mechanism of horizontal movement is simply a trail of ionized air being blown by the wind.
In the case of the video below, we have continuous arc rather than separate strokes, but still there is a patch of ionized air being blown by the wind. Some of the ions get left behind, but new ones are created each instant.
In this video at 2:53-3:04 ask yourself why this arc wants to move to the left and why a long U rather than a shorter one. IMO, it is once again simply wind.
p.s. I miss Jim Hardy too. He was the best.
Last edited:
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2025 Award
- 22,712
- 7,802
I was thinking IxB.berkeman said:Maybe the Lorentz force pushing clouds of short-circuiting ionized air away from the power source? (I'm not sure I have the direction correct, but I think it would be away...?)
I was also wondering if it phase-to-phase and/or phase-to-neutral/ground.
Keith_McClary
- 752
- 1,507
Similar principle to a Jacob's Ladder?anorlunda said:trail of ionized air being blown by the wind.
- 11,327
- 8,758
I'm not convinced. The arc in the video moved at about 10 m/s (20 knots). The trees had no leaves. 20 knots of wind does not make dramatic visible effects on bare trees. Wind is still my wager.berkeman said:Aint no wind in those trees in the video...![]()
Science Advisor
- 1,567
- 5,225
+1anorlunda said:I'm not convinced. The arc in the video moved at about 10 m/s (20 knots). The trees had no leaves. 20 knots of wind does not make dramatic visible effects on bare trees. Wind is still my wager.
https://www.kxan.com/news/stunning-...surge-traveling-down-power-line-during-storm/
The winter storm moving through the area is the same as the one knocking out power to cities in Texas and dropping snow from the Gulf of Mexico to the Ohio River Valley.
Easy to see the arc being affected by wind here causing wire slapping.
Similar threads
Protect Your Home Theater System: Choosing the Right Power Surge Solution
- ffp
- · Replies 2 ·
- Electrical Engineering
- Replies
- 2
Undergrad Experimental results for current/power surge in a lightbulb
- freefaller
- · Replies 7 ·
- Electromagnetism
- Replies
- 7
High School Lightning Strike and electrical power surge
- Caveman717
- · Replies 5 ·
- Electromagnetism
- Replies
- 5