Project, parts id and physics explain

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the design and mechanics of a device intended to release stored mechanical energy over a period of time, specifically for a "post-apocalypse" themed project. Participants explore various components such as springs, gears, and mechanisms to achieve a controlled release of force to spin two wheels, which would then impart motion to an object, like a ball in a pitching machine.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant proposes using a spring assembly to store and release force slowly over 5-10 seconds to avoid abrupt stops of the wheels.
  • Another suggests using a mainspring or "going barrel" from clock mechanisms to deliver power, questioning if it can provide sufficient energy.
  • There is a discussion about whether the force exerted by the springs directly correlates with the force imparted by the wheels.
  • Participants consider using two springs coiled in opposite directions to power both wheels directly.
  • One participant raises a question about the relationship between the speed of the wheels and the force exerted on the ball, seeking clarification on the underlying physics.
  • Another participant mentions the potential use of a ratcheting lever to build up energy and release it to spin the wheels.
  • There are suggestions to use a come-along mechanism to lift a weight that could then release energy to spin the wheels, though concerns about the instantaneous release of energy are noted.
  • One participant expresses uncertainty about the mechanics of energy release and whether the wheels need to reach a certain speed before imparting force to an object.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various ideas and approaches, but there is no consensus on the best method to achieve the desired energy release or the relationship between wheel speed and force imparted. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing views and uncertainties present.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations in their understanding of the physics involved, particularly regarding the concepts of force, energy, and the mechanics of springs and wheels. There are also references to specific components and mechanisms that may not be universally understood.

Alt-Bringer
Messages
35
Reaction score
3
im going to need help filling holes and someone to explain to me what I am trying to say/do
ill start with what i want to do, and hopfully someone will be able to tell me what i need
part-wise (i have some idea but not much)

1) I am looking at needing some sort of spring assembly in order to have stored force
release in a slow and semi-constant fashion maybe over 5-10 seconds

the idea being to make 2 "wheels" spin and not abruptly stop if disturbed within that time

2) how to transfer force from spring to the "wheels"

im thinking maybe i can drive a chain/belt to a relatively large gear, then to drive the wheels
have one interact directly with big gear then 2 on the other side one driving the other which
drive the wheel so they spin opposite of each other

my thought is to use easily found/made materials so maybe a chain/belt isn't the best idea

2,a) what connects to the "spring"? (to transfer force)
b) in can't have the wheels driven directly, or theyd stop abruptly,
so i need to have them on some sort of free/flywheel?

3) what forces am i dealing with
on the spring, i think its measured in weight units, ie foot-pounds
at the wheels its velocity

weight and size is a concern, end product hopfully would be near or less than a wood 4x4
(yes i do realize that weight differ by wood species)

in a 2 wheel pitching machine
obviously the wheel rotation affects how fast and/or hard the ball travels
but is it the wheels speed or the torsional force privided by the motor used to measure the force imparted onto the ball?

whats the math part behind it... in moron please, because I am bad with this stuff and
especially numbers (dyscalcula)
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
ok as for part one all i come up with is a mainspring or "going barrel" (clock parts)
but can i make one that will deliver enough power?

2) i could use 2 springs coiled in opposite directions
then since the housing of a going barrel is a gear, i could directly power both wheels

please reference barrel (horology) at wikipedia for description of what I am talking about

still trying to find out if the force on the springs directly corralates with force imparted by the wheels

i wasnt going to post in my own thread, but i couldn't find an edit button to add this to the main post
 
force stored = force exerted? clarification

ive asked this in my other posts and elsewhere but no answers
but here i think its cause the question is "burried" among other stuff

...the base model i guess youd call it, that I am going to use this time is
a "plunger" as found on a pinball machine

i think the formula would be (correct me if I am wrong)

force (base) is spring under "full load" = #
force exerted is # - ball weight - gravity

therefore if the ball weight is neglegible and the table was flat or gone then
the ball would travel with the force of # until gravity, friction etc, slows it to zero

am i on the right track,
or am i just clueless?
 
Your post is unclear. Additional information is required to make sense of what you are trying to do.
 
Alt-Bringer said:
ok as for part one all i come up with is a mainspring or "going barrel" (clock parts)
but can i make one that will deliver enough power?

2) i could use 2 springs coiled in opposite directions
then since the housing of a going barrel is a gear, i could directly power both wheels

please reference barrel (horology) at wikipedia for description of what I am talking about

still trying to find out if the force on the springs directly corralates with force imparted by the wheels

i wasnt going to post in my own thread, but i couldn't find an edit button to add this to the main post

Your reference to horology is a bit confusing, since in the other parts of your posts you are referring to delivering energy over a 5-10 second interval (rather than just keeping time).

You should do some reading on wikipedia about momentum and inertia (both linear and rotational). You don't store "force", you store energy. A compressed spring stores energy, and you can use wikipedia to learn how much energy is stored. That energy can do work over some distance, Work = Force * Distance. The force available in a compressed spring has to do with its spring constant and how far it is compressed.

If you store rotational energy in a spinning disk, the time it takes to slow down and stop depends on its Moment of Inertia, and how fast it is spinning, and the retarding torque that is trying to slow it down.
 
all i could find web searing for something that would release mechanical energy over time
was the clock part,
if i didnt need to worry about the wheels stopping the moment someone breathes too hard
i could do a "pull cord" type deal like a mousetrap car

so making something similar but stronger was the idea i came to

my project is to make a "post-apocalypse" themed tech piece
(using readily available salvagable or makeable parts)

so trying to think of what kinds of "bits & bobs" i need, with my limited knowledge of tech,
i come up with springs gears pins and other simple things,

i maybe my problems is that i am trying to explain things, and just "making mountains" as they say

in simple terms ...relativley (just look who your dealing with here)

i want to use a ratcheting lever to build up energy
[part name] to store energy
apply that energy to make 2 wheels spin opposite of each other
and use the spinning of the wheels to impart/exert [term] upon and object
 
Alt-Bringer said:
all i could find web searing for something that would release mechanical energy over time
was the clock part,
if i didnt need to worry about the wheels stopping the moment someone breathes too hard
i could do a "pull cord" type deal like a mousetrap car

so making something similar but stronger was the idea i came to

my project is to make a "post-apocalypse" themed tech piece
(using readily available salvagable or makeable parts)

so trying to think of what kinds of "bits & bobs" i need, with my limited knowledge of tech,
i come up with springs gears pins and other simple things,

i maybe my problems is that i am trying to explain things, and just "making mountains" as they say

in simple terms ...relativley (just look who your dealing with here)

i want to use a ratcheting lever to build up energy
[part name] to store energy
apply that energy to make 2 wheels spin opposite of each other
and use the spinning of the wheels to impart/exert [term] upon and object

You could use a come-along to ratchet/lift a heavy weight up a few feet, and then release the weight to pull down on a cable that spins your wheels. That might do what you want...

http://www.erasmatazz.com/Personal/WeirdProjects/Gateway/files/comealong.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
a come-along might work...

pull on a spring, disengage ratchet stopper... i think its called a catch?

can use sprockets on wheels instead, put them close enough together
so a bike chain can be pulled between them

would function similar enough to what i was thinking

would be "instantaineous" or "burst" release of energy though

if i could just figure out how to get a prolonged reaction
in berkeman's example, that's solved by travel time of the weight, if I am thinking right

but for my use, i want to keep small scale, as to make a hand-held device

i had an idea, but ruled it out once i realized how it worked... (garage door spring)

new thought,
maybe i can negate the need for a prolonged reaction
if said object is already in contact with the wheels,

which raises the question again, (admitedly i worded it bad)

in a scenario of a pitching machine, is it the velocity (speed) of the tire rotation
or the amount of force used make the tires spin,
that is the power behind the pitch?

in otherwords, do i have to get the wheels spinning "at speed" first
or does the "instant" release of energy of a spring take care of that
 
Last edited:
You didn't do the reading assignment that I gave you. Bad on you.

Please do the reading on energy and moment of inertia. That will answer your questions. If you have specific questions about those readings, post them here with links to the articles.
 
  • #10
ow, my brain hurts,

i had an easier time reading "the republic" by plato (gave up on that rather quick)

all i see is math written in symbols (the equations) and the little bit trying to explain what it means
by using the equation, most of it is going over my head (i did legitimatly try)
so far all i really understand among all that is

the potential of a spring is proprtional to how much its stretch/compressed
and if force is applied to something, it moves (with equivalent force)

lets see if i can guess at it,

in my situation, the force applied is equal the tension on the spring

wheel spin is, propotional? to the force,
velocity imparted would be proportionate to how fast the wheels spin
ie put a speedometer on the wheel and that would tell me how fast the object would travel if the objects mass?
was the same

so force for calculating spin
but for the work potential of the object wheel spin = velocity
its weight and velocity to calculate impact strength

so, all my confussion was cause i had it backwards in tring to figure force to impact
instead of force to spin, spin to object, velocity x? weight = impact force

and as far as object simply causing the wheels to stop
is a matter of having just enough contact pressure for the wheels to "grab"

would i be better off with something where i squeeze/pump a trigger causing the wheels to spin
 
Last edited:
  • #11
I would probably just use a hand crank through a gear box to spin up the wheels...
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K