Problem with friction on weighing machine

8 replies · 3K views · last reply
decentfellow
Messages
130
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


A man of mass ##80## kg, stands. on a horizontal weighing machine, of negligible mass, attached to a massless platform P that slides down a ##37^{\circ}## incline. The weighing machine reads ##72## kg. Man is always at rest w.r.t weighing machine.
Diagram of a man standing on a weighing machine on top of a block labelled P, which rests on a 37 degree incline sloping down to the right over a hatched ground surface.


Calculate:
(a) The vertical acceleration of the man.
(b) The coefficient of kinetic friction ##\mu## between the platform and man.

Homework Equations



$$\begin{align}
&f_k\le \mu_{k}mg\qquad\qquad \text{where, $\mu_{k}\rightarrow$ coefficient of static friction} \\
&f_s\le \mu_{s}mg\qquad\qquad \text{where, $\mu_{s}\rightarrow$ coefficient of static friction} \\
&F=ma
\end{align}$$

The Attempt at a Solution



The first part of the question was pretty easily solve but its the second part where I am having the problem.
$$m_Mg-N_1=m_Ma_P\sin{37^{\circ}}\qquad\qquad\text{where, $m_M$ is the mass of man} \\
\implies (80-72)g=80a_P\left(\dfrac{3}{5}\right)\implies a_P=\dfrac{5}{3}\text{m/s$^2$}$$
Free-body diagram of a man standing on a platform: downward weight m_M g, upward normal force N_1, horizontal friction force f_s, and an acceleration vector a_P pointing down and to the right.

Free-body diagram of block P on an incline with forces N1 down, fs left, N2 normal, mg cos θ and mg sin θ labelled, and acceleration a_P pointing down-right.


So, from the above FBD of the man standing on the platform we see that
$$f_s=m_Ma_P\cos\theta$$

From the above equation, I concluded that for the platform and the man to not move relatively to each other its not necessary that the friction acting b/w the man and the platform be the maximum static friction, so I don't think we can find the coefficient of "kinetic friction", even though if it had been possible we could have only found the coefficient of static friction. Now, if we were to find the coefficient of the static friction shouldn't the question have also mentioned that the force of friction acting b/w the surfaces to make them move together is the maximum friction.

Also, the coefficient of friction that I found is
$$(f_s)_{max}=m_Ma_P\cos\theta\implies \mu_sN_1=80\left(\dfrac{5}{3}\right)\left(\dfrac{4}{5}\right)\\
\implies \mu_s(72g)=80\left(\dfrac{5}{3}\right)\left(\dfrac{4}{5}\right)\implies \mu_s=\dfrac{4}{27}$$

So, the coefficient of friction that I got is ##\mu_s=\dfrac{4}{27}##, whereas the book got the coefficient of friction as ##\mu=\dfrac{13}{24}##. So, can you please point out where am I going wrong.
 
Last edited:
I concluded that for the platform and the man to not move relatively to each other its not necessary that the friction acting b/w the man and the platform be the maximum static friction, so I don't think we can find the coefficient of "kinetic friction", even though if it had been possible we could have only found the coefficient of static friction. Now, if we were to find the coefficient of the static friction shouldn't the question have also mentioned that the force of friction acting b/w the surfaces to make them move together is the maximum friction.
That is completely correct ... it is possible the question wants the coeff kinetic friction between the platform and the slope.
 
Simon Bridge said:
That is completely correct ... it is possible the question wants the coeff kinetic friction between the platform and the slope.
If that is so then there is the question of why my and the books answer differ.
 
decentfellow said:
If that is so then there is the question of why my and the books answer differ.
Not sure you read Simon's suggestion carefully. The question statement is wrong. It wants you to find the coefficient of kinetic friction between the platform and the slope. You can just assume the friction between platform and man is sufficient to prevent sliding.
On this basis, I get the book answer.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Simon Bridge
haruspex said:
Not sure you read Simon's suggestion carefully. The question statement is wrong. It wants you to find the coefficient of kinetic friction between the platform and the slope. You can just assume the friction between platform and man is sufficient to prevent sliding.
On this basis, I get the book answer.
I am very sorry for the late reply, but yes it seems like I did not properly read Simon's post, and after solving it myself according to what Simon suggested I did get the answer but I solved it in a different manner than the book suggested and I am having a very hard time understanding what the book did, so I will be showing my attempt and the books attempt and the steps that I did not understand in the book's solution.

My solution:-
Free-body diagram of a man on an inclined wedge at 37 degrees, labelled with forces N1 downward, N2 normal to the incline, friction f_s to the left, and mu N2 along the incline, plus acceleration a_P pointing down and to the right.

Free-body diagram of a man on a platform with acceleration a_P pointing down and to the right, friction force f_s pointing right, normal force N_1 pointing up, and weight m_Mg pointing down.

From the above FBD of the man, we get
$$m_Mg-N_1=m_Ma_P\sin{37^{\circ}}\implies a_P=\dfrac{5}{3}\text{m/s$^2$}\\
f_s=m_Ma_P\cos{37^{\circ}}\implies f_s=80\times\dfrac{5}{3}$$

Now, as the platform P is massless so, from its FBD we get the following equations:-
$$N_2=f_s\sin\theta+N_1\cos\theta=640 N\\
\mu_k N_2+f_s\cos\theta=N_1\sin\theta\implies \mu_k=\dfrac{13}{24}$$

Textbook's Solution:-

Two free-body diagrams on an incline at 37 degrees: (b) a man on a block with N up, mg down, friction mu mg horizontal, and acceleration a split into ax and ay; (c) the acceleration vector a with components a cos 37 degrees = ax and ay = a sin 37 degrees.

$$(80-72)g=ma_y\implies a_y=1\text{m/s$^2$}\\
a_y=a\sin{37^{\circ}}=1\text{m/s$^2$}\implies a=\dfrac{5}{3}\text{m/s$^2$}$$

Now apply Newton's second law on man in direction of acceleration. Note that ##x-##component of acceleration is due to friction.
$$mg\sin{37^{\circ}}-\mu mg\sin{37^{\circ}}=m\times(5/3)\\
\implies 6-8\mu=5/3\implies 6-(5/3)=8\mu\implies \mu=\dfrac{13}{24}$$

According to the FBD that the book has drawn is it not that that the book is finding the coefficient of friction b/w man and the platform not b/w platform and incline.
 
decentfellow said:
According to the FBD that the book has drawn is it not that that the book is finding the coefficient of friction b/w man and the platform not b/w platform and incline.
You are right, so it turns out that the error in the book is that it should have asked for the minimum static friction, not the kinetic friction, and by coincidence both "error corrected" versions of the question have the same answer.
By the way, there is an error in one line of the textbook solution as you have posted it. It should read ##mg\sin(37)-\mu mg\cos(37)##.
 
haruspex said:
By the way, there is an error in one line of the textbook solution as you have posted it. It should read mgsin(37)−μmgcos(37)mgsin⁡(37)−μmgcos⁡(37)mg\sin(37)-\mu mg\cos(37).

Yeah, that was the same thing written in the book its a mistake on my side, it ought to be ##mg\sin{37^{\circ}}-\mu mg\cos{37^{\circ}}=m\times(5/3)##. Also, according to the FBD the book has drawn doesn't the force equation in the direction of the acceleration look faulty instead of ##mg\sin{37^{\circ}}-\mu mg\cos{37^{\circ}}=m\times(5/3)## shouldn't it be ##mg\sin{37^{\circ}}+\mu mg\cos{37^{\circ}}=m\times(5/3)##
 
Last edited:
haruspex said:
You are right, so it turns out that the error in the book is that it should have asked for the minimum static friction, not the kinetic friction, and by coincidence both "error corrected" versions of the question have the same answer.
I don't think the book's answer is correct regarding the coefficient of static friction b/w the platform and the man because it has not included the normal's component along the direction of the acceleration of the man.
The expression should be
$$mg\sin{37^{\circ}}+\mu_s N_1\cos{37^{\circ}}-N_1\sin{37^{\circ}}=m\times(5/3) \\
\implies (80-72)g\sin{37^{\circ}}+\mu_s 72g\cos{37^{\circ}}=80\times(5/3) \\
\implies \mu_s=\dfrac{4}{27}$$

or the simpler method that I did in the first post
$$\mu_s N_1=ma_P\cos{37^{\circ}}\implies \mu_s=\dfrac{4}{27}$$
 
decentfellow said:
I don't think the book's answer is correct regarding the coefficient of static friction b/w the platform and the man because it has not included the normal's component along the direction of the acceleration of the man.
The expression should be
$$mg\sin{37^{\circ}}+\mu_s N_1\cos{37^{\circ}}-N_1\sin{37^{\circ}}=m\times(5/3) \\
\implies (80-72)g\sin{37^{\circ}}+\mu_s 72g\cos{37^{\circ}}=80\times(5/3) \\
\implies \mu_s=\dfrac{4}{27}$$

or the simpler method that I did in the first post
$$\mu_s N_1=ma_P\cos{37^{\circ}}\implies \mu_s=\dfrac{4}{27}$$
Yes, sorry, I forgot that part... looking at too many different threads. So the book is completely wrong.