Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around recommendations for currently under-appreciated films, with participants sharing personal favorites and insights into various movies. The scope includes classic films, animated features, and documentaries, with a focus on their artistic and emotional impact.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant recommends "Paths of Glory," highlighting its ethical dilemmas and dramatic tension.
- Another suggests "The Duelists," noting its beautiful photography and historical context.
- “Samurai I, II, & III” is praised for its cultural significance and epic storytelling.
- “Gettysburg” is described as a detailed recreation of a historical battle, featuring notable performances.
- “The Nightmare Before Christmas” is recognized for its creativity and depth, with a focus on its music and animation.
- “The Civil War” is mentioned as a significant documentary, with a participant questioning its association with Shelby Foote's writings.
- “Beauty and the Beast” by Jean Cocteau is noted for its unique sense of mystery and fantasy.
- Henry Fonda's filmography is suggested for its intense dramatic roles, with a participant listing several notable films.
- “The Potemkin” is highlighted for its gripping portrayal of a historical event during the Russian Revolution.
- Buster Keaton's works are celebrated for their physical humor and innovative stunts.
- Another participant recommends "Fantastic Planet" and "The Triplets of Belleville" for their unique animated perspectives on humanity.
- Classic holiday films like "The Bishop's Wife," "National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation," and "It's a Wonderful Life" are suggested for their heartwarming stories.
- “Heaven Can Wait” is mentioned as a successful remake that combines humor and emotional depth.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying opinions on what constitutes under-appreciated films, with some questioning the inclusion of certain titles based on their popularity. There is no consensus on the definition of under-appreciated, and multiple viewpoints are presented regarding the films mentioned.
Contextual Notes
Some participants clarify the relationship between Shelby Foote's writings and Ken Burns' documentary, indicating potential confusion about the source material. The discussion reflects differing perceptions of film appreciation among the general public versus film enthusiasts.