Quantum jitter vs thermal jitter

In summary, Susskind explains that quantum jitters do not cause pain because there is no way to borrow energy from the ground state. However, quantum jitters can be partly thermal and the state of the system can be described as a mixed thermal state proportional to ##e^{-\beta H}##, where ##H## is the Hamiltonian. There is no textbook that describes a state with its two parts as thermal and non-thermal, but rather as mixed-state and pure-state fluctuations. The evolution of pure states is described by Schrodinger equation, while a generalization to mixed states can be approximated by the Lindblad equation.
  • #1
naima
Gold Member
938
54
In this book Susskind writes that if thermal jitter can burn our nerves, quantum jitter cannot. He explains why:
"Even though quantum jitters can be incredibly energetic, they cause no pain. Why? there is no way to borrow energy from the ground state. And quantum jitter is what is left over when the system is in its absolute minimum ground state."

I used to think that quantum fluctuations exist for all states. Could anyone elaborate this point?
Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
naima said:
I used to think that quantum fluctuations exist for all states. Could anyone elaborate this point?
You are right, quantum fluctuations exist for all states. But for non-ground states there may be additional (e.g. thermal) fluctuations as well.
 
  • #3
Can a quantum jitter be partly thermal? Is it a yes/no property and how to define when a quantum jitter is thermal?
 
  • #4
naima said:
Can a quantum jitter be partly thermal? Is it a yes/no property and how to define when a quantum jitter is thermal?
Yes, a quantum jitter can be partly thermal. In this case the state of the system is a mixed thermal state proportional to ##e^{-\beta H}##,
where ##H## is the Hamiltonian.
 
  • Like
Likes naima
  • #5
So with a complex ##\beta## we should factorize the state in a thermal and a non thermal part?
 
  • #6
Is there a textbook in which a state is described with its two parts (thermal and non thermal)? Is there a generalized Schrodinger equation?
 
  • #8
naima said:
So with a complex ##\beta## we should factorize the state in a thermal and a non thermal part?
No.
 
  • #9
naima said:
Is there a textbook in which a state is described with its two parts (thermal and non thermal)? Is there a generalized Schrodinger equation?
I would not talk about thermal and non-thermal fluctuations. I would talk about mixed-state and pure-state fluctuations. Thermal fluctuations are nothing but a very special case of mixed-state fluctuations. Evolution of pure states is described by Schrodinger equation. A generalization to mixed states is not so simple, so let me just say that one approximate approach is based on the Lindblad equation.
 
  • Like
Likes naima

What is quantum jitter?

Quantum jitter is the random fluctuations in a quantum system, caused by the uncertainty principle. It is the inherent uncertainty in the position, momentum, and energy of particles at the quantum level.

What is thermal jitter?

Thermal jitter is the random motion of particles at the macroscopic level, caused by thermal energy. It is the result of the constant movement of particles due to their kinetic energy.

What is the difference between quantum jitter and thermal jitter?

The main difference between quantum jitter and thermal jitter is the scale at which they occur. Quantum jitter is at the subatomic level, while thermal jitter is at the macroscopic level. Additionally, quantum jitter is caused by the uncertainty principle, while thermal jitter is caused by thermal energy.

How do quantum jitter and thermal jitter affect systems?

Quantum jitter can affect the accuracy and precision of measurements in quantum systems, as it introduces uncertainty into the position, momentum, and energy of particles. Thermal jitter can cause objects to vibrate or move randomly, which can affect the stability and performance of systems.

Can quantum jitter and thermal jitter be controlled or eliminated?

Quantum jitter is an inherent property of quantum systems and cannot be completely eliminated. However, it can be minimized through careful experimental design and the use of techniques such as quantum error correction. Thermal jitter can be reduced by controlling the temperature and minimizing external vibrations in a system.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
967
Replies
46
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
45
Views
10K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
25
Views
1K
Back
Top