- #1
- 24,775
- 792
QG status paper---explication only thread
If you wish to critique or challenge the Rovelli paper about current QG status, please start your own separate thread to do that.
It is a short paper with a lot in it and it need first of all to be EXPLICATED which means paraphrased and unpacked--the way you do a suitcase---to see what is in it.
French kids learn this in school called "explication de texte" and you should really do it with everything before you start criticising and arguing---make a detailed paraphrase of the main points and assemble some references to other work.
So this is a FRIENDLY INTERPRETATION and paraphrase thread. And if you have critique/challenge type stuff that is material for another thread---please start one, as controversy will surely prove useful.
==============
OK, so I will start quietly unpacking the paper, which is
Unfinished Revolution
Carlo Rovelli
http://arxiv.org/gr-qc/0604045
If you wish to critique or challenge the Rovelli paper about current QG status, please start your own separate thread to do that.
It is a short paper with a lot in it and it need first of all to be EXPLICATED which means paraphrased and unpacked--the way you do a suitcase---to see what is in it.
French kids learn this in school called "explication de texte" and you should really do it with everything before you start criticising and arguing---make a detailed paraphrase of the main points and assemble some references to other work.
So this is a FRIENDLY INTERPRETATION and paraphrase thread. And if you have critique/challenge type stuff that is material for another thread---please start one, as controversy will surely prove useful.
==============
OK, so I will start quietly unpacking the paper, which is
Unfinished Revolution
Carlo Rovelli
http://arxiv.org/gr-qc/0604045
Last edited by a moderator: