Evanish
- 120
- 10
I was wondering if I was holding a handful of ordinary dirt would there likely be some amount of every naturally occurring element in it?
The discussion revolves around the composition of ordinary dirt and whether it contains every naturally occurring element. Participants explore the presence and detection of various elements, including rare and transient ones, in a handful of soil.
Participants generally agree that many elements may be present in dirt, but there is disagreement regarding the presence of specific elements like helium and astatine, with some asserting their absence while others provide reasoning for their potential presence.
The discussion includes assumptions about the detection limits of analytical methods and the rarity of certain elements, which may affect the conclusions drawn about their presence in dirt.
I thought that might be the case, but I wasn't sure. Thanks for the conformation.Borek said:Quite likely, although many of them can be present in amounts that are way below detection limits of our best analytical methods.
DrJohnSmith said:I could believe there isn't a single atom of Helium