Reformulation of Loop gravity in progress, comment?

  • Thread starter Thread starter marcus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Gravity Loop
  • #201
Abstracts have been posted for some of the Loops 2013 talks. In other cases a guess is offered as to the possible topic.

First, here are the talks for which abstracts are already posted:

Carlo Rovelli, Centre de Physique Théorique, overview What have we learned so far about quantum gravity?*
Aurelien Barrau, Universite Joseph Fourier, LQC observational consequences incl. adequate inflation*
Dafne Guetta, Braude College, LQG observational constraints Phenomenology with Neutrinos and high energy photons.*
Madhavan Varadarajan, Raman Research Institute, towards completing canonical LQG*
Abhay Ashtekar, Penn State, outlook. Promising paths for future research*.

*For the abstracts see menu at bottom of http://www.perimeterinstitute.ca/conferences/loops-13

And here are other listed speakers, with some guesses as to topic:
Ivan Agullo, DAMPT Cambridge, LQC bounce cosmology incl. pre-inflation.
Eugenio Bianchi, Perimeter Institute, LQG black hole thermodynamics
Steve Carlip, UC Davis, TBA
Fay Dowker, Imperial College London, causal sets
Henrique Gomes, UC Davis, shape dynamics
Razvan Gurau, Université Paris-Sud, tensor models
Frank Hellmann, MPI for Gravitational Physics Potsdam, holonomy spinfoams
Viqar Husain, University of New Brunswick, computable LQG framework
Kirill Krasnov, University of Nottingham, pure connection gravity
Etera Livine, Ens de Lyon, several possibilities including spinorial LQG
Alejandro Perez, Centre de Physique Theorique, several including loop BH thermodynamics
Vincent Rivasseau, Universite Paris-Sud Orsay, tensor models
David Skinner, DAMPT Cambridge+IAS, N=8 supergravity?
Bill Unruh, University of British Columbia, analog models of QG?Notes:
Krasnov recent pure connection formulation, http://arxiv.org/abs/1304.6946
Etera Livine recent spinorial LQG, http://arxiv.org/abs/1302.7142
Husain computable LQG framework,http://arxiv.org/abs/1305.5203
Varadarajan recent papers progress towards completing canonical LQG: e.g. http://arxiv.org/abs/1210.6877 http://pirsa.org/13040104/
The project of completing LQG Hamiltonian dynamics could also be called "closing the quantum constraint algebra". This corresponds classically to the hypersurface deformation algebra, which closes in GR. The snag which the Hamiltonian approach hit in the late 1990s seems essentially to have been that the quantum operator version of HD algebra did not close off shell. Dittrich and Bonzom have a paper about the HD algebra.
Alesci et al have also made recent progress towards completing LQG Hamiltonian dynamics. http://arxiv.org/abs/1306.0861

Reminders to myself:
cosmology/observational tests
black holes and thermodynamics
causal sets
shape dynamics
tensor models
holonomy spinfoams
spinorial LQG
spin nets (simpler analogs of spin foams using finite group instead of full SU(2) )
closing constraint algebra

Some things I don't see listed:
Marcolli Suijlekom (beautiful work on "gauge networks": graphs labeled with chunks of spectral geometry)
Freidel Hnybida (new basis for the intertwiners http://arxiv.org/abs/1305.3326)
Daniele Pranzetti (broad synthesis of ideas from Connes Rovelli Perez Bianchi Wieland and others. http://arxiv.org/abs/1305.6714 But I think his work may be covered in survey by Alejandro Perez with whom he has co-authored.)
Bianca Dittrich (http://arxiv.org/abs/1306.2987 "Coarse graining of spin net models: dynamics of intertwiners")

The intertwiners are the "atoms" of spatial geometry in both canonical LQG and Spinfoams.
Marcolli Suijlekom also has intertwiners at the nodes but based on spectral triples of NCG
The spin nets that Dittrich et al use are simplified (e.g. finite group) analogs of spin foams not meant to replace them but to facilitate progress understanding them. Dittrich is one of the conference organizers. I don't know what conference etiquette requires. The research on spin nets as "toy version" spinfoams seems potentially important and appropriate for plenary session. Maybe Dittrich can hand it off to one of her co-authors.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #202
Talks given at a major conference can give an idea of what areas are active in LQG research. My main focus has been to identify themes emerging as important at Loops 2013 that runs 22-26 July at Perimeter. That's what the preceding post is about. However in a couple of weeks we also have a Loops session of the Warsaw GR20 conference coming up as a kind of opener for the main conference.
Here's a list of 36 talks scheduled for Session D1, organized/chaired by Dittrich and Pawlowski. You can see many of the same lines of investigation as appeared in the Perimeter conference lineup:

Dr. Ivan Agullo A quantum gravity extension of the inflationary scenario
Dr. Emanuele Alesci Quantum Reduced Loop Gravity
Prof. Abhay Ashtekar Loop Quantum Cosmology: Fundamentals and Phenomenology
Mehdi Assanioussi A quantum Ricci operator for LQG
Dr. Fernando Barbero Geometric Constraint algorithm for field theories with boundaries.
Dr. Eugenio Bianchi Black hole entropy and entanglement in spinfoam gravity
Dr. Francesco Cianfrani Introduction to Quantum Reduced Loop Gravity for cosmology
MSc. Andrea Dapor QFT on quantum spacetime
Dr. Jonathan Engle Quantum isotropy and dynamical quantum symmetry reduction
Mikel Fernández-Méndez An Inflationary Model in Loop Quantum Cosmology
Dr. Ernesto Frodden On the Quasilocal First Law for Isolated Horizon and its uses in the Euclidean Partition Function
Prof. Kristina Giesel Scalar Material Reference Systems and Loop Quantum Gravity
Brajesh Gupt Quantum gravitational inflationary scenario in Bianchi-I spacetime
Brajesh Gupt Chimera: A hybrid numerical scheme for isotropic loop quantum cosmology
Dr. Hal Haggard Pentahedral volume, chaos, and quantum gravity
Prof. Viqar Husain Time and a physical hamiltonian for quantum gravity
Dr. Wojciech Kaminski Curvature constraints in spin foam models
MSc. Marcin Kisielowski The Dipole Cosmology transition amplitude: first-order contributions
Dr. Tim Koslowski Shape Dynamics and Quantum Gravity
Linda Linsefors Duration of inflation as a prediction of effective LQC
Prof. Yongge Ma Connection dynamics of a gauge theory of gravity coupled with matter
Abhishek Majhi Microcanonical Entropy of Isolated Horizon and fixation of the Barbero-Immirzi parameter
Seth Major On Loop Quantization of Plane Gravitational Waves
Dr. Jakub Mielczarek Asymptotic silence in quantum gravity
MSc. Edison Montoya Qualitative Effective Dynamics in Bianchi IX Loop Quantum Cosmology
MSc. Jacek Puchta Asymptotic behaviour of lorentzian polyhedra propagator
Prof. Jorge Pullin Complete quantization of vacuum spherically symmetric gravity
Dr. li qin Coherent state functional integrals in quantum cosmology
Dr. Saeed Rastgoo An analysis of the CGHS model in new variables
Prof. Carlo Rovelli Radiative corrections in covariant Loop Quantum Gravity
Jędrzej Świeżewski Construction of Dirac observables for General Relativity with the use of geometry
MSc. Sara Tavares Observables in two-dimensional BF theory
Madhavan Varadarajan Anomaly free constraint algebra for a weak coupling limit of gravity
Dr. jingbo wang The entropy of BTZ black hole from loop quantum gravity
MSc. Wolfgang Wieland Hamiltonian Spinfoam Gravity
Antonia Zipfel On the relation between canonical and covariant Quantum Gravity
========================
List of parallel sessions:
http://gr20-amaldi10.edu.pl/index.php?id=18
List of talks in each parallel session:
http://gr20-amaldi10.edu.pl/index.php?id=32
Loop folk have branched out and besides session D1 (their main session) are also giving talks in sessions A3, A4, D3, D4, and the special joint session D1+2+4
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #203
Gravi-weak unification at ILQGS (online talk by Marciano)

Loop gravity is making a strong showing at Warsaw G20. This is a conference with over 900 registered participants covering many types of research: gravity wave, dark matter search, numerical GR, observational cosmology, and of course quantum gravity. The public lecture this time will be given by Carlo Rovelli and will be about major questions and developments in QG. Loop folks have gotten into a bunch of other sessions besides their main one D1. They are also giving talks in A3, A4, D3, D4, and a joint session on BH evaporation (e.g. the "firewall" issue) that brings together people from D1+D2+D4 (loop+string+QFTcurvedspacetime...). I will try to identify the themes emerging from just the talks in session D1.
Here's a list of 36 talks scheduled for Session D1.
3 I see engaged in joining LQC and LQG, and
3 focused on BH thermodynamics.
5 talks can be expected to focus on the LQC bounce and inflation. The bounce turns out to be a straightforward model ensuring sufficient inflation (without resort to fine-tunes and multiverses).
7 I see as focused on completing the program--getting a real Hamiltonian, combining the canonical and spinfoam approaches, showing convergence and wellness of definition. This seems to be a time when a lot of people are making progress on that.

Dr. Ivan Agullo A quantum gravity extension of the inflationary scenario bounce inflation
Dr. Emanuele Alesci Quantum Reduced Loop Gravity join LQC to LQG
Prof. Abhay Ashtekar Loop Quantum Cosmology: Fundamentals and Phenomenology bounce inflation + testing + overview
Mehdi Assanioussi A quantum Ricci operator for LQG
Dr. Fernando Barbero Geometric Constraint algorithm for field theories with boundaries.
Dr. Eugenio Bianchi Black hole entropy and entanglement in spinfoam gravity BH thermo
Dr. Francesco Cianfrani Introduction to Quantum Reduced Loop Gravity for cosmology join LQC to LQG
MSc. Andrea Dapor QFT on quantum spacetime completing the program, with matter
Dr. Jonathan Engle Quantum isotropy and dynamical quantum symmetry reduction join LQC to LQG
Mikel Fernández-Méndez An Inflationary Model in Loop Quantum Cosmology bounce inflation
Dr. Ernesto Frodden On the Quasilocal First Law for Isolated Horizon and its uses in the Euclidean Partition Function BH thermo
Prof. Kristina Giesel Scalar Material Reference Systems and Loop Quantum Gravity complete the program with dust
Brajesh Gupt Quantum gravitational inflationary scenario in Bianchi-I spacetime bounce inflation
Brajesh Gupt Chimera: A hybrid numerical scheme for isotropic loop quantum cosmology
Dr. Hal Haggard Pentahedral volume, chaos, and quantum gravity validation
Prof. Viqar Husain Time and a physical hamiltonian for quantum gravity completing the program, with dust
Dr. Wojciech Kaminski Curvature constraints in spin foam models
MSc. Marcin Kisielowski The Dipole Cosmology transition amplitude: first-order contributions
Dr. Tim Koslowski Shape Dynamics and Quantum Gravity
Linda Linsefors Duration of inflation as a prediction of effective LQC bounce inflation, no multiverse, coauthor Barrau
Prof. Yongge Ma Connection dynamics of a gauge theory of gravity coupled with matter
Abhishek Majhi Microcanonical Entropy of Isolated Horizon and fixation of the Barbero-Immirzi parameter BH thermo
Seth Major On Loop Quantization of Plane Gravitational Waves
Dr. Jakub Mielczarek Asymptotic silence in quantum gravity
MSc. Edison Montoya Qualitative Effective Dynamics in Bianchi IX Loop Quantum Cosmology
MSc. Jacek Puchta Asymptotic behaviour of lorentzian polyhedra propagator
Prof. Jorge Pullin Complete quantization of vacuum spherically symmetric gravity
Dr. Li Qin Coherent state functional integrals in quantum cosmology
Dr. Saeed Rastgoo An analysis of the CGHS model in new variables
Prof. Carlo Rovelli Radiative corrections in covariant Loop Quantum Gravity completing the program
Jędrzej Świeżewski Construction of Dirac observables for General Relativity with the use of geometry
MSc. Sara Tavares Observables in two-dimensional BF theory
Madhavan Varadarajan Anomaly free constraint algebra for a weak coupling limit of gravity completing the program
Dr. Jingbo Wang The entropy of BTZ black hole from loop quantum gravity BH thermo
MSc. Wolfgang Wieland Hamiltonian Spinfoam Gravity completing the program
Antonia Zipfel On the relation between canonical and covariant Quantum Gravity completing the program, co-author Alesci
========================
List of parallel sessions:
http://gr20-amaldi10.edu.pl/index.php?id=18
List of talks in each parallel session:
http://gr20-amaldi10.edu.pl/index.php?id=32
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

Back
Top